(this is page 45 of 121)





Latest

Like Umair Haque, Bruce Sterling has always been one of those sharp commentators that is either much smarter than the rest of us or just plain batshit crazy— and maybe a bit of both. Perhaps it is because I am just about to finish his latest book, "The Caryatids" (a fantastic dystopian vision of the future of the world), but I found the transcript of his talk from Webstock 09 an amazing analysis of just what this whole "Web 2.0 thing" was all about.

Many people have tried to describe it in hindsight (usually with a fair dollop of cynicism), but having lived it, Sterling's summary strikes me as the most accurate:

Web 2.0 goes away. Its work is done. The thing I always loved best about Web 2.0 was its implicit expiration date. It really took guts to say that: well, we've got a bunch of cool initiatives here, and we know they're not gonna last very long. It's not Utopia, it's not a New World Order, it's just a brave attempt to sweep up the ashes of the burst Internet Bubble and build something big and fast with the small burnt-up bits that were loosely joined.

And as to the "next new thing," he writes:

So -- what does tomorrow's web look like? Well, the official version would be ubiquity. I've been seeing ubiquity theory for years now. I'm a notorious fan of this stuff. A zealot, even. I'm a snake-waving street-preacher about it. Finally the heavy operators are waking from their dogmatic slumbers; in the past eighteen months, 24 months, we've seen ubiquity initiatives from Nokia, Cisco, General Electric, IBM... Microsoft even, Jesus, Microsoft, the place where innovative ideas go to die.
But it's too early for that to be the next stage of the web. We got nice cellphones, which are ubiquity in practice, we got GPS, geolocativity, but too much of the hardware just isn't there yet. The batteries aren't there, the bandwidth is not there, RFID does not work well at all, and there aren't any ubiquity pure-play companies.

[Which interestingly enough, is the main technological backdrop to all that happens in The Caryatids]

I could quote many more parts of the talk— but you should go read it instead. Dense and pithy at the same time, it is worth the slog, not just because he has nailed the cultural analysis of what has happened over the past 5 years, but because he leaves us with a glimmer of optimism for what it is that we need to do now.

Comments Permalink

Apparently there was an article in the Globe last week about the need for the Boston technology scene to rebrand itself to attract attention to the local successes around here. Wade Roush takes this apart today as the wrong way to approach the problem of getting more innovation, investment dollars, and entrepreneurs around here.

I could not agree more.

When I clicked through to the original article, I felt as though I were reading something out of the Onion— with that exquisite feel of "almost real" while at the same time being totally ludicrous.

It is really simple: the only thing we need to "brand" ourselves as a technology powerhouse is more successes. We've got almost all of the ingredients in just about the right quantities. What we are missing is minor attitude shifts on the part of investors, startup service providers (lawyers, landlords, etc.), and even entrepreneurs (I will write about the attitude shift needed in the last bucket more later). Oh yeah, and maybe some more global warming to take care of this "winter thing."

But come on— a $150,000 study on branding? Come on guys, if this is how we are going to waste money, we deserve to become irrelevant.

Comments Permalink

In this month's Wired, Clive Thompson has the best single piece of analysis on the netbook phenomenon. While he makes the standard argument that this anemic but affordable low-end disruptor took the big PC vendors by surprise and threatens to eliminate the last bastion of attractive profits in the commodity PC business, the feature-laden laptop, where the piece really shines is in the way that he traces the confluence of factors that led a Taiwanese company, Asustek, to become a powerhouse in launching this new category.

For Thomspon it was the combination of the design work started at OLPC, the design muscle that Asustek had built up over a decade of making, and eventually designing, PCs for the big American companies, and the shift in computer use to the web browser for most everyday computing tasks that allowed the EeePC to explode on to the scene. It is worth considering the power of these overseas ODMs (as opposed to an Original Equipment Manafucturer, an Original Design Manufacturer can play a big role in the design of a product top-to-bottom).

Thompson's money quote:

What Asustek proved is that the companies with real leverage are the ones that actually make desirable products. The Taiwanese laptop builders possess the atom-hacking smarts that once defined America but which have atrophied here along with our industrial base.

I can attest to the fact that every product we make these days has big contributions from the ODM even very early in the planning phases. For the most part this is a good thing, after all specialization and factor inputs tend to lead industries in this direction; however, as a non-hardware person, I've been surprised at how some design decisions seem to turn significantly on what the ODM can or can not do for a given project. More often than not American companies present specifications in the form of Word docs and not real engineering to companies like Asustek, Foxcom, and Quanta. It makes one wonder whether we have not opened ourselves up to a dependency that might be unhealthy for the types of R&D engineering innovations that made companies like HP in the first place.

Meanwhile the best analogy in the article is of the standard laptop to the SUV— a computer that is far too powerful and sold for the promise that one might actually do some simulated annealing work on it someday. And just like no momtank ever goes off road, most computer users (nongamers and nonprogrammers) barely venture off of the communications paved highway.

