(this is page 12 of 121)





Latest

Tim Wu's "Master Switch" has been a page-turner for me over the holiday weekend. Though it's non-fiction and very much in the spirit of nerdy tomes like "Wealth of Networks," or "The Future of the Internet," the thing this book has going for it more than those is its deeply researched history of the evolution of the phone, radio, movie, and cable TV industries.

The book's key message can be summed up with George Santayana's quote: "Those who cannot learn from history are doomed to repeat it." For in each of the communications industries covered, events begin with the spark of the amateur hackers doing things just for the sheer joy of seeing them exist up until the point at which the capitalists come in, checkbooks blazing to create AT&T, NBC/RCA, Turner Broadcasting, etc. Real disruptive businesses are built on venture dynamics and out of the best of each, natural monopolies emerge—monopolies which are based on unique qualities of communications infrastructure— only to then be meddled with by the government who, concerned with the potential damaging effects of monopoly business (and totally clueless on how these industries are different), spend a lot of time thinking about how to break apart these businesses only to discover that they are, at best, legislating last year's technology and trying hard not to look foolish doing so, while the now incumbent businesses go along their merry way building franchises that are hard to compete with by any new entrants not leveraging a truly new and disruptive technology.

The last chunk of the book is devoted to exploring the question of whether the Internet is different than previous forms of media that have gone before it. And in the end Wu concludes that it is not— that despite having been designed from the ground up to be decentralizedand abstracted into layers that would encourage continued entrepreneurial energy, the Internet too is likely to follow the path of its ancestors and end up a medium dominated by a few large entities. Of course he covers the battle currently waging between Apple and Google, comparing Apple's controlling approach to the AT&T of old and likening Google's "open" approach to prior mavericks attacking the establishment.

This last part hangs together less well than the rest of the book, but in the era of the FCC debating net neutrality, I'd say it is still a great book worth reading for anyone who wonders where this whole thing might end up. In my own case, my first thought upon putting this throughly enjoyable and informative book down was "ok, let's hope we get that next disruptive communication technology real soon now..."

Comments Permalink

Thinking about all of the gadgets wrapped under my tree this year, I think I was supposed to feel guilty as a result of Jordan Pouille's piece on the quality of life for kids working at the Foxconn plants, making it possible for millions of gadgets to appear under the Christmas tree which, according to loads of naysayers, would be "far too expensive otherwise" (just look at the comments here, here, and here).

[Perhaps because I hail from the third world myself, I didn't particularly find the photos and video particularly horrible— in fact, I'd argue they looked pretty good compared to what poor life in rural China might be like. But then again, I don't see many pieces chronicling that these days.]

What they piece did make me consider though was whether it was true that it was only as a result of these "sweatshops" that all of these gadgets have become to affordable. For instance, everyone knows that laptops, a 30 year old mass market consumer product, have come down from about $3000 to $300 (in nominal dollars), but it would strike me at first pass that Moore's Law and the trend towards system integration (more and more components on a single piece of silicon) have had more to do with this than the labor saving of moving manufacturing and assembly from the US to Japan and eventually Foxconn's facilities in China.

Because I couldn't get good data on laptop component prices over time (what ever happened to the promise of Wolfram Alpha?), I settled on that well traveled iPhone 4 iSuppli cost estimates (after all the Pouille piece's attention grabbing headline pointed to that particular global offender). According to NYT's estimate (which combined iSuppli's work with some data from Needham & Company), the direct assembly cost of the iPhone 4 is $6.54 as compared to a total materials cost of $187.51 and landing costs (which can include transport, packaging, etc.) of $45.95.

There is of course a second order effect on the labor cost— after all, many of the most expensive components come Samsung which may itself be benefitting from similar labor savings, but outside the display, a large number of these components seem to be largely silicon which is often manufactured in more expensive places (due to process control and IP leakage fears).

Foxconn conditions may in the end be net-negative for the folks moving in from rural China (though I'd still like to see the journalists looking into poor farming life), but this notion that we've only got affordable gadgets because of cheap labor seems a bit far fetched. Perhaps the rallying cry this year should be towards putting all of those gizmos on container ships (as opposed to air freight) and dedicating 1/3 of the landing costs to tripling the wage rate.

Update: a friend on the Twitter phone sent me this piece which makes a different argument that supports the same conclusion.
Comments Permalink

Where is the HTML5 app IDE?

I am beyond shocked that Adobe managed to pull off a $1 billion quarter not because I buy the exaggerated rumors of Flash's demise, but because their tools are so lousy. Despite the fanfare around the release of CS5, CS-CS4 were a study in shipping progressively buggier authoring suites for creative professionals that seemed to rely on nothing more than the power of muscle memory and Stockholm syndrome to keep the license renewal cash machine running. And despite their recent claims to the contrary, it is very rare these days that I run into any web developers who are still using anything outside of Photoshop, much less any of their nascent HTML 5 projects.

