(this is page 111 of 121)





Latest

Caterina Fake comes back from her travels and writes an incredibly thought-provoking post attempting to categorize the types of social sites out there, especially with respect to user growth metrics. In the post she argues for three categories: primarily social (MySpace, Facebook), rich content (Flickr, YouTube), and person to person (Y Photos, Ofoto) with each type having different kinds of production/consumption behavior.

I think Caterina's three categories are great as archetypes to use when thinking through the character of sites, or key product management questions, but at the risk of going against the current Web2 grain of "keeping it simple," I was left wondering why we can't have a little bit of everything. In fact, I think this little bit of everything is what makes Flickr such a great success.

It wasn't until we launched a got a whole influx of Flickr folks that I realized that the Flickr social community is very vibrant. I've heard from more than one user now that Flickr is in fact their adult version of Facebook. They use the "Your contacts" page as their browser's home page and wake up every morning to the sight of new photos within their social network. One user even described Flickr as a "communal photo blog" that was "the best way to stay in touch with people that I care about but who I don't talk to regularly." Does this sound MySpacey to anyone? In fact, I think it's way better because of the way in which the photos provide an entertaining substrate for the types of social activity that are otherwise context-less on sites like MySpace (more on that in a future post).

On to the person-to-person type of site: in a totally unofficial survey of some of the Flickr pro users I know, I was surprised to see how many of them use the site as one would use Ofoto or Yahoo Photos to share pictures on an access controlled basis with people in their tight social circle (family and close friends). In fact, when we first built the Flickr-Tabblo bridge, we failed to respect photo ACLs form Flickr which was a clear mistake we had to rush to fix given the number of folks who had a substantial number of private photos. If I had to guess, I bet that Flickr photos and privacy resemble a sort of upside-down glacier with 40% or so of the content buried under the privacy waterline for just this reason.

Here is my reason for pointing out how well Flickr does in the other two types Caterina describes– I think most people are multi-modal in their online behavior. Sometimes you want to act like one of Bradley's content generators putting together stuff with your "publisher" hat on, sometimes you want to share the photos of the BBQ with little care for composition or editing with people you know really want to see them, and there are even times when you'll use the site to find people who you might want to know. It is the sites that do the best job of providing enough flexibility to accommodate the different modes of behavior that end up doing the best in the end. Doing anything else (at least until you've got many many users showing you otherwise) seems like premature optimization to me.

Comments Permalink

Ba-ba-Barcamp Boston is Bun

So Barcamp Boston is off to a great start, at least from the energy level of the first day's crowd. It feels almost like a whole lot of folks here in Boston have been in a state of suspended animation while the dot-com fallout took place, and they are just now starting to re-emerge.


It's good to see contemporaries who started their careers during the first web coming back wiser and better than before. More patience, more humility, and a greater willingness to listen are amongst the qualities that I'm feeling in this crowd. Even the kids just starting out seem more humble than we were the first time around.
Comments Permalink

There is an IBMer with a terrific blog post where he tells of describing all of this Web 2.0 hoopla to a friend as:

chmod 777 web


So in UNIX-speak this loosely means: allow anyone to read, write, and execute the web. Really cute, and really right on. Anyone who knows even a little bit of UNIX gets it right away.

Especially nice during this week of Web 2.0 trademark nonsense when people just decided to pile on poor Tim.
(via Infectious Greed)

Comments Permalink

Rafe Needleman covers the neatest device unveiled at this week's D4 conference in San Diego, a portable music player by Zing with Wifi and Bluetooth that can upload/download without a computer in the mix.

Another attendee at D observed to me that while last year was all about the iPod and how it seemed to have no boundaries, this year's conference scarcely had any mention of Apple's beloved little device. Instead the session speakers and chatter in the hallways were all about the importance of content getting on the network (from both the media companies and regular folks) with a specific emphasis on video. I think that this may in part be due to the fact that Apple had little presence at the conference (Steve didn't even show), but another more important reason may be that Apple being Apple has stopped really having something worthy of the buzz in the portable player space. Sure Bose-clones are nice, and the iPod ID is still good enough to eat, but startups like Zing are showing that the important next step for these devices– a step which would excite the geeks that attend events like D– have to do with networking the devices together to do more interesting stuff.

