My goal with this blog

I write about relevant changes in the way that people use the web and how startups are built to provide services and products for this ever changing wonderful thing we still know as "the web." As a former entrepreneur turned early-stage investor, my greatest hope is for this to be useful to other folks that are like me in the hopes that they can avoid some of the mistakes I've made.

Platform Plays in the age of Personal Media

Since there was all this hoopla about how MSN Spaces has crossed 100M spaces, I decided to go back and take a look at what has transpired there in the year and a half since I first signed up... and I was dissapointed. The site feels a lot snappier (which must mean that Microsoft has figured out how to scale .NET) but features-wise, MSN Spaces feels like a MySpace rev 1.1 and not much more.

Not that Yahoo 360 is much better. Both of these tools suffer from the same thing: they have a number of "widgets" but each of the widgets is far from being anywhere close to best-in-class. Blog widget? Blogger is still much better. Pictures? What's being offered on both of these properties at this point in terms of photos smells of Geocities circa 1999 (Y360's flickr integration being the only exception). Ditto for music, lists, profiles, and (where available) free-form pages.

My point isn't really that these big companies can't execute on the vision of a general-purpose personal publishing platform– but that they seem to be stuck with this bad hypothesis that an integrated set of mediocre tools is more valuable than just one or two really kick-ass components. It's the 1980s office suite mentality or the 1990s portal approach all over again. Except that today we're supposed to be living in the era of Web 2.0 where the Internet is the common substrate for IPC and best-of-breed tools should be integrated and remixed to provide one great service as opposed to just another "me too" in the blogs/photos/lists/social network soup.

Finally, what really gets me is that these guys: Microsoft, Yahoo, Google, and to a lesser extent AOL are the platform players which means that if anyone could really take a leadership role in this new way of building things, it is them. Google did it with maps (and the others have quickly followed) by providing a great, best-of-breed component that was easy to integrate just about anywhere and then letting a thousand flowers bloom. With a couple of more world-class components like these, Google may find itself much more able to do the "platform thing" than these ho-hum integrated attempts– and if they do these 100M spaces are going to end up nothing more than ghost towns left behind by the goldrush that MySpace started.