(this is page 28 of 121)





Latest

The "App economy" is all over the place, even gracing the cover of Businessweek in the latest issue. Loads of attention, and as of late, seemingly lots of dollars, with Apple and Facebook being the two app hosting platforms that get the most airtime.

Of course, the only real innovation in these so-called "apps" (to me they are much more like traditional application features that user can then assemble themselves) is the fact that they bring a business model for content and software that goes beyond advertising to the consumer Internet. Both initial purchase and the subsequent in-app purchase represent the micro-transaction model that everyone has been dying to have for almost two decades now.

When Apple kicked this off with the iTunes Music Store, I was convinced that the trick had been to take the consumption of the paid-for digital goods off of the traditional PC environment and into a proprietary device like the iPod. I felt that across device boundaries, consumer expectations for what is for-pay and for-free can be reset, whether it is for MP3s, news readers, or just about anything else that is presumed to be free on the most prevalent device for accessing this stuff today, the PC. On that device, we've already screwed the pooch, and consumers expect to get it all for free and ad-supported.

Then I read about Zynga, whose CEO spoke at the Web 2.0 conference this week and who seems to be bucking that trend, with millions of users paying real money for the virtual goods and currencies that power their PC-based, Facebook-distributed casual games. They don't have a closed ecosystem or a new device with which to reset consumer expectations about what is for pay. Except of course that on the Internet, people have always expected to pay for the high-end gaming experience (look at the success of WoW), so perhaps Zynga's real magic has been extending that expectation downwards into realm of the free ad-supported casual games that have been prevalent on the Internet over the last 15 years.

I'd still bet on this "device resets payment expectations" theory which explains why the race is on for content providers to bring out as many new form-factor e-readers as possible. Or why, for instance, the exploding smartphone market may be the most interesting playground for consumer Internet startups that we've seen in quite a while.

Comments Permalink

I've recently told a couple of first-time entrepreneurs that a venture backed startup is like throwing the parts of an airplane off a cliff and hoping that you've got a tall enough cliff and a good enough team to assemble the aircraft before you hit the ground. It's a bit dramatic, but it generally gets the point across.

Last night though I came across a better analogy in the form of the Wikipedia article on the "Gimli Glider," an Air Canada 767 that, due to a series of small errors by people on the ground and in the cockpit, managed to run completely out of fuel at 41,000 feet mid-flight (the article is a gripping read). The pilots, experienced with gliders, managed to find a runway and glide several miles to a crash landing such that everyone survived.

A venture backed startup, or the ecosystem around it, is quite similar to the one that caused the Gimli mistake. Your board, advisors, and team are responsible for making hundreds of small decisions, some based on analysis, some experience, and a whole bunch of just gut alone, that are usually only tested "system-wide" along the trip when you go to raise money. And when enough of those decisions compound in the wrong direction, you can find yourself at 41,000 feet without any fuel and not a runway in sight. In those situations, the best entrepreneurs are able to calculate glide ratios that land the company either at another funding event, or often times, at a suitable corporate acquirer— but this too, has a huge element of luck.

To continue the analogy with Gimli, the scariest thing is how often it is not about one big decision, but a whole bunch of little ones along the way, which add up to one big bad outcome. This is why I am such a huge fan of what Eric Ries has been proselytizing in the form of the "lean startup," a very effective way to test the validity of all sorts of small decisions, from business ones to technical/architecture ones, along the way. When I think back to my last startup, Tabblo, I think of of the things we did right were right out of the lean startup playbook, without knowing that is what we were doing.

Bootstrapped startups often do this sort of thing out of necessity— but increasingly, the better venture backed startups are doing it as a way to avoid the Gimli situation. And that is a good thing for the ecosystem as a whole.

Comments Permalink

GutenborgDave and I went to see the Gutenborg today, a robot that can print and bind a softcover book in some reasonable amount of time without human hands touching it. They've got it installed at the Harvard Bookstore (in Cambridge), and if you like books and robots, it is worth checking out.

