The ever-inspiring writer/commentator David Brooks has a great piece in today's NYT called "The Outsourced Brain" where he writes about the way in which net-connected electronic life is making us all smarter by allowing us forget about the mundane. He starts with the wonders of an in-car navigation system, which resonates well with me as I've completely relied on one of these since 1999, and finishes by talking about how he sometimes doesn't know where he ends and his Blackberry begins.
This being the year of the smartphone, the piece is particularly prescient. Brooks is focused on whether this sea change is causing us to lose our individuality and concludes that it is our autonomy that we are giving up instead but I find it much more interesting to think about what the long term effects of the connected ubermind will be on productivity and creativity.
After having wrestled with whether the PC has had a positive impact on economic productivity over the last 25 years, macroeconomists are now going to have to think through how to measure the productivity impact of the always-connected devices in our pockets— an even trickier proposition. I don't have a single friend with a Blackberry who doesn't claim that it makes them much more productive— always available at a moment's notice to return an email. But really, how much better is the economy because the velocity of email is jacked up on on critical subjects like the company's annual dinner or the preference for softer language in the next day's presentation? All of these things feel like work which makes the 7 people playing ping-pong over the chain of emails feel productive on friday night, but I am hard pressed to see how these will show up in GDP data (outside of the increase in data usage and purchases of Blackberries).
And on the flip side, we're giving up all of the dead time in our lives to our electronic leashes, time that was previously spent at the grocery store checkout line daydreaming, free associating about problems, or jut thinking. Now it seems much easier just to check Twitter and see what's been put into the flow.
It is obvious to me that the net is going to go down as the most significant productivity boosting man-made thing ever— bigger than electric power, the steam engine, antibiotics, the book, whatever. Being networked is so transformative in the way that it allows people to communicate, work, and relate in just about any discipline that I find it impossible to believe that anyone would argue against this. Here I'm just curious about extending the net's reach into every place we go and every second of our lives.
And for the record, there is no way I would go back, even if it turns out we're going to be half as productive and twice as boring as a society— if only because I think that being more connected is a worthwhile positive mission to keep on driving. But it is interesting to read Brook's social commentary and think about how much more like the Borg we are slowly becoming.
