(this is page 93 of 121)





Latest

It's good to be full of it

Ok, so my last post is starting to smell like blogger's fromunda, if only because I tried too hard to reduce the argument about creation/consumption to make it more fun and polarized. That said, since posting it, I've had a few really interesting conversations with folks about consumption, creation, and the consequences of the tools at your disposal.

The most interesting one was at the weekly office pizza session yesterday where we quickly got off of the iPhone vs. N95 thing (not so interesting anyway) and into the question over whether any type of content creation— even if it is bad, lazily composed content— was better than any type of content consumption (I know, generalizations like this can make one's hair catch on fire). I was somewhat amused to see that this belief was not universally held among the folks that brought you Tabblo, with some preferring to think of some types of content as not worth the bytes they take up. It's an interesting assertion which cuts so against this whole democratization of personal publishing that it took me for a loop-de-loop as I thought about whether this might indeed be true. Certainly worthy of more thought.

One thing which Dave also argued for, but which I'm not on board for was that easier, more ubiquitous, and more connected content-creation and publishing tools (as has been argued about the N95) were not necessarily a net-gain because the serious folks would just take out the big honking iron to get the pictures and videos worth capturing.

It turns out that we are both wrong, but it took another David to prove us both wrong. Talking about his friends Greg and Petra who've just finished documenting a cross-country trip, he wrote to me last night:

I agree the trip is only interesting to close friends it's no On The Road, but great content, great stories, great communication, great pictures. And it requires a very low barrier IMO the same phone greg had in his pocket helped to be able to take pictures and email them to blogger more often than he would have any other time he took a trip.

(You can go and see this wondeful photoblog here)

Now it turns out that these guys used an iPhone and a Blogger account to tell this story. And you know what? Despite not knowing them, I found myself completely captivated by both commentary and photos. This may speak to Greg and Petra being particularly creative, it may be because I've done this very trip a couple of times, and it may simply be because it feels so real, but in any case, here was a clear case of what I had labeled the ultimate "consumption device" being used to tell a really wonderful story. I'm sure someone better equipped could have done a much more artistic job of it, but for the 10 minutes I spent learning about Greg and Petra's sweet adventure, I don't know that it would have made any difference. And in fact, the risk that they would have gotten to the Pacific without the time to edit, compose, and publish it, thereby depriving me of my 10 minutes is certainly not worth it.

So maybe not all content is worth publishing, but I do dig what these guys have done. Oh, and I'm happy to eat crow on my attacking the iPhone (for now).

Postscript: I got a chance to meet these guys last week while out in SF.
Comments Permalink

In the office, 2007 is going to go down as the Year of the Smartphone as everyone seems to have decided to simultaneously update their cellphones to smart ones. At the high end, the classic Jets versus Sharks face-off seems to be brewing between Apple's iPhone and Nokia's N95-3. Both are amazing devices, which clearly herald the era of very powerful things in your pocket. At the same time, they each seem to express such fundamentally different philosophical underpinnings that this promises to be a much more interesting fight than the old Mac-vs-PC spat of the last decade.

I have to admit that until very recently I was deeply ensconced in the iPhone camp. Having gotten used to the crappy quality of the device as a phone, I went about gleefully evangelizing the whole "it's not a phone, it's a computer in your pocket" until Apple pushed its 1.1.1 upgrade. The locked down firmware, the continued lack of 3rd party development support, and most significantly, the sudden appearance of the "iTunes Wifi store" (ahead of say, IM or MMS), has made me start to see my iPhone as a big pipe Apple (and maybe AT&T) is intending to use to sell me stuff (what my friend Jerry might call the ultimate consumer leash, encouraging me to "gulp products and crap cash").

