In what is a great example of how Digg/Reddit have made blog post titles irrelevant, Paul Graham has a piece called "Microsoft is dead" which is really much more about how they are now irrelevant. The thrust of his argument is that Google and AJAX make their platform irrelevant for new hackers.
Fun stuff, appropriately lambasted by wizened veterans like Dave Winer and Don Dodge and put properly in the context of "Rich Internet Applications" by Ryan Stewart. So rather than plumb the depths of the argument, I wanted to keep the plane at 30,000 feet:
For a platform strategy to be displaced (and this is what Microsoft has done brilliantly up until now), you need to have a new platform strategy and a viable economic model.
Are AJAX-enabled web applications enough? Not by themselves. It's cool to have a much richer experience in the browser but I doubt that this alone is discontinuous enough. Outlook web access was after all, the first AJAX-enabled web application, made by the very folks at Microsoft who this new platform is supposed to make irrelevant. Despite the portability advantages of data-in-the-cloud, turning the world of PCs into dumb terminals doesn't even necessarily feel like it is altogether a step forward in the evolution of personal computing.
However, there is something else that makes Web 2.0 a much better candidate as a full on platform: people. Tim O'Reilly has been writing about it for years, and plenty of others have jumped in; collective intelligence, smart mobs, folksonomies— however you label it, the idea that people can come together and trade, write encyclopedias, etc. is really powerful. I don't think we even know how to understand what this new people platform is really defined by, but we can see its outlines in examples emerging from the wild. For instance, Twittervision is a great example of an app built on the people platform.
That said, we still need the economic model to give the platform enough time to grow its ecosystem. Microsoft has had wonderful one here in software licensing. Open source has a pretty good one in the gift economy and ego/reputation (albeit not as good as Microsoft). Web 2.0 most definitely does not have a good economic model in "selling the feature to Google/Yahoo." Furthermore, it's not clear that the ad thing is going to work, especially as we see increasing returns to scale in the online ad networks, and try as we might, no non-content provider has yet to crack the subscription model on the consumer side.
Without a viable economic model, it will only be a matter of time before Microsoft and Google incorporate the features that make the people platform into their respective businesses and leave a vast wasteland of cynical folks capable of using pastels and rounding corners on rectangles. This stuff is really hard to get right; you need the platform shift (timing), the economic model (business), and the emergent ecosystem (developers) to work together for a long stretch of years. And no matter what the cool kids at Y-Combinator are worrying about these days, I'm not sure we've got all of the key ingredients in place.
As an aside, if you want to see a great example of someone who got this right on the money the last time around, go and listen to this long-ish talk by Bill Gates from 1989 when he talks about the PC ecosystem. He must have been in his mid-thirties at the time, and it is just amazing to hear how well he can navigate the level of detail up and down to paint a really cohesive vision of where personal computing was going back then.