(this is page 17 of 121)





Latest

For a while now I've been noticing that Google's ability to deliver results that I care about in search slots 3-X seems to have decayed in the face of SEO spam, realtime clutter, and other distractions. Assuming I am like most people (who don't even look beyond the first page of results), this means that the Google product is now delivering about 20% of what it could. Seems like an astonishingly low hit rate for a brand that built on the premise of being a better mousetrap.

This might explain the attempt to add knobs with the latest redesign that might better target the rest of the results. And yet, the time filter, which I had thought would be really useful to surface out of the advanced query page, seems to be relatively weak in terms of making better use of slots 3-10 on the first page. And what is worse, the overall widget has given Google the feel of a Windows 95 control panel.

I'm not a big believer that search is dead by any stretch of the imagination. The social graph, app stores, Q&A services— you pick your favorite disruptor for the traditional method for discovery— I can come up with a whole mess of queries that just will not fit the model (some of which are among Google's most profitable). But I do think that the company needs to pay attention to this 20% hit rate and focus on that more than on the rest of the new shiny toys everyone keeps clamoring for them to build

Comments Permalink

Charlie Stross, one of my favorite living scifi writers has a prognostication piece on the future of the PC industry that is among best tech analysis I've seen anywhere. He starts with this:

I've got a theory, and it's this: Steve Jobs believes he's gambling Apple's future — the future of a corporation with a market cap well over US $200Bn — on an all-or-nothing push into a new market. HP have woken up and smelled the forest fire, two or three years late; Microsoft are mired in a tar pit, unable to grasp that the inferno heading towards them is going to burn down the entire ecosystem in which they exist. There is the smell of panic in the air, and here's why ...

and ends here:

If you're using an iPad in 2015, my bet is that you won't bother to have home broadband; you'll just have data on demand wherever you are. You won't bother yourself about backups, because your data is stored in Apple's cloud. You won't need to bother about software updates because all that stuff will simply happen automatically in the background, without any fuss: nor will worms or viruses or malware be allowed. You will, of course, pay a lot more for the experience than your netbook-toting hardcore microsofties — but you won't have to worry about your antivirus software breaking your computer, either. Because you won't have a "computer" in the current sense of the word. You'll just be surrounded by a swarm of devices that give you access to your data whenever and however you need it.

In between he weaves a great story around Apple's ridiculous gestapo-esque policies regarding what software can run on their devices and what they do to people who reveal their secrets, why Flash is abhored on the iDevices, and what 4G data networks will really mean for the world at large. It's as good as any of his books and while he may not have all of the details quite right, I think he paints in broad strokes how the PC era will truly end for consumers, and what the cloud one will entail.

Comments Permalink

[Note: these are my thoughts and not those of my former employer. I had zero visibility into a potential Palm acquisition and was as surprised as everyone else on Wednesday when I read the news]

As the case with most of the large tech companies, there is a lot of Apple jealousy inside the halls of the product side of the HP house. I used to play a game of reverse Buzzword Bingo, collecting one point for every meeting during a given week when Apple wasn't mentioned in some capacity ("we need to be as elegant/integrated/creative as the iPhone... we want this to be the iPhone of X"). Most weeks my score was 0— 1 on the weeks when I had meetings with the facility manager.

From that perspective, buying Palm makes a ton of sense for the world's largest tech supermarket: it gets the chance to bring a line of products to market that are fully integrated, it controls the software experience, and from what I've been told (because I've never owned a webOS device myself), it gets a very good copy of the iPhone OS which can be ported with little effort up and down the product line.

This is why it makes sense that the company would cancel the slate rumor that was rushed to announcement in January and I suspect that it will also be just a matter of time before all of the released Android products— and worse still— any of the on-deck Android products— get canceled or replaced by ones with webOS in their plan of record.

In fact, the fate of Android inside of HP is likely the greatest casualty of this whole deal, and given the recent pressure exerted on HTC by Apple's lawyers, it doesn't come at a good time. While it it hardly the case that HP was single handedly moving Android forward with its engagement with the OS, I think as one of 3 "tier one" players who had begun to embrace it (albeit apprehensively) with partners and the supply chain, the signaling power of the company's retreat will be felt.

