(this is page 23 of 121)





Latest

VR pioneer Jaron Lanier has a fascinating and incredibly well-written editorial in the WSJ today called "World Wide Mush" where he looks at the dark side of what he calls "digital collectivism," or the ethos behind the platforms and projects that have most benefited from user contributions.

As a huge fan of open source over proprietary software, and insightful bloggers over established journalists, I was particularly taken by his claim that the era of digital collectivism is destroying the ability for the folks engaged in intellectual work to make a decent living. As he writes:

We're well over a decade into this utopia of demonetized sharing and almost everyone who does the kind of work that has been collectivized online is getting poorer. There are only a tiny handful of writers or musicians who actually make a living in the new utopia, for instance. Almost everyone else is becoming more like a peasant every day.

This is a bold claim— however it is one which he supports with a number of interesting arguments that make the piece a gem. Curious as to whether I could do some of my own quick research on the peasantization of the folks at the frontier of digital culture, I turned to Indeed's fantastic salary comparison search engine to try to tease out the differences in jobs available to folks playing in similar but distinct positions.

I started with my favorite: bloggers versus traditional journalists: according to Indeed, the average salaries for jobs listing "blogger," "reporter," and "journalist" in their title or descriptions are $34K, $44K, and $52K respectively. Ouch!

Turning then to software, where there is little doubt of the leverage and impact of open source, I was similarly surprised. I wanted to look at web developers according to technology of choice so I picked "PHP" (the most prevalent and totally open source), "Struts" (a Java-based middle ground between both worlds), and "ASP.NET" (Microsoft's completely proprietary stack) and came away with: $75K, $89K, and $83K respectively.

Now there are all sorts of problems with this type of quick-and-dirty analysis, but the pattern that emerges as you play out the types of job descriptions more aligned with this new era of digital collectivism against their predecessors is that Larnier is right— digital collectivism is no panacea for making a living.

A similar theme has emerged around the notion of "digital sharecroppers" or platform purveyors that leverage millions of small user contributions to build accrue most of the value for themselves. With the exception of eBay, and possibly Google (until now), this seems to be the case among all of the other "platforms" that have emerged in the last decade. So much so in fact, that I often tend to read the vision of many of these platforms, "X is going to democratize Y," as "X is going to really reap the investments of users who will do Y for next to nothing."

Examples:

Facebook is going to democratize communications and publishing = Facebook is going to reap the creative investment of users who will pour their lives into the largest privacy violation cesspool ever known to man.

Apple is democratizing mobile applications = Apple is going to reap the hundreds of millions of hours invested by developers for apps that are either free or sell for next to nothing so that they can maintain and possibly widen their lead selling expensive small computers.

The combination of these two trends makes Larnier's parting message in the piece something we should all be paying close attention to:

The owners of big computer resources on the Internet, like Google, will be able to make money from the open approach for a long time, of course, by routing advertisements, but middle-class people will be increasingly asked to accept a diet of mere kudos. No one should feel insulated from this trend. Poverty has a way of trickling up. Once everyone is aggregated, what will be left to be advertised?

Certainly worth at least keeping in mind as we plow forward into this brave new world.

Comments Permalink

What I hope 2010 brings

There is no doubt that in the tech world, the combination of the shift to "cloud" computing (which to me means both the growing relegation of the desktop PC as nothing more than an intelligent cache that can power more responsive UIs, and the ability to leverage at-scale virtual compute environments run by the big web companies) plus the explosion of post-PC ubiquitously connected mobile devices, are going to be two most important ingredients in the cocktail that gets mixed up over the course of the coming year.

In the context of those two undeniable trends, here are three predictions for the coming year:

Privacy on the net is going to become a big deal. Facebook's recent snafu was just the start of this. Every year people do more important stuff online, and when combined with big companies whose emergent business models are predicated on targeted media accelerating attempts to ramp revenue, you get an explosive combination. This will only be exacerbated by mobile devices streaming all sorts of interesting metadata (starting with location) to these same web services. It will not take long for one of these location-based features to mix with lax privacy in a way that causes real harm in the physical world— theft, adultery, rape, or murder style— and when it does, it will create one of the big stories of 2010. It will also result in a groundswell movement on the part of normal users to take control over their information, be it what gets clicked on from their web browser, or emitted from a mobile.

