My goal with this blog

I write about relevant changes in the way that people use the web and how startups are built to provide services and products for this ever changing wonderful thing we still know as "the web." As a former entrepreneur turned early-stage investor, my greatest hope is for this to be useful to other folks that are like me in the hopes that they can avoid some of the mistakes I've made.

Making web businesses that work is not getting easier

Paul Graham, whose writing is usually a real treat for me, has written a lame essay about the impeding abundance of web startups due to how cheap it has become to get one off the ground. In the piece he foresees a world where the startups become like a dandelions sprouting up all over the web. He asks how basic elements of the startup lifecycle (funding, strategy , acquisition) will change as we much into this world of surfeit.

While I think that it is an interesting thought experiment, I doubt that things will fundamentally change all that much. Rather, the current explosion of PHP-monkeys building Zizzl or Dizzl (thank you Fake Steve Jobs), the next great tagging-based version of eBay for digital goods, reminds me a lot of the late 1990s. There may have been a lot more money sloshing around then, and there certainly was a path to exit that is now closed to all non-businesses (IPOing), but the same overabundance of people trying things was around then as well.

Except for one big difference which Fred Wilson mentions in his follow-up post: back in the 1990s the surfeit of entrepreneurs were largely newly-minted MBAs looking to apply their talents to dreaming up all of these new businesses. Today it seems like that particular cattle cart of lemmings has returned to financial services, leaving the mantle in the hands of the geeks who are now "empowered" by Ruby on Rails, virtual dedicated hosting, S3, and essays about how easy it is to build a startup today.

Unfortunately, as is the case with pendulum swings, the sustainable model for startup innovation and wealth creation is probably somewhere in the middle of the two scenarios. From what I've seen it takes three things to have a great startup: 1. an exploding market, 2. a great product that works (herald the great geeks!), and 3. solid thinking about the business model and the go-to-market plan. The need for this third leg of the stool has not been obviated by cheaper infrastructure costs, and certainly not by the emergence of AdWords as "instant businessmodel."

Confusing the success of startups that get $25,000 in funding and sell for $5MM to Some Big Company with a fundamental change in how businesses are built is not understanding the core driver of value for the acquirer. When any big company buys on the cheap like this, what they are generally doing is smart hiring, not actually paying for the opportunity to enter a market or inherit and working business. Vesting schedules being what they are, paying $5MM for 5 engineers that have a proven track record as a capable team, and making them work for 3-4 years for that money is actually a great deal from an HR cost of acquiring talent perspective, especially because it is generally funded out of the balance sheet.

There is no magic— it is hard to start startups, especially if the role of these is to build businesses that work. Making stuff people will use is a good first step, but there are a whole bunch that need to come behind it.