Anyway, after having played with an N95 in the office yesterday, realizing yet again that Symbian is still unusable as hell, I was nevertheless left with the impression that there is something more to this N95 than the iPhone. The combination of really solid still and video capture, integrated GPS, and a rich and open API for third party development makes it almost possible to overlook one of the most byzantine UIs a phone could have. Then this morning I came across Jonathan Greene's excellent head-to-head review of exactly these two phones and realized what that tickling sense of possibility was all about:

The iPhone is for consuming content, while the N95 is for creating it. —via Steve Litchfield

(to be fair, I think Eddie and Pitkin were trying to tell me this last night but I was just fried)

How true, how true. The iPhone (today) is a great locked pipe for consuming your media, and as of 1.1.1, for buying some too. You don't have to look further than the re-monetization of your own songs as ringtones to see where Apple wants to go. Whereas the N95 feels a lot more like a swiss-army knife for content creation— perhaps not as good as dedicated device for any one of its tasks— but good-enough... and just so handy.

Now we know how this movie ends, at least here in the US. When given the choice between creating and consuming content, most people would rather just sit back and consume. This is why YouTube won when many other more producer-friendly video sites floundered. It's why TV still commands the kind of audience that most "huge" online properties would kill for. And it's why, as a mass market product, I'd be willing to bet that the iPhone will spank the N95.

But there is something potentially different about this particular twist on consuming versus creating. For a long time now, I've been hot and bothered by the idea of the "unwitting blogger," or the regular user who, in the process of doing stuff, becomes a creator of content without really thinking about it. On the PC/Internet, the trick is most successfully implemented by the proper harvesting of either metadata or messaging data. Digg is today's king of metadata, and Facebook the king of messaging. Both sites turn their "consumers" into creators during the very process of consuming the services.

What I would argue in the case of the N95 is that a phone equipped with a really good camera, a GPS, and an open API could become rocket fuel for the explosion of unwitting bloggers. Geotagged automatic upload to Shozu is just the beginning (though a very powerful one), as is Jaiku's twist on presence. We've surely got more to come as developers begin to explore how we bring location, multimedia, mobility, presence, messaging, and the cloud together in new and creative ways.

Comments Permalink

My brother-in-law gave me an ARC copy of the forthcoming Fake Steve Jobs book, Options, which I have to heartily recommend as high quality trash that is also very good for your soul. Why? Because it has been a long time since I've caught myself chuckling out loud— no, downright crying/laughing in public like this (to be precise, the last time I had this experience was while watching Arrested Development while on long cross country flights). In fact, last week I kept quite a few people up on a redeye flight as I laughed my way across the continent while reading about Fake Steve's trials and tribulations.

The book is great not just because it is an awesome parody of Steve Jobs himself, but because it it also a sendup of all of the famous people in his life. From Bono to Spielberg, from Hillary Clinton to Yoko Ono, no one escapes Fake Steve's wit and acerbic observations.

For me though, the funniest parts always come back to "El Jobso" and his attempt to cope with a world that is quickly moving away from the PC and towards new media company and the "Googletards" that he just can't understand. I'll leave you with one of my favorite passages in the book, where Jobso is celebrating his public company CEO achievements to some fanfare:

They're all raving about us...Cramer, that lunatic, is pounding his desk and screaming at people to buy Apple.
"This stock is a must-own!" he says, his face so red it looks like his head is going to explode and splatter his brains all over the set.
"Steve Jobs should be elected president of the world!"
I'm so psyched that I drive down to the back of the parking lot and do some donuts in my Mercedes. There's smoke everywhere. A bunch of Mexican groundskeepers stand there whooping and waving their arms. One of them scream, "Chinga tu puta madre, cabron!" which I believe means, "Dude, you totally rock!"
And you know what? I do. I totally do.

Comments Permalink

Paul Graham, whose writing is usually a real treat for me, has written a lame essay about the impeding abundance of web startups due to how cheap it has become to get one off the ground. In the piece he foresees a world where the startups become like a dandelions sprouting up all over the web. He asks how basic elements of the startup lifecycle (funding, strategy , acquisition) will change as we much into this world of surfeit.

