(this is page 113 of 121)





Latest

If it had been April Fool's day, I would have assumed that today's big New York Times/Microsoft announcement of some type of eReader software to replicate the look and feel of the print newspaper on your laptop/tablet was a joke. How could two big companies filled with clued-in people think that this was worth doing at all?

Jeff Jarvis beat me to the punch with his assessment of why this is being done (basically either out of ego or to try and pull a fast one on advertisers) so I am not going to belabor it. But it does seem fitting that this should happen this week, the same week that Smilebox launched its product with a bunch of the same underlying assumptions baked into it about how people want to consume their digital media online.

For those that don't know Smilebox is a "new way to share photos" online according to this week's WSJ Personal Technology column. I do not know them personally but from what I have heard, they are a bunch of smart ex-Microsoft guys who've built a Flash-based downloadable tool to easily compose montages of your photos and canned soundtracks which are then turned into Flash movies that can be shared. After reading the Journal piece I decided to give the app a try despite my general distaste for semi-canned Flash movies and was generally pleased with the results. In a few minutes I was able to create a couple of compelling slideshows with a cool "carousel" effect that feels almost as though it belongs in an online game world.

However, I was amazed at how far into the interface you had to dig to get at this particular type of output mostly because it was buried between "photo book" and "scrapbook" (don't ask me the difference) and a zillion template elements that all mimic the real world of glitter, deckled photo edges, paper, scissors and glue but for 100% online output. Now there are probably a lot of people that will spend hours creating these virtual books whose pages really do "turn" on-screen and whose photos appear pasted in, but as I looked at the options, all I could think of was: boy this feels like using a buggywhip as a steering wheel.

The web is a really cool new medium; it introduces a fundamentally new primitive (the hyperlink) and a whole bunch of formats that are optimized around computer displays and spotty bandwidth. Scrolling is now second nature to anyone who uses the Internet as is clicking a link, using the back button, and a whole host of other actions that don't quite have analogs in the UIs built around aping the real world objects. After all, the real genius of the Mac interface was not in putting a trash can on the Desktop but in making it behave in expected ways given the new medium of the bitmap display (imagine having to "open" the trash can every time you wanted to delete a document).

So maybe the folks at the New York Times, Microsoft, and Smilebox know something I don't about the mental model of the typical web user today– maybe they are keenly aware of a latent desire to return to a familiar pre-computer world for interfacing with data.

I hope not though because at Tabblo we're taking a whole different approach: our soon-to-be-released 1.0 product currently has one kind of thing you build, a tabblo. We went so far as to name it something new, despite it being similar to an online gallery, a photo album, a slideshow, etc. because we want to cue our users to the fact that what they are creating is something that is not quite what they've been used to doing with their photos and text before. If we've done our job right it will fill the needs fulfilled by making scrapbooks and assembling photo albums in the physical world, but in the context of the web as a medium.

Of course this doesn't mean that we don't believe in the value of the objects being directly mimicked by the "real object" interface folks– after all I just came from a place where all we did was use software to make fancy paper-and-ink photo albums so I've seen first-hand how compelling these can be– it is just that I'm not sure that what is emotionally engaging about them carries over well in the atoms-to-bits transition.

Comments Permalink

The Economist (my absolute favorite) has a wonderful special report this week on "New Media" by Andreas Kluth that is absolutely worth its weight in dead trees. It is thorough, substantive, and manages to hit all the high notes while getting quotes and insight from all of the key players driving the transition into the era of Personal Media (Kluth calls it "personal or participatory media," however I like the word personal better because it has the same ring as Personal Computer).

The intro piece(if you read only one piece, read this one) starts with the now-venerable debate on quality versus quantity in content brought on by the new media explosion, framed between quotes from Barry Diller and my friend Jerry Michalski (who follows up on why he's not getting invited to Barry's next Christmas party) with a great blog post (and getting Jerry to put fingers to keyboard on his blog is about as hard as mating a flamingo with a plunger so kudos to the report for that as well). The quality-versus-quantity argument is almost not worth having at this point; we're all aware that on average an amateur is going to produce a less "finished" product (just compare this post to the depth and insight of the aforementioned survey). Like Jerry says in his follow up post, the wonderful thing about the new media explosion is just how much content is out there for us to consume.

