(this is page 37 of 121)





Latest

We need a GPL equivalent for websites that accrue user generated content as their main source of value. The way that it would work is that sites could adopt this license, a la Creative Commons, and be able to visibly display a logo that says they are compliant. Then in the event that the TOS (terms of service) of the site changed in any way (for instance, because the site was trying to institute some sort of a paywall), they would have to provide a suitable means of download for all of the data, much like Wikipedia does today.

This wouldn't keep entrepreneurs from building the next YouTube and it wouldn't prevent Google from paying billions of dollars for the value aggregated. It would however protect the content from dumb business model experiments. And more importantly, it would protect the users who contributed the work and effort under a different set of assumptions about the potential impact of their contributions.

I've been thinking about this ever since discovering earlier this week that Instructables.com— one of my favorite sites on the Internet— has decided to hobble their user-contributed database with a clumsily implemented paywall that blocks users from seeing alternative/hi-res images (and a few other things) to the projects written up on the site. This is a terrible move— not because I think Instructables shouldn't try to make money (more on that below), and certainly not because I am against paywalls per se (the Wall St Journal and Zagat are just fine)— but for the simple reason that in making this move now, Instructables has destroyed value contributed by its users under a different set of starting assumptions about what the site was going to do with the content they put up. In so doing, they changed the rules mid-game to the detriment of everyone involved.

While it is true that most regular consumers of content wouldn't care about the GPL equivalent for content much in the same way that most folks who use a Linksys router don't care about the GPLed code provided on the Cisco site, content authors would— especially the ones who spend painstaking hours documenting how to make a continuously rotating servo for the betterment of mankind only to discover that their work has become the pawn of some business model chess game most startups have already lost.

Now, back to making money. I think it is a great thing to do especially for a site as rich in possibilities for monetization as Instructables. How about the site sell a premium print magazine of the best projects every month? How about t-shirts? How about seminars with the "experts"? A conference like Maker Faire but on a smaller scale with Meetup-like distributed dynamics?

Now I'm sure that the guys there have thought of all of these possibilities and many more so my point here isn't really to come up with a new business model for them, but to suggest that there may be some out there that are not quite as corrosive to the mission of becoming the public documentation tool for the DIY generation— a very worthwhile one— that they initially set out upon.

And in the meanwhile, who's going to get this GPL for user-generated content thing going? Because we're going to need it— especially mobile devices empower all sorts of very valuable location-aware content authoring over the next decade.

Comments Permalink

Economists have this concept called path dependence for explaining how non-market driven equilibrium can result from past historical decisions that keep the market from developing to a more efficient point. VHS, sewers, and most natural resource-rich Latin American economies are prime "victims" of path dependence. It's an interesting concept that Tomi Ahonen has recently applied to the development of the smartphone market in the US versus the rest of the world in a rambling but insightful post.

Ahonen, a former Nokia employee and mobile consultant argues that the US has a very warped view of what constitutes a smartphone due to the path dependence of the smartphone being born in this country out of the PDA (or pocket computer) vision which sacrifices hard keyboards for screen size, and more importantly, efficient text input for application flexibility and real estate. European and Asian usage, he argues, has always been driven by the prevalence of SMS (something we didn't wake up to here until just last year) and as such, fast typing rules the roost.

However his most controversial point to do with the unique American view of the smartphone is around the future of the smartphone as a type of PC with the user customizing its functionality via AppStores:

By far the most of those 160 million buyers did not for one second consider "what operating system does this have, what apps can I download to it". You and I may have done so. You and I care. The mass market is not like you and me. And the Apple iPhone customer today is not a typical mass market customer. Do not kid yourself. Those who bought an average smartphone last year wanted a certain high-end phone with certain abilities and that given smartphone happened to match that need. Its operating system and any applications had ZERO bearing on the decision. Not for mass market consumers.
...
We do not buy - and the mass market will not ever buy - smartphones so that they could install some apps to it. The vast majority of users will be contented with the apps that come pre-loaded, and then they go to web based services to get their additional benefits.

I'm not sure he is right here. Just as we were blind to the addictive power of SMS in the US until recently, it seems that the European/Asian analysts seem blind to the power of user customized mobile computers. Perhaps our path dependence is in a different direction overall— that is assuming that it becomes economically viable to survive as a mobile applications developer.

