(this is page 104 of 121)





Latest

Money and love are in the air

Well it seems like after the suspension of disbelief that was 2006 as far as making money from social sites, web 2.0 mashups, etc., we may see 2007 as the year when people start asking themselves that question in earnest. All of those eyeballs have got to turn into dollars after all, and thus far Rupert Murdoch seems to be the only guy who's been able to do it right.

The signs of change are in the air: YouTube— despite its new corporate parent's deep pockets— is making noise about pre-roll ads and revenue sharing, Microsoft is looking to take on Paypal to facilitate online payments, and even Businessweek is jumping into the fray with pieces like this one which argues that we're now going to need the serious venture bucks to build out the "real businesses."

At the end of the day though where all of these social sites are concerned, you either have an audience that advertisers want to pay for, or a base of potential customers that can be incented to spend money. Google, Yahoo, and all of the rest of Web 2.0 fall into the former camp, and innovative new companies like Smugmug, Cafe Press, and Tabblo fit into the latter.

For our part, after having spent six months building an initial member base that was attracted to the Tabblo service (either because of the editor, the online/offline combination, or the quality of the products we make), we're now starting to experiment in earnest with products that will begin to motivate members to buy at greater frequency than most other output vendors.

Tabblo Valentines, which we are launching today, is an interesting first experiment in this regard for a few reasons. First, at $1 including shipping, it's a relatively low commitment to try. Second, Tabblo Valentines are an offering that builds on all of the core parts of the free service that we've built over the last year. The same editor, the same mix of photos and words, and most importantly the same focus on collaborative/social content creation. So it will be really interesting to see whether these elements when combined get us to something more interesting than "yet another site offering some Valentine card gimmick." Finally, the inclusion of a relatively small feature, auto-addressing makes the Valentine product something that is really interesting in the context of an online community.

Most people who meet online don't know each other's physical addresses— usually not a problem (and sometimes an advantage). However there are times when it really is nice to interact in meatspace which is why people still read real books and like to get real cards. This is what auto-addressing is meant to fix. By letting Tabblo be a blind intermediary in handling the addressing and shipping of the package, it becomes possible for members to strengthen their online ties offline without doing too much work or feeling awkward about it. And in doing so, we're also lowering the friction usually involved in sending real mail (a nice thing to do despite living online).

This is the first step in what is going to be one long experiment with our business model— focusing on the types of physical products that make sense for our online community— however this seems like a very timely experiment now that 2007 is here to stay.

Comments Permalink

Last year I was obsessed with 2006 being the year of the "casual publisher" which I guess it might have been if you buy the load of hoopla Time magazine heaped on us with the Person of the Year but I'm not sure we got as far as I would have liked. Sure YouTube is the absolute bee's knees and they really do deserve almost $2b of Google's money they got, but it's not because of the explosion in casual publishing they've enabled (it's because they did something really amazing in giving the bits of television that serve to hold our culture together permalinks that we could all email, IM, and post to our blogs).

And no, wikipedia— though even more awesome than YouTube— does not make for a universe of casual publishers (for instance, it's been 18 months since I last contributed to an entry). What Wikipedia did prove in 2006 is that the dynamic from the Professor and the Madman can be amplified 1000-fold with the Internet and broadened way beyond the scope of the OED.

We spent the year at Tabblo focused on the casual publisher. Our particular twist was that the distance between "photo sharer" and "casual publisher" was short and easy to cross if you could pre-select the type of person coming to you by giving them an app with the right attributes. Our angle was (and still is) collaborative story-telling with pictures and words, helped by a personal art director in software and the ability to go from online to print with a few clicks of the mouse.

The good news was that more than a million people seemed interested enough to at least drive by and take a look with a good number of them staying around to make some really outstanding stuff. The more interesting news however, is that we've still got a bit of work to do to truly make it casual and that this looks like a great year for that to happen.

By casual we don't just mean easy (which is where we'll be focused for the next few months) but also compelling, relevant, and right-sized. This last bit is the big lesson from all of personal publishing in 2006— and the hardest one to get right. For instance, blogs are really interesting and compelling but for most people they are the hammer of personal publishing; that is, sitting down to compose an entry like this one takes forethought, time, and sweat. I am afraid that is is still the same for tabbloing— giving people that much creative freedom amidst a community of artistes who live to look at each other's work necessarily implies that authors have to really make an effort to tabblo. We attempted to mitigate some of this by building a publishing platform where distribution could be varied with access controls (from 1 person to the world), and as the folks at Six Apart have learned, this does help a bit— but it doesn't solve the whole problem.

We also attacked it with different formats— defining some as quick and others as more involved and elaborate. We did this specifically with the introduction of books and other printable products that could also be shared virtually. This gives you two axes— intended audience size and type of output which does provide some freedom to do all sorts of different kinds of things depending on your mood and intent.