It was never easy for HP to get its head around Android— between the open development model and Google's inconsistent messaging around Android versus Chrome and the different classes of devices (which seemed at times poorly thought out and at times just downright flakey), it was a bumpy takeoff every step of the way. HP is a company used to dealing with "vendors" who meet RFPs and charge license/support costs to deliver predictable help, not a community guided by a single company whose core business wasn't serving HP's needs.

In the end, I'm not sure whether HP can make webOS a commercial success (it may be too late), but I applaud their boldness in trying it. There is a lot a stake here if the world continues to go the route of app stores and platform dictators and I'd hate to play without full control of the stack (not to mention the glee at HP legal on the patent trove they're about to own).

What I do think is true is that we consumers ought to fast forward and think through whether we'll be better served with Apple, Google, RIM, and now HP all running this same playbook, or with the seemingly fading promise of a post-PC world that is as open as the desktop/browser one has been for the last decade.

Comments Permalink

Product, product, product

I found this Dropbox presentation absolutely charming, not only because I am an avid user of the product, and a passionate fan of the product, but because it speaks so honestly about something that should be front and center for every single startup that uses the Internet to deliver its offering: your product matters— in fact it matters almost more than anything else.

As we fall in love with all sorts of new concepts around distribution: virality, social game dynamics, flash sales, etc., it is critical to remember that these are tactics to expose new potential users to your product (or service), and that no matter how well they work, at some point you will go splat if the product is not unique enough to delight some subset of your potential customer base.

Product, product, product. Say it 10 times and don't forget it. If you are a startup, this is the only way that you will build deep and sustainable value. While investors (like me) may ask you questions about distribution, these should only be coming after they already believe you've cleared the first threshold of having something people will actually want.

[And to those who might point to the failure of the Betamax in the 1980s or the Mac in the 1990s, I have good arguments for why these were both bad products for the markets where they lost. As is probably the case for many other counterexamples of great products losing to sales & marketing]

Comments Permalink

The web as a rainforest

This is my last bit on this whole Facebook thing (not quite sure why
this week's announcement has rubbed me so wrong):

I am currently waiting out a rainstorm at the Yunque national forest,
one of the only tropical rainforests in the US national park system.
What is amazing about this place is how heterogenous it is, from the
fauna to the flora. There are something like 225 species of trees alone!

It is really a sight to behold. Looking at it, I couldn't help but see
this interwoven set of animals, plants, and trees as a good metaphor
for the web as a whole. It thrives because of how diverse it is.

And yet asking one of the parks folks whether there was any common
element to the speed of development of the ecosystem as a whole, I got
an interesting answer: apparently the flow of water, from cloud to
rain to trees to the ground and back is the only thing that governs
the speed of growth, and it would seem that the biggest threats the
reserve has faced over time have come from global environmental
factors that affect this general flow (such as global warming).

Similarly on the web, it has been the flow of hyperlinks, from page to
page that I think has governed the speed of development. Between http
and HTML, we've gotten the same basic elements that have allowed for
the heterogeneity of the web: from amazon to wikipedia and millions of
smaller species that hav thrived.

If this Facebook thing takes off in a big way, it has the chance to
evolve the link in interesting and very powerful ways. No doubt. But
at the behest of one company. This can not possibly be a good thing.

Google was made possible because of the web. And today it is
incredibly powerful. But if it were to go away tomorrow, we'd still be
left with the web- it'd be like the National Park Service pulling out
of the Yunque- mostly because until recently they've sought to curate
the web and not evolve it in a way that makes it less rAinforest and
more zoo.

The park folks keep telling us that this is our park and that
protecting it is our responsibility to the future. It strikes me that
the same could be asked of us on behalf of the open web.

(Excuse the typos. Typed on an iPhone in the middle of a rainforest.
In the rain)

Comments Permalink