(this is page 18 of 121)





Latest
Star Wars Lego, weekend 2

Anyone with little boys knows that what passes for modern day crack cocaine with them is the combination of two great franchises: Lego and Star Wars. Whoever thought of that cross licensing deal deserved his marketing bonus for the year (which he's probably spending on endless Lego Star Wars sets for his kids).

Having spent the week chasing down misplaced Clone Troopers, I got to thinking about a potential equivalent big-boy combination of two great franchises: Apple's fantastic hardware & software design with Google's openness and Internet services DNA. Why is it that we're made to choose between fantastic devices with unparalleled fit and finish but totalitarian control points, or sloppy designed-by-committee but wonderfully generative platforms like Android or Chrome?

People of both sides of the open vs. closed debate have argued that each company's products result from their starting philosophies, that closed begets more finished products, and open requires tolerance of more "generic" experiences.

I call bullshit on that.

Instead of philosophies, I think we need to focus on a much simpler cause— one based on simple economics. It's been a long time since Apple has had to be open in their approach to a product for business reasons. At the launch of OS X, the alternative to being open (with an OS that was easy to port to, attractive to Linux/Unix developers, enticing to ISVs) was being broke. So the company was incented to do the right thing. Similarly, until the iPhone ran away from the pack, Google had little incentive to do anything but get a checkbox in the mobile OS category of their strategy slide— but as is clear with the Nexus (and likely with the Incredible and all future high end Android phones), they are now playing up to Apple's level on mobile fit and finish (at least to a couple of revs back).

I'm hoping that the take-over-the-world stuff we saw this week from Facebook (with Microsoft cheering on from the sidelines) will wake these guys up so some deeper economic motivation to stop fighting and figure out how to do the Lego/Lucas love dance. At the very least, I'm tired of having to choose.

Comments Permalink

Facebook's news yesterday at the F8 conference can be boiled down to one statement: the company wants to be the identity system for the web, but not just for people, but for every type of object that can be boiled down into a URL: restaurants, places, chunks of media— eventually just about anything physical or abstract that we can think of wiring into the net.

On the one hand this is great news for the semantic web geeks because we'll finally get the right combination of ease-of-use and incentives required for publishers to truly mark up their content appropriately for the coming semantic search engine that Facebook will be deploying (though they were too smart to use this stinker of a label yesterday). Publishers want to traffic and engagement they will likely get, users want the convenience of overlaying their friends on top of the web, developers want the power of playing with all of this newly exposed data, and Facebook just plain wants the data as their endrun on Google. Everybody wins. Right?

Except of course that, at scale, this is giving an inordinate amount of power to one company. The kind of power that would make IBM handing the keys to the PC over to Microsoft look like the Portuguese Air Force by comparison (all two planes).

Here is an interesting thought experiment: imagine if Microsoft had used their combination of Frontpage HTML authoring tool and Internet Explorer monopoly to inject metatags in every document created, and corresponding code in the browser to read the tags and collect the data in a master database in the sky for subsequent mining— all in the name of enhancing the user experience. People would then have the convenience of the semantic web at the expense of giving all of that power to Microsoft. Instinctively, wouldn't you recoil at this proposition?

And in fact people did— despite the fact that Microsoft's was a much less ambitious plan. The whole "Smart Tags" fiasco taught the company a lesson about the boundary between useful and creepy. And yet, now we are seeing the same movie again, albeit from a much more clueful and powerful competitor when it comes to the web.

What am I missing?

Comments Permalink

Not enticed by the additional cores and upgraded memory bus on the i7 laptops, I opted instead to finally make the plunge to solid state for my main laptop disk drive.

Man what a difference it makes!

I don't think that I've felt such a noticeable difference in the performance of a personal computer since Apple switched from PPC to Intel a few years back. Where there was latency in applications before, there is just instant gratification now. And more surprisingly, the apps that seem to benefit the most are the ones I would have thought were CPU bound due to all of the layers of abstraction: VMWare and Chrome/Firefox/Safari. If I were Intel, I'd be more worried about SSD storage these days than cramming cores into fixed dies.

It's not cheap— in fact, it is still atrociously expensive: on the order of $2.80/GB versus about $0.20/GB for the fastest possible spinning platter in the same 2.5 inch form factor. And what is more, at least on OSX, the operating system is horrendously not optimized for the different read/write characteristics of an SSD— and still you get this crazy performance boost (if you do take the plunge, and you are on a Mac, I'd highly recommend this atime hack before you swap your solid state disk in).

I'm sure SSDs as mainstream components are coming though, and to the degree that Apple still cares about their one open OS, I hope they make the investment in SSD filesystem support (like the TRIM command which Windows 7 supports out of the box).

And in the meanwhile it is funny to think that between smartphone, PC, iPad, iPod, etc, nary a platter is spinning in my life. In fact, magnetic platters have become the new tape— useful for backups and not much else.