But there is still one big problem in getting the experience to the right size: the ease of publishing when the moment motivates you to do so. The mobloggers got this from the very beginning— blogging from your cellphone wasn't just about "hey cool I can blog from my cellphone!" but also about being able to casually publish during the holes in your day (waiting in line at the supermarket, riding the subway, driving). Unfortunately the experience is just too cumbersome for most device/platform combinations. That said, the product that did the best job of bringing the potential of mobile-based publishing this year was the phoenix that rose from the ashes of Odeo, Twitter. Sure, they're only aiming to help you answer the question: "What are you doing?" but everyone of those SMSes has just picked up a thread, an audience, and most importantly, a permalink (no surprise that this product is from Ev and some of the other ex-Blogger folks).

Even if Twitter solves it for the words that come out of SMSes though, I want to see it solved for photos, audio, video, even the data that comes out of my Nike+/iPod running partner. We'll be giving it our own unique twist for photos at Tabblo this year, but as 2007 bring all sorts of new device/data combinations, the opportunities are almost limitless.

To close: why the hell should we care? I would argue that we should care because it turns out that casual publishing is a lot more like voicemail and a lot less like commercial radio— it's an opportunity to make connections with the fellow tribesfolk you most care about in new and interesting ways. And as Barry Schwartz argues in his book, it is these relationships (and the constraints they bring with them) that truly make us happy and fulfilled.

And even if you don't buy that, Chris Anderson (of Long Tail fame) had another possible reason in the best answer in this year's Edge question with his "Metcalfe's law of minds." Essentially, it this type of activity that can make us smarter as a species more quickly than anything that came before it. This too should be plenty of reason why you too should continue rooting for the casual publisher in 2007.

Comments Permalink

It's finally time now

Apparently, the reason why US telephone numbers have seven digits in them is because a psychologist from Harvard University named George Miller did some research in 1956 that concluded that most people can remember at most seven chunks of information, plus or minus two.

As convergence in the digital age sneaks up on us, it would be interesting to see the same study replicated for the things we carry around with us. In my own case, it feels like the most I can remember to keep with me is two things plus-or-minus one. And unfortunately most days I end up leaving the house with 5 things (mobile, camera, media player, wallet, and id/keys). Every morning I go through the same routine: hunting for the various pieces which I've naturally deposited in different places before giving up and leaving for work with a part or two missing (a trend which is only exacerbated as we get into the cold months and I have to go searching through various jacket pockets). Just yesterday morning, I made the unfortunate mistake of leaving for breakfast without my wallet. While I was driving back home to retrieve currency to pay the bill, I was running the calculation in my head about how much time this whole ordeal is going to cost me in time over the next ten years (21 days out of 10 years spent hunting for gizmos).

Then I thought, while each of these devices serves a different function, with the exception of the very physical tokens (wallet, id) which could be better represented as data files anyway, on the inside they have the same guts (they are all basically miniaturized computers). As you look at them, they are even starting to look the same— probably because it's the same Flextronics factories churning them all out by the millions. Is it still too much to ask that they all get mushed into one device that I can carry around with me?

Power, form factor, cost, expected lifetime of use— there are plenty of reasons why the uberdevice has not worked thus far. However, we've finally got really compelling reasons for having each of these things with us at all time. Ubiquitous Internet access and a whole bunch on interesting web services existing in the cloud (iTunes, Twitter, Google Maps, etc.) I think make the general purpose smart device really compelling both for not only communication but content consumption, and perhaps more importantly, content creation.

There will always be a need for specialized devices (you can't beat the quality of a digital SLR or the screen on a video player) but in a sense, their existence will allow for sacrifices to be maade that would make the uber communicator workable. Here is the list of things, I would gladly sacrifice for the convenience of an integrated solution:

  • camera
    • flash
    • super zoom lens
    • resolutions higher than 3MP
  • phone
    • the "handset" form factor (headset talking is just fine)
    • multi-frequency radio (including AMPs support for ubiquity of signal)
  • wallet
    • cash (you can carry this separately)
  • media player
    • video

The one thing that is absolutely non-negotiable is simple software that works quickly without crashing. I use a Treo 700p on a daily basis which is supposed to be the fastest and most stable of the smartphones and yet, I find its software to be complete crap. This device would have to work more like an iPod in terms of reliability and speed which may in the end mean separate processors, OSes, and even power sources. This ok— so long we still get a form factor that is all-in-one.

Since I am a software person, this is mainly my Jetsons view of the world (totally imaginable but not necessarily feasible). However, with all of this crazy speculation about Apple doing an iPhone and Google getting into the business as well, I figure I'd put it out there— my Christmas wishlist if you will.

In the meanwhile, I'm off to find a very low tech system so that I stop leaving things behind.

Comments Permalink

Zero sum stupid

James Surowiecki, who wrote 2004's fascinating book, The Wisdom of the Crowds, has a great piece in this week's New Yorker on Nintendo's strategy with their new Wii game console where they are clearly ceding the #1 and #2 positions (by volume) to Sony and Microsoft but still managing to squeeze out a nice place/profit despite being #3. It's a great read for anyone interested in the dynamics of marketshare but especially good for the lemming investors/entrepreneurs/analysts who cover the web space and talk about the importance of "being the biggest," or "being at scale relative to the competitors."

