(this is page 43 of 121)





Latest

Great companies polish their products until they are clear as glass, and great software companies do this despite the fact that it is often easier/more convenient/cooler to work on something completely new or to start over.

iPhone 3.0 is mostly polishing, with two game changers one one Achilles heel. And polishing is something Apple excels at. Sure, it is a little ridiculous to be heralding copy&paste but for the iPhone this feature, as well as universal search, MMS, multiple photo attachments, and landscape keyboard on all of the Apple apps, is a solid refinement of an already very polished user experience.

The first of the game changers is GameKit, a peer-to-peer library that works over the Bluetooth radio. Bonjour (mDNS) has always been on of the most exciting things about the iPhone platform but the 802.11 radio burns a lot of juice, and the need to have all of the peer devices on the same logical network (same SSID) has really held back the truly serendipitous mobile use cases. Get ready for all sorts of local social apps based on this feature. And to boot, GameKit also provides a set of objects for peer-to-peer voice chat— a great addition given how heinous the recording/playback sound APIs are and the fact that the device is optimized for this sort of stuff.

The micropayments system (StoreKit) is the second fantastic improvement. I can't believe that after 15 years of going at it, after Paypal and Amazon and Google Checkout— and even carrier billing— it's going to be Apple that is going to deliver us a truly flexible, ubiquitous, and affordable micropayment solution. While some developers for trial-to-pay capabilities, others for a "premium AppStore," and others still for subscription infrastructure, StoreKit seems like a great compromise that enables all of these modes of billing plus more. I'd expect to see that all of the real commercial efforts on the AppStore are soon going to move to a free download with all sorts of "pay up" toggles in-app that open more functionality.

Now for the ugly: no background processing? Seriously Apple WTF? For sure bad applications will trash the battery, but well behaved ones shouldn't and there is a well-known system of reviews and approval to police the overall ecosystem. What is even more ridiculous is that they are trying to pass off this XMPP push notification thing as a suitable substitute. Push notification is a nice thing and should be available on top of background processing, but it is not a good alternative.

Take the canonical example of an IM service app. With background notification, you need to establish a proxy process in the cloud that will log into your account and monitor it for incoming IMs, to then send a ping to Apple's notification router. Compare the moving pieces and overall complexity of this with a client on the device that stays connected while it can and falls off the network when it can thus terminating the session with the server. It seems much more prone to state errors to have that second proxy process in place. Now in the case of the big IM providers like AIM, this is already done for the IM-to-mobile gateway, but I fear that others may not have such an easy time wrapping network services in this two-tiered way, especially not ones which are built around a synchronous interaction model.

Overall, it looks like a solid incremental improvement though, and I expect that it will keep Apple firmly in the smartphone innovation lead.

Comments Permalink

24 is a great television concept and this season has been brilliantly executed. Occasionally though, even an ardent fan like me has to trip over the suspension of disbelief required to truly enjoy the show, and for whatever geeky reason, the portrayal of modern technology is always my own particular speed bump (I have a theory that geeks needs to point out the tech flaws to feel better about so whole-heartedly enjoying the larger plot issues like the terrorists that sneak into the White House through the sewers).

Last night, Jack Bauer escapes from custody in a hospital, Vulcan grips the security guard and runs off with the CD that contains all of the security video footage from the hospital (he is looking for a bad guy). He then smashes a car window where the owner happens to have left his Macbook in the passenger seat fully charged and ready for some counter-terrorist kungfu. As he rips away from the FBI at 55MPH down a 25MPH street, Jack nonchalantly opens the Macbook and pops the cd into the drive. And what is awesome is that instead of being some heinous Windows 3.1 security system with some crazy video format that was standardized in 1982 and abandoned in 1986, the security videos as conveniently archived as an iPhoto library which Jack is able to load up in mere seconds, proceeding to grab a frame and then use the awesome "terrorist face enhancing wand" to get a clear closeup from the grainy black and white video frame.
(Almost done here, bear with me as I have a point)
Because the Macbook's original owner is cheap and doesn't pay $80/month, Jack is then forced to take out his Sprint Novatel 3G modem which he pops into the laptop, and magically sans drivers, instantly establishes a strong EVDO signal to zip the picture of said bad guy to his accomplice in the FBI office.

As I was watching it happen, all I could do was think about how slow the real iPhoto is, how ridiculous it is that he's able to get the Sprint modem working without installation, and how awesome the fact that he doesn't have to know the FBI agent's email to send her stuff.

