(this is page 112 of 121)





Latest

Feed me Seymour

Mike Arrington has a nice writeup of Dave Winer's new project, "Share Your OPML" which covers a really neat experiment in collecting what I think is invaluable profile data on RSS-powered people. OPML is the XML-format most commonly used by RSS aggregators to export a list of subscriptions in a single file. Though the format could be a lot richer (capturing metadata about items read, for example), it is good enough to get a real feeling for the type of subjects that a particular person is motivated enough to track. In fact, a relatively rich OPML file (>50 feeds) is so good at telling you about its owner that I now find myself asking for an OPML export as part of the interview process during hiring for any position, and find it to be (when available) at least as good as the candidate's resume.

That said, herein lies my concern with the viability of Share Your OPML: the system appears to have no inbuilt way of encouraging users to take the trouble to upload this type of valuable metadata in the first place. Though it is early still, I think this is why the data extracted from the OPML files collected reveals a blogging A-list distribution in the various aggregated stats (these are after all Dave's friends and fans who have the necessary incentive at this point). Arrington suggests that it will be cool to have "better recommendations," using the classic collaborative filter model, but this still is not good enough for me to have the system slurp my data, at least not until I've seen it work its magic with other people's data, and even then it's unclear that the collaborative filter could bring enough value by itself).

It strikes me though that there is more low hanging fruit in terms of encouraging active participation (and upload). Share Your OPML could quickly become a sort of delicious for feed lists if it grows a simple API quickly. Fortunately, this is something that Dave Winer has proven very adept at in the past, so I would find it hard to believe that he is not already about to release it. In the meanwhile, it's worth checking out what this neat experiment will bring.

Comments Permalink

Since there was all this hoopla about how MSN Spaces has crossed 100M spaces, I decided to go back and take a look at what has transpired there in the year and a half since I first signed up... and I was dissapointed. The site feels a lot snappier (which must mean that Microsoft has figured out how to scale .NET) but features-wise, MSN Spaces feels like a MySpace rev 1.1 and not much more.

Not that Yahoo 360 is much better. Both of these tools suffer from the same thing: they have a number of "widgets" but each of the widgets is far from being anywhere close to best-in-class. Blog widget? Blogger is still much better. Pictures? What's being offered on both of these properties at this point in terms of photos smells of Geocities circa 1999 (Y360's flickr integration being the only exception). Ditto for music, lists, profiles, and (where available) free-form pages.

My point isn't really that these big companies can't execute on the vision of a general-purpose personal publishing platform– but that they seem to be stuck with this bad hypothesis that an integrated set of mediocre tools is more valuable than just one or two really kick-ass components. It's the 1980s office suite mentality or the 1990s portal approach all over again. Except that today we're supposed to be living in the era of Web 2.0 where the Internet is the common substrate for IPC and best-of-breed tools should be integrated and remixed to provide one great service as opposed to just another "me too" in the blogs/photos/lists/social network soup.

Finally, what really gets me is that these guys: Microsoft, Yahoo, Google, and to a lesser extent AOL are the platform players which means that if anyone could really take a leadership role in this new way of building things, it is them. Google did it with maps (and the others have quickly followed) by providing a great, best-of-breed component that was easy to integrate just about anywhere and then letting a thousand flowers bloom. With a couple of more world-class components like these, Google may find itself much more able to do the "platform thing" than these ho-hum integrated attempts– and if they do these 100M spaces are going to end up nothing more than ghost towns left behind by the goldrush that MySpace started.

Comments Permalink

I don't usually get excited by the happenings in the iPod ecosystem but Apple's new collaboration with Nike is really cool. The plan is to build an RF pedometer that can feed telemetry to the iPod via an attached wireless receiver. As anyone who runs a lot can tell you, this is a very nice thing indeed.

