So Paul Graham finally got himself a blog which is a Very Good Thing (though he seems to be using a half-finished product to write it so its RSS feed is annoyingly borked).
Graham is a good essayist; in fact you could even call him a geek's Mark Twain. On his site he has a whole bunch of essays that range from just ok to absolutely great. The best ones are funny, insightful, and well written. Even the bad ones have a certain charm to them that makes them worth reading. What is clear from all of them though is that he puts in a good amount of time thinking, writing, and revising what he writes. Now that he has a blog, it is going to be interesting to see how the quality of the posts compares to the essays.
I can't decide if what I'd rather have from him is cleverness or perspective. His essays are clever, made even more so by the attention that he constantly pays to the power of analogy (i.e. "The atmosphere of the average workplace is to productivity what flames painted on the side of a car are to speed"), and I think that these clever twists are hard to just whip out while blogging– not because you can't come up with them but because you don't spend the time editing the bad ones out so that the good ones shine through.
At the same time, if Graham does embrace blogging seriously, it will be good to see his perspective applied to some of the memes that make their way across the blogosphere. Given how much time he spends crafting his essays, it is just impossible for him to take part in any of the distributed conversations that you can see at places like Memeonrandum.
To date everyone seems obsessed with comparing newspapers and blogs which I guess implies that the analog of the blog post is the newspaper article. To me, this comparison is not all that interesting though given how different the means of production are for both. The more interesting question as the blogosphere grows to consume more and more of the time that people used to spend producing essays, do the gains outweigh the losses?
A thought experiment: let's say Paul only has 25 hours/week to dedicate to the general "bucket" of writing. Assuming you are a Graham fan, would you prefer that he craft essays to be delivered one every two months or that he dive right in to the topic of the day with his own unique point of view? I'm not sure which I'd choose but I think following his blog for a few weeks will tell us a bit about the blog post as a format particularly when compared to its distant cousin the essay.