(this is page 24 of 121)





Latest

Post Christmas everyone seems ecstatic about how well the Kindle is doing, with Amazon claiming that they sold more Kindle books than real books on Christmas day. And yes, just as with the Bose headphones a few years ago, the Kindle does seem to be the "it" gift for 2009.

But this is Jeff Bezos we're talking about, and fantastic though he may be as an entrepreneur, he does not (yet) have the Jobsean "Reality Distortion Field" powers, so before we all get carried away, let's remember that we are just at the start of ebooks— and more importantly that this first inning is pretty ugly.

E-Ink sucks. Its refresh rate is pathetic. On the device front, you can either go with the medical instrument inspired ID of the Kindle, or the crappy firmware of the Nook (the Sony being the book version of their MP3 player). The storefronts have a really limited selection and the lack of marking, lending, and dropping into the pool are marked limitations, to say nothing of the fact that contrast rates still leave a lot to be desired when compared to paper.

In my mind, eBook readers don't get significant until they help to reinvent the format. Yes the book is popular (with 400-500 years of installed base), but so was the map before the connected mobile device put a pin that marks your location and follows you around on it. I loved maps before but absolutely would never go back to them given the opportunity to see myself on it, and watch the map spinning around me as I turn 360 degrees around. And I suspect Amerigo Vespucci would agree.

Similarly, until we've got embedded videos in our books (a la YouTube) and a "Choose your own adventure" level of interactivity, we're just going to be aping old formats with plastic devices that will remain inferior in every way except traveling weight. There is hope yet— after all TV started as radio shows with faces.

I have a feeling that 2010 is going to be good to us on this front.

Comments Permalink

Carriers today are all aflutter about the prospect of non-mobile phone devices. For instance, as a large OEM, you are likely to get a meeting with the top brass at any of the world's largest carriers so long as you are touting a netbook device or an ereader. At the same time, the smartphones are being starved for 3G data connectivity throughout the world. What gives?

Well the reality is that the all-you-can-eat, general purpose device is more than most carriers can handle. The iPhone has definitely proved that in the United States with AT&T. Give people a decent general purpose browser and a few specialized applications (namely around media streaming) and they will go nuts, or at least more nuts than current T1 backhaul and cell radio stations can accommodate.

The ereaders are easy to understand: with the e-ink displays gating any meaningful use of the network, and the tollbooth that is the bookstore on the backend, carriers see Kindle clones as easy money (at least until the Apple tablet ships). But the bigger question is: why netbooks?

One theory is that people will expect to use netbooks mostly where they already use laptops, around wi-fi halos that will give them 3-10x the speed they can expect to get from a 3G network. And as such, the ability to charge $60-80 USD/month is just free gravy to the carrier.

But I think it goes beyond that. I think that most carriers love the idea of getting consumers hooked on the idea of ubiquitous access to the network— so much so that they are willing to "forward price" access to the the 3G bits (forward pricing implies taking a loss now that will be made up later when the cost of manufacturing supply catches up with stimulated demand and has been common in semiconductor driven industries for a long time). You may not spend a lot of time listening to Pandora on your 3G netbook, but the sheer fact that you can is likely to get you hooked to the ubiquitous service. For those rare moments when you might want to.

Unwittingly this business decision to collect marginal revenue with little marginal cost is training a marketplace of ubiquitously connected consumers who will begin to measure devices not on megahertz and gigabytes, but on how "connected" they are. And my suspicion is that once the mainstream flips into this mode of thinking, no one will dare ship a device without the ubiqconn feature box checked. Good times.

Comments Permalink

I am tired of AppStore mania

The FT has one of these mostly wrong pieces today on the Android Market versus the iPhone AppStore that makes you glad old media is dying. Usually the province of the mail-it-in NYT writers, the article makes a few spurious arguments, including that it is really easy to port an iPhone app to the Android platform (it is absolutely not), and that what users really want is quality apps instead of overwhelming amounts of quantity.

What users really want is mobile computing, full stop. This means a first-rate web browser, an email client that works well, a maps application that is usable walking and driving, the best possible camera software for cleaning up the deficiencies of a small form factor, and maybe, just maybe, a media player that can fill some white spaces. The AppStore mania, partly fueled by Apple fanboy fervor, and partly fueled by Apple's fantastic marketing machine, keeps making it such that this gets lost in the mix.