As it happened, the machine was getting serviced when we showed up. But we were treated to a nice chat with John, one of the hardware engineers who has been working on the printer part of it. Talking to him was a good reminder that even in the realm of hardware, small focused teams can make a huge difference in the product development process.

As for the machine itself, it's not clear to me that this particular invention will be solving the book world's backlist problems any time soon. Much like the Roomba, this is one robot that seems to still be straddling the line between novelty and usefulness in a way that indicates we're a few years away from the Star Trek replicator fantasy coming true.

What was fun to see however, was how many pieces of the Gutenborg are now available to hobbyists everywhere. Its brains for instance, were composed of a Mac Mini with a USB hub that drives something that looks like a big boy version of one of the Arduino motor shields. And most of the robot's structure is built from an aluminum skeleton that Andy has been raving about called the "80/20 Aluminum Industrial Erector set." Even the perfect binding system the robot was using seemed to be lifted from most of the low-tech, low-cost binders I've seen in my days in the digital photo book business.

As more of this knowledge gets spread broadly, I am sure that entrepreneurs and hackers will find better ways to bring useful robots into new domains of our daily lives. And I for one welcome our coming Cylon overlords.

Comments Permalink

As we all get barraged by the fight that is shaking out in the media between Verizon and AT&T, there is only one thing that I think should matter to folks that really make use of their 3G smartphone as an all-purpose portable computer:

On the Verizon (or Sprint) EVDO networks, you can not talk on the phone AND use data services at the same time. I'm not sure if this is due to the EVDO implementations that the US carriers have chosen, or something more specific to EVDO technology as opposed to HSDPA (what AT&T uses), but either way, if you are on the phone, your new-fangled smartphone is reduced to an adult-sized portable gaming machine. That is: no network access for you.

I know people hate the AT&T network and that Verizon is supposed to have more coverage. I know AT&T customer service sucks and that customers feel nickel-and-dimed all the time. But to me (a formerly loyal Verizon customer), no data and voice at the same time is an absolute deal killer. And what is more, I suspect that this is increasingly true for everyone who is really aggressively using their smartphones.

How could all of the advertising and compare wars be missing this?

Comments Permalink

Microsoft losing the Danger customers' data in such an irrecoverable and catastrophic way has reminded me of something that I've been thinking about ever since HP bought Tabblo and put the future of our own users' data in doubt.

On the one hand, who is to say that a little startup is any more reliable than a monster tech company when it comes to keeping data safe? After all, don't most startups die anyway? And when they do, you the user don't usually end up doing better than an announcement that says something like "In 30 days we're shutting everything off; have at it!" which does little to help transition anything.

On the other hand, startups— and particularly those that rely on user-generated content— have an alignment of incentives to the death with their users that usually counts for more than executive reorgs and organizational recharters when it comes to keeping that data safe and online. Data loss does happen (after all, competence handling a server falls into a normal distribution like any other skill), but the reality is that I feel much safer trusting the preservation of my data to a little company ten times out of ten provided I understand the little company's business model well enough to know that my data won't ever be used in a way I don't like.

Of course, big companies are going to keep buying little companies— this is, after all, the very definition of success in our ecosystem. But what we may need to do as an industry is come up with some sort of GPL-like contract with our users that allow them to reasonably port their data away should the company experience a "change of control" event. I've written about a similar issue around the business model inspired paywalls like the one Instructables threw up last year, and in some ways this case quite similar.

What is the downside to this approach? Acquirers might not be too fond of the fact that they'd have to open up their servers and work towards giving users a path out. In fact, in some cases I could see such a term being used to try to argue for a discount on the acquisition price (this used to be pretty common for instance, when startups used certain open source software components).

But I'd imagine that if you were a Sidekick user today and had lost half of your contacts because the JV team has been doing your SAN migration due to a "corporate re-prioritization," you might think twice about sticking around for the next service you put your data into once it migrates to a different corporate entity. It's why I stopped using Friendfeed the moment Facebook bought them (despite liking the service and having nothing against Facebook). It's why I was glad never to have jumped on the Mint.com bandwagon once I saw they were going to Intuit. In each of these cases, I may be on the leading edge, but I think people will clue in.

Comments Permalink