And while on the subject of mobile, Android is poised to be the only alternative to the Apple juggernaut (goodbye RIM, goodbye Symbian, goodbye Maemo)— and in some key ways, it will surpass the iPhone this year. The obvious one is what is being repeated all throughout the tech blogosphere: that as everyone BUT Apple depends on Android, their installed base will quickly eclipse Apple. While I think this may be true, I am not sure that it matters all that much, as the installed base we should be talking about is that of the Webkit-derived mobile browsers that are common to both the iPhone and all of the Android devices. From a developer perspective, I think that this will increasingly become the relevant target (especially as the AppStore mania settles)— and will continue being so until the smartphone form factor settles down, x86 PC style (which I personally hope doesn't happen for a long time).

Where Android's ascendancy does matter is that as a more open system, it will enable hardware manufacturers and service providers to play with deep web service integration in much more interesting ways that any sandboxed developer environment ever will. Obvious choices will be things like data synchronization and content delivery— both of which a big company would see as ways of making users more "sticky." But there are other more interesting deep integration efforts along the "smartphone as a remote control for life" which innovative companies will be able to play with.

And finally (and I realize that this one is a geek aspiration and a stretch), I hope to see 2010 begin the process of turning regular users into programmers. Right now we are almost there without realizing it: every time someone sets a Google News alert, uses an eBay sniping program, or customizes a Pandora list, it is a form of programming. A few years ago, when millions of kids where learning rudimentary HTML and CSS to trick out their MySpace pages, I thought we were heading in this direction, but it didn't seem to catch on. This year, with the notion of APIs being front-and-center among web service developers, we may start to see something that goes beyond the geek efforts that were Yahoo Pipes and Google Mashup Editor. Already, I am amazed at how many regular folks seem to be interested in the Facebook API, and the other day, while helping a friend with a Wordpress installation, I was shocked to see how vibrant and turnkey its plug-in ecosystem has become.

The best part of anticipating the coming year is that, no matter how you cut it, it promises to be more exciting than the last one that just passed!

Comments Permalink

As we close the decade in tech, I've been reading the "2000s in summary" style articles and blog posts, amazed at how much we've gotten out of this decade. Wifi and broadband hitting a tipping point. Peer to peer. Amazon as a global powerhouse. The cloud as a viable platform. The iPod, the iPhone, and Apple's phoenix-like emergence as the dominant computer company of the 21st century. The Android alternative. The Nintendo Wii and other types of HID devices all leading to more touch, more direct manipulation, and a more seamless integration of man and machine. The AppStore, ebooks, and alternative business models for content online. OLPC and the netbook craze that it ignited. YouTube. Facebook. Twitter. Google as the fastest growing brand of all time and the future creche for our AI overlords.

It is hard to look at all of these products, services, and trends that have come into being over the last ten years and not be overawed. And yet, if I had to pick the vector that will have the longest lasting influence on the world, it wouldn't be any of these. Sure they are they adorn the pages of Geek People every day, and we all love to spill tons of virtual ink on them.

But at the end of the decade, the greatest single trend to emerge in the last ten years is the way in which the Internet has enabled mass scale changes in new forms of collaborative work. Of course, the poster boy for this trend is Wikipedia which has now bested both Microsoft's Encarta, and the much more venerable Britanica. But the real impact of this new style of work is much more apparent in the effects of a globally connected swarm of human minds working, not for the almighty dollar and all of the associated external incentives, but for the intrinsic rewards of mastering a craft and belonging to a community.

Its name is "Open Source—" coined at the beginning of the decade by people who were trying to differentiate this new style of working on software from the ideological free software movement. From it we have gotten Linux and Apache, MySQL and Mozilla. Today a software engineer working in one of the two platforms that actually matters (cloud and mobile) does so with the richest toolset ever available; from languages like the Perl/Python/Ruby family of dynamic languages to tons of high quality libraries to do just about everything imaginable. All because a whole load of hackers were early to this party and have spent the last 10 years showing everyone else how it is possible to work, collaborate, and belong without the explicit motivation of material wealth, the very grease of modern capitalism.