While I think that it is an interesting thought experiment, I doubt that things will fundamentally change all that much. Rather, the current explosion of PHP-monkeys building Zizzl or Dizzl (thank you Fake Steve Jobs), the next great tagging-based version of eBay for digital goods, reminds me a lot of the late 1990s. There may have been a lot more money sloshing around then, and there certainly was a path to exit that is now closed to all non-businesses (IPOing), but the same overabundance of people trying things was around then as well.

Except for one big difference which Fred Wilson mentions in his follow-up post: back in the 1990s the surfeit of entrepreneurs were largely newly-minted MBAs looking to apply their talents to dreaming up all of these new businesses. Today it seems like that particular cattle cart of lemmings has returned to financial services, leaving the mantle in the hands of the geeks who are now "empowered" by Ruby on Rails, virtual dedicated hosting, S3, and essays about how easy it is to build a startup today.

Unfortunately, as is the case with pendulum swings, the sustainable model for startup innovation and wealth creation is probably somewhere in the middle of the two scenarios. From what I've seen it takes three things to have a great startup: 1. an exploding market, 2. a great product that works (herald the great geeks!), and 3. solid thinking about the business model and the go-to-market plan. The need for this third leg of the stool has not been obviated by cheaper infrastructure costs, and certainly not by the emergence of AdWords as "instant businessmodel."

Confusing the success of startups that get $25,000 in funding and sell for $5MM to Some Big Company with a fundamental change in how businesses are built is not understanding the core driver of value for the acquirer. When any big company buys on the cheap like this, what they are generally doing is smart hiring, not actually paying for the opportunity to enter a market or inherit and working business. Vesting schedules being what they are, paying $5MM for 5 engineers that have a proven track record as a capable team, and making them work for 3-4 years for that money is actually a great deal from an HR cost of acquiring talent perspective, especially because it is generally funded out of the balance sheet.

There is no magic— it is hard to start startups, especially if the role of these is to build businesses that work. Making stuff people will use is a good first step, but there are a whole bunch that need to come behind it.

Comments Permalink

I can not for the life of me believe that people who have better things to write about are still debating the definition of Web 2.0, 3.0, 3.x, etc. It has now entered the realm of the absurd. And as a beneficiary of the "Web 2.0 tidalwave," I feel justified in ranting for just a second.

Tim did us all a favor back in 2003 when he coined the term Web 2.0 but for only one very simple reason: he gave the media and investors a conceptual frame from which to begin seeing a world which for the previous three years had been seen as a complete wasteland. It took about a year and bit for this conceptual frame to catch on in a meaningful way, but when it did, entrepreneurs could finally talk to financiers again about the web without being laughed out of the room. And for the most part, journalists who had been burned by the long view/short distance fallacy during the dot-com boom, were coaxed out of crap pieces about "the best places to launch a career" to talk about the impact of the net again. There was a tremendous amount of value in this soft reset, and for that, all of us entrepreneurs owe Tim a beer.

But that is it. There is absolutely no other reason to try to version the web, and any entrepreneur who relies on these dot releases for any sort of consequential decision making or strategy formation is just looking for trouble. Notice that Google— the perennial Web 2.0 company according to a whole load of experts who matter— rarely refers to Web 2.0 in describing itself or the products it is bringing to market (interestingly enough, Yahoo is not shy about cloaking its (re)launches in Web 2.0 lingo).

Most significantly, users don't actually give a rat's ass which version of the web their application belongs to. Instead of focusing on version of the web, the versionites might be better served by thinking about versions of users, as in User 1.0 ("wow, this Internet thing is amazing so I'll put up with anything"), User 2.0 ("if it isn't as simple to use as the Google search bar, I don't care about it"), User 3.0 ("if it doesn't come in my BrainPal I don't care about it), etc. At the end of the day, all of the technologies, data sources, and macro social trends that we are trying to lump into the versioned web need to support these fundamental change in user demands.

Just to end on irony: I'm looking forward seeing everyone at the Web 2.0 conference!

Comments Permalink