My goal with this blog

I write about relevant changes in the way that people use the web and how startups are built to provide services and products for this ever changing wonderful thing we still know as "the web." As a former entrepreneur turned early-stage investor, my greatest hope is for this to be useful to other folks that are like me in the hopes that they can avoid some of the mistakes I've made.

Don't feel guilty about your gadgets this Christmas

Thinking about all of the gadgets wrapped under my tree this year, I think I was supposed to feel guilty as a result of Jordan Pouille's piece on the quality of life for kids working at the Foxconn plants, making it possible for millions of gadgets to appear under the Christmas tree which, according to loads of naysayers, would be "far too expensive otherwise" (just look at the comments here, here, and here).

[Perhaps because I hail from the third world myself, I didn't particularly find the photos and video particularly horrible— in fact, I'd argue they looked pretty good compared to what poor life in rural China might be like. But then again, I don't see many pieces chronicling that these days.]

What they piece did make me consider though was whether it was true that it was only as a result of these "sweatshops" that all of these gadgets have become to affordable. For instance, everyone knows that laptops, a 30 year old mass market consumer product, have come down from about $3000 to $300 (in nominal dollars), but it would strike me at first pass that Moore's Law and the trend towards system integration (more and more components on a single piece of silicon) have had more to do with this than the labor saving of moving manufacturing and assembly from the US to Japan and eventually Foxconn's facilities in China.

Because I couldn't get good data on laptop component prices over time (what ever happened to the promise of Wolfram Alpha?), I settled on that well traveled iPhone 4 iSuppli cost estimates (after all the Pouille piece's attention grabbing headline pointed to that particular global offender). According to NYT's estimate (which combined iSuppli's work with some data from Needham & Company), the direct assembly cost of the iPhone 4 is $6.54 as compared to a total materials cost of $187.51 and landing costs (which can include transport, packaging, etc.) of $45.95.

There is of course a second order effect on the labor cost— after all, many of the most expensive components come Samsung which may itself be benefitting from similar labor savings, but outside the display, a large number of these components seem to be largely silicon which is often manufactured in more expensive places (due to process control and IP leakage fears).

Foxconn conditions may in the end be net-negative for the folks moving in from rural China (though I'd still like to see the journalists looking into poor farming life), but this notion that we've only got affordable gadgets because of cheap labor seems a bit far fetched. Perhaps the rallying cry this year should be towards putting all of those gizmos on container ships (as opposed to air freight) and dedicating 1/3 of the landing costs to tripling the wage rate.

Update: a friend on the Twitter phone sent me this piece which makes a different argument that supports the same conclusion.