It may started in software, but as Wikipedia has shown, it will not stop there. To try to understand why, pick up my last book recommendation of the year: Daniel Pink's new brand book, "Drive," which delves much more deeply into why this new form of organized value creation works. Or subscribe to Umair Haque in your blog reader for 2010.

Happy new decade. In the midst of the economic cataclysms of the last couple years, of multiple wars of the last decade, it pays to pause for a moment and realize that there is no better time to be alive than now.

Comments Permalink

Now that the word is out that Google is going to launch a phone, and that it is not going to use whitespaces and flux capacitors to obviate the need for a carrier, we can all breathe a little easier. In fact, the general reaction should be "ho-hum," but not because you are going to have to pony up $530 for an unlocked version of the device, because for all intents and purposes, this is just another T-Mobile phone.

I've had two of the three major Android phones that have come out thus far: the G1, and the HTC Ion (or MyTouch as Sprint calls it). And while they (and the Droid) have fallen short in ways that the Nexus doesn't (specifically around something as simple as the diminished proportion of the on-screen keyboard), their true Achilles heel has been the lack of 3G functionality when operating with an AT&T SIM. Once you've had 3G EDGE just blows for web surfing— which is after all the killer app of these new devices.

And let's face it, T-Mobile in the US sucks— or at least in sucks anywhere I've ever lived in or traveled to. Their 3G network is okay— when you have coverage, which is hit and miss, and mostly miss if you are in any kind of a fast-moving vehicle (by which I mean anything that travels faster than a rickshaw).

But that is not the real reason why a phone that doesn't work on the AT&T 3G frequencies is a bonehead move. The real reason is because the only people that are likely to pay up for a phone sold through a new channel like www.google.com are likely to already have an iPhone and an AT&T SIM just begging to be set free. We are the folks who are likely to be vocal, we are the Eloi who are currently fielding the questions from the fat belly of mainstream adopters who see 2010 as the year they will move to some sort of smartphone.

The only thing I can think of is that there is something hard or expensive about the 3G AT&T frequencies. After all, Nokia made the same mistake with the N900 which I would have happily bought if I could run it on my regular SIM. But this is Google we're talking about. If I were them, I would have worried less about the koi-pond wallpaper and more about getting full GSM 3G frequencies in the US models, and maybe even a dual device like the Frankesteins RIM sells under the moniker "World Phone."

Otherwise let's face it— this is yet another T-Mobile Android phone made by HTC running Google software.

Comments Permalink

Kindle on AT&T failAs we move towards the era of "appliance computing" with iPhones and Kindles and Droids and Nooks, one downside that people rarely talk about is that we are losing visibility into the components that make up our devices. This trend is not helped by the way OEM/ODM contracts are cut, where Asian manufacturers often make on-the-line component changes because someone else's WIFI chip seems to be cheaper for that quarter.

Ever notice for instance how Apple never talks about the CPU in the iPhone? Sure, the 3GS brought marketing claims around "50-100% faster" but we were never told that the ARM core had changed on that the clock had gone up by 50%.

An even better example of how this trend can bite you in the butt is what has recently happened to the Kindle. A true believer from day one, I helped to make the Kindle Amazon's #1 product this Christmas by giving it as a present. However, one of the folks I gave it to wanted to use it in rural New Hampshire, a place where my own Kindle 2 had previously worked flawlessly. Assuming this bode well for its "Whispernet" 3G service up there, I didn't think that Amazon might itself switch service providers (from Sprint to AT&T) without announcing it anywhere, thereby rendering the "same" model (Kindle 2) totally useless where previous units had worked flawlessly.

At the end of the first season of Mad Men, the good folks at Sterling Cooper get the Kodak carousel slide projector as a product to pitch. One of the copywriters extolling the virtues of Kodak as a technology-led compare (this is 1960) says "they are so proud of their technology, they even mention R&D in their ads!" thus giving you the feeling that this was the start of technology as a selling proposition.

Consumers aren't stupid, and in a day and age where the web makes the space available for marketing copy of infinite length, we might want to get back to a little more R&D and a little less "wow," "amazing," and "boom" on the side of the box.

Comments Permalink