The most interesting aspect of the Zing player was not its music-playing (ID-wise, the iPod has it beat hands down) but as Rafe writes, that it comes built-in with everything that one would need for a peer-to-peer communicator: wi-fi radio, speaker, and microphone. A friend of mine, Jordan Pollack, gave me an idea 5 years ago around a peer-to-peer Blackberry that would store small txt messages among the peers in a mesh-style LAN until one of them got Internet-connected and sent the messages out into the wild, and I've been in love with it ever since, mostly because of what a neat hack it would be. All you would need for a near-ubiquitous connection would be enough density of people carrying the devices and the occasional device passing through an open Wi-fi spot so that it could dump its stored payload out on the net.

With the Zing you could even add a sort of voicemail-like format to the mix so that people could have asynchronous voice communications with anyone anywhere on top of the synchronous voice calls available within the mesh formed by a pool of these devices.

One thing we couldn't figure out 5 years ago was how to start the process going because as with all networked gizmos, having just one or two wouldn't be any good at all. And that is where the passion that people feel about their music comes in. If you are already carrying the device around for another purpose, all the comms. stuff would just be a nice added bonus.

A term used by evolutionary biologists comes to mind to describe just how a network like this might roll out: as an exaptation.

Comments Permalink

I love the Pew studies for their conclusions even if I don't entirely understand their methods. The latest (via ClickZ News) proclaims that nearly 50MM Americans are generating content on the web. Of course this includes all sorts of things from leaving comments to sharing pictures, but despite this, the really good thing here is that this many people are willing to engage in a participatory medium.

I've written before on the magic ratio of 1-10-100 as proposed by Bradley Horowitz of Yahoo, so I'll skip the description here and just say that we might be approaching a time when that ratio skews in favor of more people creating content. But we need a couple of things first:

Better tools that can be properly contextualized

Most "content creation" tools on the web today suck, plain and simple. I'd guess that ranked by popularity or use, our old friend TEXTAREA would win hands-down. So where are the MacDraws, the PageMakers, hell even the MS Words of the web? I think when dealing with text Gmail comes the closest to being good today, and it isn't even a tool for creating content that is going to be published. Imaging tools are weak, and layout tools all but non-existent (which is a big part of the reason why we started Tabblo). And this is to say nothing of better tools for audio, video, and a few other media types. Someone needs to push iLife to the web, and fast.

Except that the tools need to be mashable, in a good old Web2 style. I want to see my layout tool of choice for words and photos right there in on my MySpace profile. On Om's blog there is an interesting post today about how social network sites are the new media– if this is indeed the case, all the best creative tools in the world will be nothing but silos if the can't play well on both import and export for starters– nevermind the necessary deeper integrations that users are going to come to expect.

Better Repurpose-ability of Content

I'd write more Amazon reviews if Amazon would also publish a blog of all of my reviews for me, at my own URL, while providing me with some styling/editing controls. I'd make more iDVD slideshows of my photos if I could also get hyperlinked iWeb-like sites out of the effort. I'd even do more LinkedIn if I could get a "portfolio site" out the other end that was part-resume, part reference checking app. In all of these cases, the key is that the tools should be smart enough to allow me to easily repurpose my creative investment in any particular piece of "content." At my old company we made layout tools that allowed hundreds of thousands of people to assemble photo books that we would then manufacture. People would spend hours crafting stories out of their photos and captions but the only type of output we supported was the physical book. We were (and probably still are) the best tool for making photo books but it wouldn't have taken that much of an effort to be pretty good at a number of other forms of output.

I think I've said it before on this blog, but this I will repeat: we live in very interesting times indeed. Man, as Graham Swift wrote, has always been a story-telling animal, but it is just now that the combination of the Internet as a persistent publishing platform, and the PC (and PC-like devices) as creative tools, that we're getting to the really interesting stuff.

Comments Permalink