Rafe, who I am seeing today at the Under the Radar conference, broke the news this morning that Google has finally launched their first foray into online photo sharing, Picasa Web Albums.
The implementation looks to be a really nice version of a clean photo-gallery plus a "photo-cast" capability that allows other Picasa users to download the photos that you publish. It's clear that what Google is hoping to do is leverage their gorgeous Picasa client to give people a way to begin sharing their photos online in a simple and basic process that doesn't allow more much beyond basic sharing (this is probably made obvious by the their own blog post titled: "It’s all about the photos.")
I'd be worried though, that without more advanced features specifically around privacy, presentation, and collaboration, the product may fail to attract the increasingly more sophisticated publishers of photos online (then again, the product may be geared towards the 30% of folks who have never shared a photo online). For instance, most of us have loads of different groups that we communicate with online and a simple two-state privacy system (private/public)– while better than the all-public model of most blogging engines– doesn't really begin to address the ways in which we'd like to represent ourselves to others via our photographs.
More importantly, I want much more creative control than the standard grid of photos plus zoom-in view that Picasa Web Albums provides. It's interesting to me that most of the online photo sites copied their interface for display (the standard grid) from desktop photo management software even though that interface was built mainly for organization/editing and not consumption. It's almost like if magazines from the newsstand were laid out like the Quark or InDesign interface. The grid is easy for sure– it requires very little creative investment on the part of the user sharing the pictures– but as anyone who has ever been the recipient of a "weddingstorm" or "babystorm" can tell you (this is what happens when your friends start getting married/having babies and discover how easy it is to spam everyone repeatedly with huge online gallery links), after the first 9 grids, it starts to get old. With all of Google's AJAX goodness, I was sort of hoping we'd get a lot more of the cinematic effects that Picasa became famous for around the composition and story-telling aspects of photo presentation and display.
Finally, I wanted Picasa web albums to be more like Google Spreadsheets in the way that the latter breaks new ground around collaboration. As one would expect, the blogosphere is already abuzz with posts about how this is the first volley in a showdown between Picasa Web Albums (Google) and Flickr (Yahoo), but I couldn't disagree more. Flickr is the world's best collaborative digital shoebox with a few people throwing stuff in, and many many more sifting through the box for the best photos, helping to reorganize them, and writing small comments on the back of the pictures for others to read. It works so well, the experience is downright entertaining. But Flickr is not a photo editing tool, a photo organizing tool, or (as mentioned above) a photo compositing and layout tool. Picasa Web Albums, on the other hand, is an online extension of a rich client tool that does do some of those things. Nick Starr wrote a few days ago that Google was trying to build the new Dot Mac with tools that allow for easily publishing content that resides on your PC, and to this end, Picasa Web Albums is a very nice first step. But to me, collaboration around photos could be a lot richer than that, and we'll have to see whether it gets there as the team evolves the product.
Basically