But as I thought about it more, I realized that we're really almost there today, and that this has been as a direct result of how fast the Internet has taken over our lives. In fact, iPhoto does act like a swiss army knife for many different types of video, Facebook and Twitter (and their inclusion into phones) are showing us the way which the address book can automagically find you recipients, and perhaps most impressively, 3G networks and their associated modems really do work the way they did in the show— and have become a totally normal and boring part of mobile computing. To say nothing of the progress of video conferencing, search engines, and all sorts of other technologies employed in 24 that are quickly becoming de rigeur for mainstream consumer users.

We do live in good times indeed.

And if you don't believe it, check out this hilarious sendup from Collegehumor.com on what 24 would have been like with 1994 technology.

Comments Permalink

Don't touch my screen!

A sign the ipod wonBack to my favorite punching bag topic for a moment: the cluelessness of laptop makers in the face on the iPhone-like interface onslaught. If this picture doesn't say it all, with the iPod Touch being favored over the "kid-friendly" OLPC by the 4 year-old, I don't know what does.

Except of course that according to the NYT this morning, now the PC makers want to get into the smartphone game which to me seems as far-fetched as the car companies getting into bicycles because they see how many people are buying them these days. The only remarkable thing about it is the fact that they might actually be able to put products in the market— but this speaks more to the power of the ODMs in getting almost anything built for those clipboard-wielding product managers.

Instead of that, or worse yet, jamming touch interface shells on standard laptops, why don't PC folks spend time thinking about the deep reasons why the iTouch devices have been successful? If aliens saw this, what would they think?I continue to believe that the "touchability" is effect and not cause— that the true reason of success for this new class of device is around the interface married closely to use cases of the mobile (small device) experience with great software-hardware integration.

After all, the Wii has shown us that we don't need touch to get to an intuitive and revolutionary interface. Come on PC guys, it's time to innovate!

Comments Permalink

Realtime. Dynamic Privacy. The social graph. If cool-sounding terms that mean relatively little were business models, we could have saved Web 2.0!

Look, there is some very real world-changing stuff going on in the primordial soup of social networking and micropublishing. Stuff that will affect how we work, play, and communicate for the rest of time. But it's not as complicated as people seem to need to make it. Just fresh from a run during which I listened to the talking heads on the Gilmour Gang overcomplicate things unnecessarily, I decided I'd had enough, that it was time for a simple explanation (perhaps more for me than for anyone else!). In case you feel that way too, here goes...

All of this stuff can be traced back to the instinctive need for the social animal to communicate. As a species we do better when we communicate, so we are hard wired to do it as much as we can. The revolution in electronic communications, namely email, took this to a whole new level with anyone being able to send anything to anyone in the world instantaneously. I was part of the first generation of people to go to work as corporate America was rolling out cross-company open email to desktops, and let me tell you it was an awesome thing to watch. Not so much for the folks like me who had had it in college, but definitely to the people that were coming from the closed Microsoft Mail and Lotus Notes systems and still depended on fax/Fedex/peons like me to get stuff to the partner/client/whoever.

And for the record, IM was only synchronous email, nothing more. All of the sociologists and cultural anthropologists who claim that it encourages more informal means of communicating have never seen two corporate drones flirting over a Blackberry-empowered network (I'll get back to how realtime is just an implementation detail in a moment, but the first time we saw it hailed as something different was in the email/IM faux distinction which is why I mention it here).

After the first dot-com collapse, there emerged this cool little standard called RSS for the syndication of published content. Anyone anywhere could author content and publish it— not as an email newsletter (which used to be popular if you remember) where you had to know, beg, borrow, or steal the exact list of recipients, but to the world who could then "pull" that content from you by subscribing to your stream of published items. It was a fantastic idea mostly because it provided a layer of indirection between writer and reader that was sorely missing from mediums like email and IM.

The problem: RSS never took off. It was too cumbersome to set up, explain, discover, and understand relative to the existing alternatives. I personally gave up evangelizing it to regular folks after years of getting "yeah, but why wouldn't I just go to the site?!?" and seeing that despite folks like Google (Reader) and FeedDemon (the thing in Outlook) getting the consuming implementation right, it just wasn't taking off.

Imagine my surprise then upon discovering that Twitter— an SMS app-turned-micropublishing service— has now evolved into RSS for the mainstream. Like many other people, I hate trying to follow conversations on Twitter— they most definitely feel like listening to half of an interesting conversation, or worse yet 1/25th of one— but I do love the quality of the links that I get from the dot-product of the people that I follow. I'm already a Google Reader convert but on weeks when I accumulate 4500+ items to go through, I find that Shift-A (the keyboard command to wipe them all away) is much easier to embrace because I've got a Twitter feed of content to summarize it all.

So, to repeat: what does Twitter give me? A layer of indirection between the people who are communicating interesting things with the world and me so that they can send great stuff my way without knowing or caring about who I am. This is powerful stuff because it allows me to take control of a torrent of communications that I find incredibly valuable but which I wouldn't be exposed to if I were just to have stuck to my parochial little address book. RSS publish-and-subscribe did it first, and arguably in a richer more open way, but it has turned out to be Betamax to Twitter's VHS.