This whole #1 or #2 thing started when Jack Welch, head alpha business monkey and super chief executive from GE, declared that if his company wasn't #1 or #2 in every market segment they competed in, he was pulling the team and exiting the business (covered in Surowiecki's piece). General managers in all sorts of industries then took to this notion in droves and started applying it broadly. What most people missed however, was that Welch was referring mainly to industrial goods businesses where there are huge up front capital costs that have to be amortized over a limited number of purchases very quickly. When you build a turbine factory for example, there are about 18 buyers in the world for your stuff and if you can't get decent marketshare in the segment, you fixed costs quickly become the death of you.

Not so in just about every other industry, and especially, service or content businesses. A few years ago at the D conference, Walt Mossberg asked Steve Jobs what the difference was between being the CEO of a computer company and being CEO of a movie company. I expected a total puff answer but was surprised to hear Jobs talk pointedly about the difference between zero sum market places and non-zero sum ones, and specifically talk about the different industry dynamics when you're out choosing an Apple over a Dell (either/or) as opposed to seeing Antz and A Bug's Life. According to him, managing a non-zero sum business (including people, projects, strategy, and tactics) was a disaster waiting to happen— which is why this piece in the New Yorker should be required reading for the take-the-market embahs looking for the next eBay opportunity.

Notwithstanding the rallying cries of the attention folks, most of the businesses we are in are far from zero-sum. I would argue that the closer a purchase of a good or service gets to emotion as an underlying driver, the further away it gets from Welch's #1/#2 model of survival because by definition is is far from zero sum.

While Surowiecki does not make this same zero-sum argument for why the Nintendo is in a great place with its Wii strategy (he prefers to focus on the classic serving an unserved segment argument), it is nice to see that implicitly the company's strategy is an affirmation of the Jobs statement on competitive dynamics. I'm no console gamer (I think I was more in the Apple ][ generation) but I do love talking to them and fantasizing about how someday a modern-day console may win me over like Myst/Zelda/Castle Wolfenstein did in years past (the only 3 computer games that have ever sucked me in deep), and what I've been gathering about the Wii is that even the most die-hard Xbox/PS3 folks are eager to get one both because it is cheap and because it provides a whole new axis for game play despite its underpowered hardware and lack of cutting edge features.

Go rising tide that lifts all boats!

Comments Permalink

Web 2.0 as a concept many flaws in it, but one of these is not the "the dictatorship of the presentation layer" as described by Bill Thompson in his post on Web 2.0 and Tim O'Reilly as Marshall Tito. A nice turn of phrase perhaps— but as we say in Spanish: "mas flojo que un mojon mojado" as far as the argument goes.

The whole fallacy starts when Thompson characterizes AJAX (one of the cornerstones of Web 2.0) as the:

answer for developers who want to offer users a richer client experience without having to go the trouble of writing a real application.

Not true. Having just spent the last year and a half building a content creation tool that is 100% browser-based and "AJAX powered," and having just this weekend* matched the level of functionality that I spent the 2.5 years before that building into "real applications," I can attest to the fact that the AJAX version is easily an order of magnitude harder to write than a native Win32/Mac OS application. You've got to deal with runtimes that are all a little bit different, you've got to deal with server roundtrips, network latency, and a protocol that is (despite the best intent of XmlHttpRequest) straw-thin and dumb simple. You've got scalability, concurrency, memory footprint, and a badly baked-in set of user affordances (hello, Back button?). And when you're done with all of that, you've got a ADD-inspired user that will spend about 5 seconds trying to figure out what you app is about before riding a hyperlink out never to return again. If mitigating risk in the face of complexity were the main goal, I would take scaling algorithms and Thompson's "message passing between distributed objects" any day over the primordial soup that all of us working to build rich Internet applications in open and extensible ways swim in every day. Hands down.

Put simply, AJAX is not about easier GUIs and cool effects. What makes the suite of associated bits known as AJAX (and specifically DOM manipulation and asynchronous server calls) so important is that it is mashable, transparent, and most importantly, late-binding in the way that it can be recombined post-facto to build value the original application designer never intended. Witness the huge explosion in innovation that Google Maps brought to the world after it was launched.

If it was just about easier GUIs, we'd all be using Flash— much more controlled runtimes and much easier debugging. But Flash is terrible for what makes Web 2.0 special because it lacks the two great enabling attributes of AJAX: "View source" (and all of the associated shallow ramp that comes with it) and IPC (Inter Process Communication) facilitated via the webpage. I'm sure the Adobe guys are not stupid and are working hard to fix this— but with AJAX as it now stands, we've already got it, and it makes the absolute pain in the ass that it is to build rich interactive applications out of what was fundamentally conceived of as a display render worth it.

Thompson's piece is fairly light-weight and so I found myself wondering why it irked me so. And then I realized why— because I've spent too much time in lecture halls and at conferences listening to the architecture astronauts talk about the "real computer science—" time I would gladly trade for more time with guys like the hackers at Tabblo who work very hard to make less than ideal technologies like AJAX sing.

Comments Permalink