That said, it may just be that we are currently in a phase of personal computing where we are not delivering the software applications around experiences like immersive video or voice recognition that could really exercise local computing power in the client. Maybe, but as the power in a smartphone approaches that of a standard Atom netbook (and as these in turn start to adopt ARM cores for battery reasons), we might have just painted ourselves into a corner where those applications will either reside on server farms, or worse yet, not get invented at all.

Comments Permalink

For a good long while now I've been pondering the differences between the coasts when it comes to the successful commercialization of new technologies. It still astounds me that after the prominence that Route 128 had in minicomputers, it missed not only the PC but two succeeding waves of the development of the Internet while the raging optimism of the west coast gave us Apple, Google, and Facebook, as well as sustaining big companies like HP and Intel.

Just by chance, I happened to run across two pieces of media this weekend that, while not taking the question on directly, do leave one with the impression that commercialization around trends brought about by innovation might be something that is just culturally the purview of the west coast.

The first was a talk given by Stanford president, former entrepreneur, and one of my favorite textbook authors, John Hennessy on innovation in academia and the private sector. Hennessy has seen the process from both startups and academia and it is worth listening to him balance the need for hardcore long term research along with fast-moving product development. This is a guy that gets that you need fundamental advances like the microprocessor or the Internet before you can have a vibrant ecosystem of startups commercializing it— and he's adamant that the Stanford ecosystem still has it going on.

Or to put it another way, as Marc Andreessen said to Charlie Rose: "each new platform enables a new layer of innovation, just like the pervasiveness of PCs with GUIs opened the door for the web browser and the commercialization of the Internet." Marc talks a mile a minute, a trait which I often associate with people trying to sound smarter than they are, but in his case he's got the goods— and his ridiculously opinionated views on just about everything (i.e., "the iPhone has been beamed in from five years in the future," or "Twitter is our new realtime electronic nervous system") make it one of the best Charlie Rose interviews ever.

In the middle of this absolute economic meltdown, what these two valley guys share that I think makes the west coast special in a way that the east coast just is not, is an unbridled sense of optimism that seems to make each almost manic when considering the sense of possibility engendered technology's march forward. I've been to far too many events as of late where people claim that the software industry is now "a mature business," or that the "Web 2.0 party is now officially over—" usually right before they start talking about some crazy shit like buying gold coins or getting a plot in Costa Rica to retire to, so it is particularly good to be reminded by these two of why we're all in this business to begin with.

Maybe it really is just about the weather!

Comments Permalink

I love my Kindle 1. It beats carrying a whole bunch of books around when traveling for work, and as many reviewers have noted, as soon as you start reading a book on it (and get used to the tricks required not to accidentally advance the pages) it just melts away and lets you focus on the content itself.

But having taken it on vacation for the first time this week, I've noticed something interesting about my own behavior. Rather than sitting by the pool reading the Kindle, I found myself spending time on Google's excellent version of Reader mobile, taking great pleasure in actually having the time to read what I mostly just skim.

After burning through two full battery charges while reading content on the iPhone's tiny 3.5 inch screen, I began to wonder whether I might be able to get the same experience from the Kindle, first by trialing a number of the magazine subscriptions available, and then by forwarding custom issues of Tabbloid to it. In neither case however, was I left satisfied, preferring instead to resort to the tiny phone screen despite how unpleasant it is to spend an hour reading off of it.

Which is to say, for magazine and online content, the Kindle is flawed mostly because the combination of screen refresh rate and overall device speed make it a real offline device. You can not credibly follow links, share content, or send a quick email— three actions that I now realize are more critical to consuming perishable (timely) content than are glossy layouts, displays that don't tire the eyes, or even a number of product compromises that I would have previously considered dealkillers for a Kindle-like device.

[Funny to accuse a gadget that comes with a perpetual 3G data connection built in of that, eh?]

This new form of content consumption is why I'm fast becoming a believer in the 7-inch capacitive touchscreen form factor that Apple and others are rumored to be working on for release in the next year. Though a lot of things could be sacrificed on such a device, it would need three attributes to fit this new type of reading: 1. a killer web browser with as close to a ubiquitous Internet connection as can be arranged (either tethered to a mobile phone or directly wired into a 3G network), 2. battery life that is acceptable (2-3 hours would actually be ok so long as recharge time was 1 hour), and most importantly, 3. not too much weight on the device. Notice I said "too much" because I actually believe that a device that weighs say what my HP 1000 netbook weighs would actually be ok. Not great, but worth the compromise for the connectivity it would bring.

Note also that I didn't mention video, music, or any of the things that people clamor for their smartphones to be able to do. While I think that the ability to play back embedded Flash videos would be a nice feature) given how predominant embedded videos have become on web, it would not be essential. Nor would an "App Store" or any of the other things that the smartphone makers are now fighting to bring to market with new twists and turns.

Finally, I've recently become a big fan of the crude-but-effective "buckets of money" theory for consumer products. You buy an iPhone with money from the bucket for cellphone spending. You buy an LCD TV from the entertainment bucket, and so on. The challenge with a product like this is that the closest bucket is the PC spending one which could make it difficult to get a new toehold in the market. PC prices are plummeting and netbooks are quickly sucking up any new dollars there.

But I'd buy one!

Comments Permalink