What was great about open source in 2000 was that it was a small club. Sure, Cobalt has sold to Sun for a lot of money, and sure Red Hat and VA Linux were on their way to IPO boom-and-bust. But it was still the case that if you were reading Slashdot to get your Hauppauge TV encoder card to do the Tivo on your Linux box, or learning the new-fangled ipchains utility to get your Gnutella client to work, you were definitely in the land of the Morlocks. Just a bunch of geeks talking to other geeks about doing things that most normals couldn't even dream of— Pringles can antennas to boost Wifi signals and sniping cron jobs that always let you win at eBay— "magic" to the rest of the world.
This has all changed— in part because of social networks, and in part because of the smartphone. As Patton Oswalt writes in the latest issue of Wired, geek culture is now mainstream: it is "cool" for Zuck to go on 60 Minutes and talk about speed chess while your accountant next door neighbor tells you about the latest iPhone app that tracks fuel consumption. While the geeks were busy thinking they were inventing the world, the world caught up. And sadly, we geeks now find ourselves scooped by the guy who spends every night surfing the AppStore for the greatest and latest or the guy who is watching his Twitter feed for the demos from the latest Meetups.
What to do about this?
Well outside of the fact that it's important to realize that "geek culture" is now akin to talking about "Gap culture," we might go back to first principles and think a bit about what we were all after in the first place:
1. a network that connected anyone to anyone independent of existing structures of control
2. a way to consume the content (or anything) we wanted when we wanted
3. a way to make computers augment our own intelligence
On items #1-2, I'd say we ought to just give up the ghost— it's happened and it is televised, mainstream, and on Facebook. #3? Not so much.
So maybe the way to cut this problem is to let geek culture die on things like "on demand" and "connecting with people" and focus instead on the fact that we've not yet cracked the problem of computers truly augmenting our intellect. Not in the way that Doug Englebart meant back in 1968.
When I think abut the subcultures that might be most relevant to this, I think of artists using computers to create not better art, but entirely new art forms altogether (like personal fabrication or locative art). I think of product managers who think about immersive experiences and bringing together online and offline in new ways (Virgin "touchpoints" for the rest of our lives). I also think of all of the programmers working hard to create ontologies in places where dumb indexes that are blindingly fast give us the false impression that services can divine what we want (semantic web junkies rejoice!). And perhaps most importantly, I think about the folks that have already taken a broadband-connected pocket computer for granted and are trying to puzzle out what a world mediated by this crowd-empowered outboard brain looks like.
Put another way, I think the next relevant subculture coming to us is from China and India, and other places where the PC never stuck and the smartphone landed even more definitively. I think it may look like "For the Win" or something quite different. What it doesn't look like though is geek chic— 60 Minutes speed chess and Harvard dropouts talking about "utilities."
The geek subculture didn't die, it just went mainstream. And now it is time to look elsewhere.