Even if the price seems too steep to replace your main drive, I'd highly recommend getting a smaller one for the system, and if necessary dropping the DVD player. Even partitioning your data is worth it, given how much newer your computer will feel.

Comments Permalink

Someone needs to do a case for the iPad that doubles as a physical keyboard of the sort that Apple is selling with that wedge thing that props up your iPad. Along with the forthcoming multitasking in OS 4.0, we might have something useful after that. But until then, unless your job consists of surfing the web and tweeting into the giant collective miasma of the link-passing masses, this is a device is best used to round out the fast growing collection of screens in your home.

Or at least that was my impression after a week of taking the machine with me everywhere where I would have previously brought a laptop, concluding in a couple of nights away without access to my trusty old clamshell. Lacking the option to escape to the laptop was the doozie, especially when I felt myself in need of editing a complex text file and discovered that without soft arrow keys you are reduced to being an angry pointing monkey, poking a finely tuned glass screen that shows your stubby homo sapien fingers little love and much smudge.

And to boot, if you have any semi-complex task that requires the use of any two applications concurrently, say something as simple as looking up instructions on a task and typing commands in, the "instant-on" claims quickly melt in the face of frustration every 4-5 second pause required to close one context and open the next.

As I gnashed my teeth trying to sort through these early challenges last night (while rushing to try to get something actually done), I realized that perhaps the worst feature in the iPad is the unrealistically high expectations that Apple and the rest of the world have set on the machine as the "next revolution" in personal computing. Much like I would never complain about the lack of control and missing features when paying $200 for a small point-and-shoot instead of $1000 for a DSLR, I think that properly evaluated in context— as a fancy peripheral for leaving the laptop out of the living room especially when there are others around— it will be an absolute monster hit. Laptop replacement? Not for geeks and not even for "normals," at least not for a while yet.

One final thought: showing the consistency of a two-year old, the TSA doesn't bat an eyelash when you leave the iPad inside the bag while clearing security. This is a monster bonus for the frequent travelers— however, I can only imagine that it is an ephemeral benefit at best (it can not be that our crack team of airport security geniuses are that fickle).

Somewhat related: Nick Carr has the best analysis of why the collective online consciousness is so up in arms about the question of whether the iPad is going to hijack computing as we know it.

Comments Permalink

Too many bytes being wasted on iPad reviews/impressions/complaints, so I am going to be brief and specific to people who care about the industries I've worked in. Just three simple initial observations:

First, it is a beautiful piece of hardware with amazing software, but my first impression upon holding it (and one which has just gotten more acute after a day of using it) was: man, this thing is heavy!

This almost doesn't bear mentioning, but it is nice to see that even Apple can not escape the laws of the physical world. If I had to guess, I'd say 40% of the weight is the battery, and an additional 30% is glass, which gives you an idea of what can come out of it in future versions (and what won't). And the weight is going to affect it negatively in two key ways: it won't be a device people can hold up over their heads lying down easily at all, and more importantly, it won't be a particularly rugged device, especially when dropped face down.

(Right now there is a very happy team at my former employer who couldn't for the life of them figure out how Apple might escape physics but were taken in enough by the Reality Distortion Field to believe they might have).

Second, I had written about how much I wanted the web browser to be first class, and it most certainly is. For some web pages it is as fast as anything on the desktop (which speaks to the fact that we're just about as there as we can be without more fiber when it comes to webpages and speed). But more importantly, the pinch and zoom is an absolute delight. And best of all, just about everything that doesn't rely on Flash or complex onDrag event handlers works. Yay open web!

Finally, and this will only be relevant to people in the photo space: photo sharing is about to change forever.

When I say photo sharing, I don't mean an online photo repository like Facebook's that just a feature of a bigger social app; I mean the full ecosystem in which the traditional photo sharing folks have existed. And what is key about this ecosystem is that output has proven to be the only scalable business model, be it the 4x6 prints of yesteryear or the photo books of today.

All of that revenue died today. Not in the going away immediately kind of dead, but in the Lotus Notes kind of way. There will be a generation of folks who will print photos and books for a little while longer, but for the bulk of people that have seen the power of a live slideshow on a bright IPS LED display of the iPad's size— one that can be passed around a living room or left rotating on a particular event— will never go back to keeping anything with ink and paper.

If I were still in that space, I'd be looking hard at the few players who have figured out how to make money with virtual-only products (which is really hard), because that is the only place where there is likely to be any significant growth.

Another way to put it: RIP photo book. You were awesome while you lasted and I'm sorry you never became truly mass market (only about 11% of the US population had made one last I checked), but there are just better ways to tell stories with pictures in a portable and human-scale way out there now.

More later after I work up the muscles to hold up the iPad better.

Comments Permalink