And then again, maybe we're all in the Apple marketing vortex and at some point down the road we'll wonder why we thought that loading native 3rd party apps was such a big opportunity.

Comments Permalink

Something I've heard recently was that Twitter's silver bullet when it comes to a business model will be a sort of Paypal 2.0 that blends universal login with a payments system that they can skim pennies off of. And while I think Paypal is more ready for a 2.0 disruption than any other legacy web service (it is appalling how bad it still is), I think it would be a dumb and dangerous thing for us as users to expect to rely on another vendor— and specifically a startup that has had trouble scaling from day 1— for something as critical to the next phase of the evolution of the consumer Internet as a payment system.

Ideally I'd love to see OpenID (which finally seems to be gaining traction) extended to allow many providers to offer payment clearing services on top of many providers already providing authentication services. Now I know this may be a bit of a pipe dream— after all, it has taken OpenID more than 5 years to come close to the required ease-of-use for a simple username/password challenge, but when it comes to payments, it is much much more critical to keep it open.

Think of the power of an open ecosystem like this: first and foremost, the payment handlers that could migrate to it like the merchant account folks or credit card companies already have tons of experience reliably clearing payments, maintaining security, etc (and sure while they have an innovator's dilemma type of issue, I am confident they would eventually see the light of day). And more importantly, competition would be a very good thing indeed if our goal is to avoid the stagnation that Paypal has suffered at the hands of eBay.

A related example: today Facebook opened up its public page user registration system for picking usernames and people rushed to make sure to get their favorite handles. To me this makes Facebook smell a lot like a DNS registrar— which again, seems like a really dumb responsibility to hand over to startup that has yet to make money, no matter how many users they have (here is a nice suggestion for avoiding the Facebook as the people's DNS problem, a least a little bit).

Finally if the open standards approach doesn't work with payments, I sure hope we standardize on a vendor like Amazon or even Apple that already has proven experience running billions of transactions through their shopping cart.

But another Paypal? No thanks.

Comments Permalink

Emerson's wisdom on startups

At the office today, we were having a conversation at lunch about startups and how to make them successful. The discussion reminded me of a question folks have been asking me a lot over the last year as the economy has been cratering and B rounds have been all but nonexistent: how can you get your startup to a successful exit?

I've been saving this quote since before we were acquired by HP in 2007 but now seems like a fitting time for it:

As to methods there may be a million and then some, but principles are few. The man who grasps principles can successfully select his own methods. The man who tries methods, ignoring principles, is sure to have trouble.
— Ralph Waldo Emerson

It is the same with startups: the main principle to grasp is that building value for the enduser is the best way to be successful. There are far too many gyrations to do anything but, despite what all of the entrepreneurs, investors, and advisors who are fooled by randomness might claim about how to win.

Build something people love that solves a hard technical problem in the process and something good is likely to happen most of the time. Outside of that it doesn't matter which development methodology you use, which viral loops you bake into your service, or even what your customer acquisition economics look like. These are but methods to be tweaked once you know you've built real value.

Comments Permalink

It's not been a good week for AT&T with all of the ire the company has taken from frustrated iPhone users who can not MMS or tether and who will not get a nice subsidy discount on Apple's shiny new product. To top things off, Saul Hansell is now using the megaphone of the NYTimes to take the carrier to task for its privacy policy, or more specifically for its ability to use our location information to its own ends:

But the company [AT&T] is saying more clearly than most other big companies that it knows a lot about you, that it will use that information to help it make more money in any number of ways, that it will keep the data for as long as you remain a customer, and that it can be forced to give all that information to the government without giving you the chance to object

I suspect that all current telcos are buying themselves options here given how unpopular wireless carriers are with their subscribers in the first place, I'd think that they might want to keep a close ear to how users might react the first time they are interrupted with a pushed ad that uses information the carrier has obtained and sold by virtue of the privacy policy.

Who knows? Now that Sprint is selling bandwidth to other types of devices, we might have an opening for an MVNO that is more worried about end users than protecting its own business model. It didn't work the first time around but with the increasing amount of power that device manufacturers have with their branded smartphones, should the carriers get too egregious, it might work next time.

Comments Permalink