But it also shows the kind of power and platform lock-in that Apple has gotten with the iPod. When people talk about that, it is usually in reference to Apple's music store and its proprietary DRM which is currently definitely a form of lock-in, but ultimately one that can't last. However, the lock-in that comes from the fact that the iPod is the only constantly semi network-connected portable device (on an open network, unlike the cellphones) might just last for quite a while, or at least until we finally get to the promise of cheap-enough networking for regular everyday devices (and that seems to be one of those classic situations where everyone is confusing a long view with a short distance).

As you get more digital music, the incentive exists to constantly be syncing your iPod to your PC to refresh your portable library. The podcasting folks saw this as an opportunity to push new content to the device for a sort of "time-shifted radio" experience, and they were right on. That said, no one is properly leveraging the back-channel yet (moving data from the iPod to the network) mostly because the software is not rich enough on the iPod to capture any data worth sending back (playcount and song ratings being the only exceptions).

But with this Nike collaboration, the possibilities are much richer due to the fact that the iPod is going to be collecting all sorts of data about your activity. And by the way, Nike is not just now waking up to this idea; for a while they (and others) have had non-networked devices that do this, and even associated websites for runners to compete on stats in virtual races. The problem has always been that the cost of participation has been too high both because those other companies were not software companies (remember the first Audible player software anyone?), and because it was just too much hassle for most people to spend all that time connecting a device just this purpose.

However if I am already going to be connecting the device to sync my music, the cost of of getting on the network is in effect subsidized by music listening desires, and everything else gets to ride along for free. One thing Steve and co. are well aware of is just how passionate people are about their music, and it wouldn't surprise me at all if this Nike thing is just the first step to truly leverage the iPod ecosystem in interesting ways (beyond colored socks and compact speakers) that point us in the direction of the world of networked devices.

I can't wait for people to start hacking on those data feeds to do more than whatever the Flash-encrusted Nike site will do. Recently I read a blog post (which I can not for the life of me find) about how the real reason Apple dropped PortalPlayer was because they were beefing up the hardware to run a scaled-down version of OS X on the devices. This is probably a complete fantasy, but how nice would it be to have a device that is that more general purpose (read: programmable), talking on an open network to services and perhaps sporadically even to other devices being synced by others?

Comments Permalink

So we've officially launched the public beta for Tabblo amidst two storms. The first one was the state of emergency declared by the state of Massachusetts due to the flooding that has been brought about by the interminable rain here in the Bay State. The second storm is taking place in the blogosphere over Josh Kopelman's post on the value of the 53,651 geeks who read TechCrunch and jump from beta to beta as all of these Web 2.0 companies launch. Josh's argument is classic Crossing the Chasm: these users, being on the leading edge do not translate to meaningful traction in the mass market. Dave Winer takes issue and points to how valuable these early users can be, and I tend to agree (for a nice summary of the debate, see Om's post).

Probably only about 10% of those 50K users are passionate enough to qualify for what I am about to argue but the number is large enough. In the social software space (in which I would include virtually every webapp out there), software without lots of users of early users will necessarily be worse than software with early and passionate users. Take for example del.icio.us and Furl: when they started, Furl was actually quite a bit more usable but del.icio.us managed to resonate with some of the early adopter crowd relatively early and within a year there was no comparison between the sites.

The argument has also been made that this early crowd is just too different and distracting from the bread-and-butter folks who make up the "mass market" but I don't buy that for two reasons that both center on this vague notion of the "mass market." These are people too, right? People who get out there and use MySpace or Gmail, or send TXTs to American Idol once a week. How then can we assume that because they haven't heard of digg, or del.icio.us, they wouldn't grok it right away if they did? The second point is simply this: if as a startup you have good product management on board, it's just not that hard to keep two lists: the features that the really important people who are helping co-develop your product want and get excited about, and the features that the fast-followers and "mass market" types want. I all about laser focus in startups, but it seems to me that if there is one place where it pays to keep your ear to the ground and be willing to experiment, it is in early user co-development of your service.