Example: at the office everyone is obsessed with Lost which means that, despite the fact that it's gone steadily downhill during the second season, we all have to watch it. This week I found it especially funny that while putting up with a bad excuse for a new episode (hello, recap episodes went out with MacGuyver treading water for 60 minutes 20 years ago), I was able to surf from an email to YouTube and see a much more entertaining bit of video content. Now this 24 spoof is definitely much lower quality in terms of production value (it's not even that good), and it qualifies as what Steven Johnson calls parasitic content, but since I am a huge fan of 24 anyone who can pull off such a good Jack Bauer impersonation will get my attention.

The final thing I will say about the Economist report was how great it was to have David Weinberger (another Boston local) quoted as saying this new media thing was more of a social phenomenon than a publishing one. So true, and yet so often missed in all of the "blogs will take down the New York Times" articles that usually appear on paper.

It is about small audiences that find the content you produce as new media maker incredibly relevant- much more so than rehashed Lost episodes. And even if it takes 10 years to find the business models (assuming we even need to) it's great to be around during a time of so much choice is how we spend our time communicating, consuming, and even making, new media.

Comments Permalink

There is Accounting for Taste

I was very happy to see Martin Fowler rip XSLT a new one when talking about his use of it on his site not because it sucks but because XSLT was "the hot thing" for developers five years ago and has now become one of my favorite weed-out topics when interviewing new candidates. We usually get around to talking about supporting output for the web and I ask the age-old: how do you separate content from styling? And about 25% of candidates jump right into the XSLT hot water. Now of those, there are some who have just used it at work and when pushed will quickly get to the pain-in-the-ass that it is for doing anything more than simple transforms (and the overkill that it is for even those). And then there are the staunch defenders who are willing to go down in angle-bracket flames arguing for the "formality" and "performance" of XSL over simpler more elegant solutions.

I don't want to just knock XSLT given that I have never actually used it for any serious work (though I only know one good hacker who still uses it on his blog, and it's only because he's too lazy to dump it). Instead, I want to make a bigger point about taste and hackers, and I want to do it for self-serving reasons. If you're reading this because you're coming to a job interview at Tabblo, and you decided to see what Tabblo was about (and who the hell I was), you're probably inbound from Google. So let me help the self-selection process here along: when you show up, please do not check your taste at the door. We love people with clear and defined tastes, and believe that to work in the consumer internet you must have a sense of taste whether you're a QA guy, an infrastructure C hacker, or the person in charge of feeding Eddie.

A word for the hackers: fancy-pants computer science programs from places like my alma mater try to teach students that as a "computer scientist" you are supposed to be agnostic to your tools, and especially to the computer language du jour (LISP being the Great Exception). Somehow it gets ingrained in you that saying "oh it doesn't matter to me what language we use" makes you seem smarter. Not true. At worst it makes you like those other college intellectuals that talk fast, wear itchy-looking polyester pants two sizes too tight, and chain-smoke just to seem smarter, and at best you look like a hired gun.

So be ready to talk about your favorite languages, libraries, frameworks, typefaces, software apps, websites, and just about any other thing that helps us figure out who you are. And be ready to make your case. Because we do it all day every day with each other (it's a miracle we get anything else done). And remember, I'm still looking for that genius hacker who just loves XSLT and is ready to passionately argue for why it is the cat's meow.

Comments Permalink

Web browser as Platform

As the first high-profile rich browser app, Google Maps unleashed an explosion of creativity in pushing the web-browser-as-application-runtime. It gave birth to the term AJAX, put drag-and-drop on the list of approved cross-browser features, and seemed to lift the ban on imaginative ways to use Javascript and DOM manipulation to give users a much richer experience.

Proponents of the browser-as-platform have been around since Andresen's famous snub at Microsoft ten years ago ("Windows is gonna be reduced to a buggy bag of device drivers"), but in recently years people have noticed that some apps (i.e., webmail) are making a real run at replacing their desktop cousins.

But what if instead of working on a task-by-task basis, someone came out with a full-blown application runtime for the browser? I'm not sure I buy it, but I was reminded of it yesterday when I saw this Mac OS 7 emulation in the browser. Now it turns out that this is actually very painstakingly constructed Flash movie with a bunch of interactive dead-ends, but it nonetheless got my wheels spinning on what would be required to go further and provide a full OS environment in the frame of the web browser. Are there ways in which this would be more useful than the current stand-alone "rich" browser-based apps, i.e. Gmail, or Writely?