What about all of those that claim that Twitter is "realtime" while everything else before it is not? Again, an implementation detail just like email and IM. There is no reason why RSS readers can not poll aggressively enough to simulate realtime especially in a world of distributed blogs where one service doesn't have to take all of the load. Google can (and is) updating selective parts of its index in close to realtime as well. Culturally, Twitter tries to enforce a difference with the 140 character limit (to borrow from evolution, an exaptation that came from the service's original desire to blend SMS and the web), but in reality there are plenty of valuable blogs that provide little more than title and link with each entry so that seems like a thin distinction.

Now, to close on Facebook. Unlike the one-way subscribe/follow relationship of Twitter, Facebook's roots come more from the standard addressbook/buddy list where relationships are bi-directionally approved. Friending is no different than adding someone to your buddy list in that it implies that you are now also in theirs except for the fact that the act is the used to filter a steady stream of communications on your behalf. The folks at Facebook are geniuses at doing this well once the relationship is established— both by rolling out a steady stream of really useful but lightweight applications (Photos for instance) and by encouraging "social signaling" behaviors (relationship status anyone?) on the part of their users that increase the volume of communication.

But where Facebook really hopes to innovate, and has in fact started to already, is in the process of discovering new bi-directional relationships on your behalf by stuff that can be as simple as exposing you to friends of your friends or finding your old school mates, and as complex as trying to match your "profile" with other people you might like.

Before the social networking craze of 2000+, there were many startups that died on the vine trying to tackle the more complex methods of forming new relationships automatically (Abuzz, Visible Path, etc.). All of these companies failed because they overthought the problem (certainly compared to Friendster, MySpace, and Facebook), but they were dead on about the fact that the evolution of the address book requires automatic updating with valuable contacts you may not yet know being added by using the power of electronic communications and good software.

I think that both of these innovations, the taking of publish/subscribe that RSS introduced into the mainstream and the growing of the dynamic address book are eventually going to be as big as email or the web itself. They will have to become open standards to truly thrive, and it will be tricky to find sustainable business models for all but the largest players (who can just monetize the eyeballs), but they are here to stay as permanent fixtures in the evolution of how we communicate.

The most important thing to keep in mind though is that both of these companies are playing on a continuum and not doing something that is so fundamentally new that we should go around inventing buzzwords and claiming we can not yet understand it. Jeff Bezos, while on Charlie Rose to pimp the new Kindle, told Charlie that the important thing to realize in technology companies taking the long view is that while the technology itself may change quickly, the core underlying customer need doesn't, and in fact tends to evolve slowly. We ought to keep this in mind when we consider all of these new communication platforms.

Comments Permalink

Small paperweights that I have at homeOm has a great piece on how Apple is for sure making a netbook that won't be like the Fischer-Price toys that vendors small and big are characterizing as the brightspot of the PC industry in 2008 (8 million units last year and expected to grow quickly).

His piece reminded me of having owned a Rio PMP500 way back before the iPod. It was amazing to replace the walkman I was using in much the same way that it is amazing to replace a Windows Vista luggable computer with a svelte laptop that just emanates portability. But as soon as you start using it for real you realize that the limitations far exceed the cool factor and quickly learn to supplement the device with a more traditional big sibling (in my case, I was doing a lot of cross continental travel and the PMP500 would only get me about an hour of music so I carried a Discman as well).

We are so desperate for volume in the PC industry during this global meltdown that we're not clearly applying the "bozo test" to this new segment (the bozo test states that only a bozo would back the business plan). In my case, I've now owned and tried to push 3 netbooks (if you count the OLPC) on my family only to have them prefer the iTouch form factor for most of the common computing activities.

More significantly, this weekend I went for a walk in Harvard Square, a fairly urban area full of students and young professionals alike, in search of spotting netbooks in the wild. The final tally: out of about 25 computers (and about the same number of smartphones), I spotted one Asus EeePC. I did however notice that about 35% of the laptops I saw were some form of MacBook (especially popular at Peet's), and more surprisingly still, plenty of iPhones. I even noticed one young woman waving an iPod touch around like a magic wand, trying to cast a spell to conjure some Internet.

Clearly this isn't a super empirical study but I'd love to see return rates on netbooks when they are purchased as primary computers. In the meanwhile, it is good news that Apple is trying to reinvent this category because once they do, there will be all sorts of vendors who will be fast followers and drive ubiquity for whatever that tweener formfactor ends up looking like. Unlike the MP3 case, there is no portable computer vendor that is asleep at the wheel on this transition to the second high volume post-PC device.

Comments Permalink