What developers want is the ability to deliver their increasingly cloud-based applications into as broad of a mobile device footprint as possible, along with— in a few narrow verticals— the ability to monetize at point of install through a micropayment system that works. Apple is off to a great start on the last point, but let's face it, the carrier/consumer billing relationship is much stronger (ringtones have proven that), and also a more natural place for micropayments to happen.

We are so tied up in AppStore mania (one of the great themes of 2009) that we've lost the real story: the twin forces of the move of computing happening in the cloud with really compelling mobile browsers that should, over the medium term, subsume all of the more important native platform capabilities. That is the real story I wish these big guys were writing about.

Comments Permalink

After the snowThe single biggest thing I miss about my pre-iPhone Nokia e61 is the way that great applications like Shozu let you perform a network-related content authoring action, and then faded gracefully into the background to slowly bang on the Inter Tubes and get the bits across. I was reminded of that earlier today when in the process of messing around with an HDR iPhone application, I tried to reply to a text and ended up dropping the phone into a snowbank. Much like this chap over here.

I've had the discussions over and over about how the iPhone doesn't need background processing, that it is not a general purpose computer, that it would slow down the phone with bloated apps, and that would ruin its magic. Frankly though at this point all of these Apple apologist arguments are ringing about as false as those around how the battery is "good enough" and doesn't need to be removable.

These are general purpose computers, and what is more, they represent the next stage of all sorts of rich content publishing for most of us. And that means that you need to be able to go from start to finish in a little as 15-60 seconds— a virtual impossibility once you move beyond meaningless tweets about who you've just run into.

Come on Apple, please help me avoid forking over $600 to Nokia for great hardware running into a software brick wall!

Comments Permalink

Learning from full automation

IEEE Spectrum has a fascinating piece on the failure of automated systems that use sensors, actuators, and software to drive all sorts of transportation equipment on behalf of the humans who become simply passive "gauge watchers." The piece is great for airplane junkies, but it makes a much more fundamental point about the way that supposedly foolproof systems are designed incorrectly, often because the engineers involved forget to take into account the human nature of the operators:

”We draw a system’s boundary in the wrong place,” Thomas states. ”There is an assumption that the system boundary that the engineer should be interested in [sits] at the boundary of the sensors and actuators of the box that is being designed by the engineers. The humans who are interrelating with these systems are outside it. Whether they are operators, pilots, controllers, or clinicians, they are not part of the system.

The part of the piece I found more applicable to general product design for regular people comes at the end though:

Parasuraman explains that ”if you deliberately engineer anomalies into the automation, people rely less on it and will perform a little bit better in monitoring the system. For example, if the system is 90 percent reliable, operators will be better at picking up the 10 percent of the errors than if the system is 99 percent reliable.”

[Sort of like Desmond on Lost pushing the button, right?]

Something about this statement made me think about driving engagement with users in web applications. It's not often the apps that are most completely baked— nor, as is the conventional wisdom today, those that are as simple as Google to use, that spark the imagination or win the hearts and minds of users. Instead the web apps that users seem to really engage deeply with, are the ones that do just enough to make a task easier or more enjoyable, but leave enough fuzziness in their design so as to make the operator want to lean forward and explore the space of possibilities.

A concrete example: the first generation photo sites (Shutterfly, Ofoto) were completely baked to make people slip down the 4x6 slide of print ordering, with each of the experience flows targeted at the handful of tasks that supposedly would lead to more of that. Along came Flickr with its dead-dumb simple metaphor of "one photo in a stream" and drove mass adoption of photo sharing by a group of folks who previously had little interest in photos online. In the third phase, when we set out to improve on that at Tabblo, we gave people a half-formed page editor to create stories in a fairly open-ended way that combined photos and words with a little bit of software assist. The concept was harder to grasp than the previous two iterations, but its open-ended nature led to some pretty engaged, "lean forward" types of users.

The piece just continues to remind me that the future of computing is really all about cyborgs— or the intelligent design of systems that use both machines and humans (with our flawed and sloppy analog brains) to obtain results which neither can achieve alone. Or, more succinctly put, the future belongs to the giant Human Computing Platform that the Internet is helping to create.

Comments Permalink