From an implementation point-of-view, I think that the pseudo OS in browser is finally really possible now. In the office, everyone is really tired of my constant touting of the recently open sourced Yahoo User Interface Library which I find to be as well thought-out and documented as any rich GUI library that I've seen. It would not take too much work to wrap something like Amazon's Simple Storage Service, and a few web service APIs for richer interop with "application islands" out there on the Internet (EBay, Google Maps, etc.), and you've got a really rich runtime at your hands.

This morning I saw a glimmer of this in the Y-Combinator backed YouOS. They've got an application installer, cross-application interop, an API for people looking to write new applications for YouOS, and even a set of primitive data structures that can support concurrent network access and be persisted on the server. I think these guys deserve a lot of credit for trying this, and the remarkable thing is that it works almost as well as an early Linux X-Windows window manager.

However, it's just a glimmer because no matter how far the richness of the browser has come, my rich client has gone further. Right now OS X 10.4 on Intel is finally snappy enough to be a first class GUI with a rich UNIX core and there ain't no web-based OS that can come close to that level of productivity.

But there may be a compromise. Apple (to continue the example) provides a hosted-data service called Dot-Mac which supports webmail, calendar, and basic web publishing as well as a very limited backup service for data and metadata. Over the years the web side of Dot-Mac has gotten richer and richer in terms of the functionality exposed. Why couldn't Apple go the whole way and create an AJAX version of their Display PDF engine and Cocoa framework, sync the list of your installed applications, and allow you to run an entire Desktop in the web browser? They've already got key data and metadata stored on the server, and they own the real OS APis that everyone is already programming to. For sure the web experience would be slower and crummier, but for occasional use it would be just fine.

To repeat it for the third time, I am not sure that this whole OS-in-the-web-browser is a better model than finely tuned webapps that use their own native medium better- in fact, if I had to bet on it coming from a startup like YouOS, I'd bet against it. But I do think that if someone could pull off a valuable use-case, it would have to be one of the rich client platform vendors (Microsoft or Apple). Dashboard Widgets was an interesting step in that direction from the rich client out (as was Konfabulator), but the big guys could do much more.

[ As an aside, it is too bad that the guy with enough skill, experience, and muscle to pull it off seems now to be distracted by the kind of cute web hack that should be left to the rest of us not in control of a major platform. ]

As I often think when I finish one of these posts, it's nice to see that we live in interesting times.

Comments Permalink

So Paul Graham finally got himself a blog which is a Very Good Thing (though he seems to be using a half-finished product to write it so its RSS feed is annoyingly borked).

Graham is a good essayist; in fact you could even call him a geek's Mark Twain. On his site he has a whole bunch of essays that range from just ok to absolutely great. The best ones are funny, insightful, and well written. Even the bad ones have a certain charm to them that makes them worth reading. What is clear from all of them though is that he puts in a good amount of time thinking, writing, and revising what he writes. Now that he has a blog, it is going to be interesting to see how the quality of the posts compares to the essays.

I can't decide if what I'd rather have from him is cleverness or perspective. His essays are clever, made even more so by the attention that he constantly pays to the power of analogy (i.e. "The atmosphere of the average workplace is to productivity what flames painted on the side of a car are to speed"), and I think that these clever twists are hard to just whip out while blogging– not because you can't come up with them but because you don't spend the time editing the bad ones out so that the good ones shine through.

At the same time, if Graham does embrace blogging seriously, it will be good to see his perspective applied to some of the memes that make their way across the blogosphere. Given how much time he spends crafting his essays, it is just impossible for him to take part in any of the distributed conversations that you can see at places like Memeonrandum.

To date everyone seems obsessed with comparing newspapers and blogs which I guess implies that the analog of the blog post is the newspaper article. To me, this comparison is not all that interesting though given how different the means of production are for both. The more interesting question as the blogosphere grows to consume more and more of the time that people used to spend producing essays, do the gains outweigh the losses?

A thought experiment: let's say Paul only has 25 hours/week to dedicate to the general "bucket" of writing. Assuming you are a Graham fan, would you prefer that he craft essays to be delivered one every two months or that he dive right in to the topic of the day with his own unique point of view? I'm not sure which I'd choose but I think following his blog for a few weeks will tell us a bit about the blog post as a format particularly when compared to its distant cousin the essay.

Comments Permalink