Speaking selfishly from Tabblo's perspective, I welcome every one of those 53,651 power users into our public beta even if you want to pick up your stakes and move on to whatever the hot launch is next week. There are worse problems than having a bunch of smart, well-immersed folks tread all over you for the opportunity to capture the hearts and minds of just a few of them. As Scoble writes, "one snowflake at a time."

Comments Permalink

So it would seem that Valleywag has outed Tabblo 10 days ahead of launch, and with somewhat good reason, blasted us for a less-than-perfectly thought-out press outreach. It's actually a fairly snarky and funny post that makes two points: first, does the world need yet another photo-sharing site (YAPS)? and second, just why would we, in a world where there are no secrets just information waiting to be discovered, try such a lame strategy for building up to our launch?

First, I would most definitely agree with Valleywag that the world most definitely does not need another photo-sharing site if by photo-sharing site what people mean is another copy of Flickr or a slightly updated version of the Generation-1 photo sites: OFoto, Shutterfly, and Snapfish. Our basic premise in starting Tabblo was that there was a functionality gap in the things one could easily do with photos online; that while Flickr defined a new mode of behavior around the photo stream constantly flowing past a community of interested users, there are still times when what one wants to do is put a bunch of photos in a context which helps to paint a picture, tell a story, or capture something particular about the subject of the photos.

If you think about it from that perspective, what you end up wanting as a user is a more of a general purpose publishing tool that lets you work with layout, text, styling elements, and pictures. You can conceive of it as a special-purpose Dreamweaver, or even more like Apple's new iWeb app, but 100% in the browser, paired with a web service, built to solve some of the collaborative problems presented by multiple photographers at the same event, and aimed at hiding the complexity of basic design, technical details, and most of all, the high threshold for participation that creative tools like Quark, InDesign, and even Dreamweaver have put in the path of regular folks.

Why go through all this trouble instead of just assuming that what people want is basic gallery-style or Flickr-style gobs of pictures with a slideshow option for viewing? Two reasons: one, when given a creative communications tool for self-expression, people show again and again an almost unlimited amount of creativity in what they do. And second, and to Valleywag snark about YAPS, we at Tabblo are most excited about competing not with Flickr, Smugmug, Yahoo Photos, and two dozen other new entrants, but with non-consumption. That is, if you look at the numbers, by far the biggest photo-sharing service out there is still email. For the most part, people find that what is out there does not add enough value to merit being used instead of just attaching a bunch of pictures to an email and hitting send (and this is despite all of the associated mailserver hell).

So, on to the second point: is it lame to send out a generic email to press that uses words like embargo, best reserved for dealing with naughty regimes? Probably, and David Parmet helped to take us to task for it. Here is our only excuse: when you are just seven people working around the clock to get a product launched, sometimes things can fall through the cracks. In the end, I'm pretty sure that our users will prefer that their credit cards get charged correctly, that their tabblos not get lost, and that the site is snappy enough. Meanwhile consider this whoops a bit of slop that we're going to work very hard to avoid in the future.

To that end, let me give you a scoop here: in a couple of days a press release is going to go out announcing a major funding event on the part of a tier-1 venture fund (Matrix Partners) who is as excited about the space and opportunity as we are. Along with the press release (as we should have done before), I'm going to write a post here describing why we went to Matrix and why they are excited about the investment.

One final thing: I'm actually glad to have made Valleywag– it might even be seen as a sort of badge of honor (though next time please use incriminating pictures of me ordering coffee behind one of those Google babes– this will make for better copy)– but I am not psyched that Kerry got singled-out for this by name. For the record, Kerry was largely responsible for why I choose Red Javelin in the first place; she's worked for some really clued-in web-native companies like Viaweb and TripAdvisor and her former clients rave about her. She is incredibly open, thoughtful, and happy to take comments and answer any questions you may have about Tabblo at: kerry@redjavelin.com. And, by the way, so am I: antonio@tabblo.com.

Comments Permalink