Imagine then, the pleasant surprise in seeing Apple ship a creative tool for producing iAds that is likely two configuration options away from being a full blown IDE for HTML 5 web applications. Having spent all of 15 minutes playing with it, I felt completely convinced that this interface model is what iWeb and Dashcode should have been, and quite likely what Vermeer FrontPage and Macromedia Dreamweaver would have been had Microsoft and Adobe not interceded with the buckets of acquisition dollars and ensuing strategy taxes that slowly turned each of the products into pigs made of bits.

Which is to say, I think there is a market opportunity right now for someone to build a kickass HTML5 authoring environment. In my mind, this would mean a native app* due to the fact that doing authoring apps in the browser is still too janky, built on the site tree UI metaphor (like iAds Producer), taking full advantage of device specific templates (PC browser, pad, smartphone), and engineered with a proper roundtrip process for advanced editing of HTML, Javascript, and CSS should a developer want to "go further."

The startup that does this right could find itself with a nice tools business and a pretty strategic asset once folks wake up from this AppStore/native app induced fever and remember what it was that we liked about the web in the first place.

* And at this point a company could get away with shipping a Mac/Cocoa version only, perhaps to leverage the forthcoming Mac AppStore.

Comments Permalink

An entrepreneur came by to pitch this week and said something that reminded me of a sticker from the schwag bag at Google's I/O conference in 2008: that the mega datacenters being built out of commodity hardware densely packed represent the future of the PC.

I'm not sure whether he meant to say the PC industry instead but the comment crystalized for me the fact that despite 2010 having been an incredible year for device innovation— we started the year with the Nexus One, got the iPad, the iPhone 4, a variety of Android-powered Samsung devices of all sizes, the SSD-powered Macbook Air that finally executed on the promise of the netbook while Chrome OS and the CR-48 are trying to put the rest of the netbook market on life support— all of the attention paid to these devices might actually be helping to bury the real storyline here.

While we've got a pre-Cambrian explosion of access devices, it's never been more true that the real power comes from what lies at the other end of that relatively thin interface. As Paul Bucheit, ex-Google guy, writes:

One way of understanding this new architecture is to view the entire Internet as a single computer. This computer is a massively distributed system with billions of processors, billions of displays, exabytes of storage, and it's spread across the entire planet. Your phone or laptop is just one part of this global computer, and its primarily purpose is to provide a convenient interface. The actual computation and data storage is distributed in surprisingly complex and dynamic ways, but that complexity is mostly hidden from the end user.

Which of course begs the question: if it's the datacenter that is going to replace the PC, why are we so obsessed as users on the access device itself? Geeks and gadgets and objects of lust and all that aside, I'm beginning to think that this obsession at conferences with the new access form factor may end up looking in hindsight like the great trackball fetish of 1985 (when all of the early mouse users went gaga over colored Kensington trackball pointing devices).

Comments Permalink

Dan Bricklin has a lengthy but worthwhile piece on the challenges facing the startup developer these days that puts some meat behind Zuckerberg's concern of a few months ago that building a consumer facing web service today has become a lot harder due to the challenges of supporting the myriad of endpoint devices.

During the 2005 "everyone loves AJAX" era when I started Tabblo, front-end engineering meant Firefox2/Safari2 and the dreaded IE6 challenges of making the DOM dance. Today if you are working on any semi-interesting service you are also likely to want to support iPhone OS 3.x/4 out of the gate, Android 2.X, and likely also the iPad (which though it now carries the iOS 4.2 moniker actually tends to require a ground up rewrite). So what was a 1 man effort in 2005 is now a 2-3 man job at minimum. And every entrepreneur who I meet who tells me they can outsource this is fooling themselves in much the same way that the MBAs who claim they can outsource technology do.

Combine this with the super lean seed funded craze of late and you've got a situation where you now have to cover 3 salaries (even at Ramen levels this adds up) where before there was 1 to say nothing of the additional challenges around UX and QA. The math of what you can do with $200-500K starts to look weird when you factor this in.

I've been trying to hold on to the hope that projects like jQuery mobile will make a lot of this a short term pain but Dan's post points to the reality of interface modalities which may make this a pipe dream at best.

In a resource constrained environment I'd hate to see people prioritizing mobile (and specifically iPhone) over more horizontally accessible interfaces like the modern web browser but in a world of "mobile first" this would be exactly what I'd do.

Help us Obi Wan (Google?), you're our only hope...

Comments Permalink