My goal with this blog

I write about relevant changes in the way that people use the web and how startups are built to provide services and products for this ever changing wonderful thing we still know as "the web." As a former entrepreneur turned early-stage investor, my greatest hope is for this to be useful to other folks that are like me in the hopes that they can avoid some of the mistakes I've made.

Weak ties and weak work

In the fabulously executed Facebook movie, Jesse Eisenberg (the Zuckerberg character) continually bristles at his partner's early attempts to make money through advertising, claiming that it is too early to tell "what this is," the clear implication being that Facebook is bound to be something much much bigger than just another marketing channel.

I couldn't help but think of that repeated line as I read Malcolm Gladwell's piece in the New Yorker this week on social media and its mixed track record when it comes to empowering meaningful activism. Gladwell's argument centers around the claim that the weak ties encouraged by the poster children of social media (namely Facebook and Twitter) are terrific for information sharing but insufficient when it comes to the kind of involvement that makes change happen. In the piece he debunks the much touted myth that the hashtag surfing causists who tweetblogliked and otherwise expressed opinions about what was going on in Iran actually had any meaningful impact, at least compared to the students participating in the de-segregation protests of America in the 1960s.

It is a glib argument in some ways: the real comparison would be to the Iranian protesters who merely took advantage of the amplification provided by realtime communications networks like Twitter to shine a light that might have actually helped to change the degrees of freedom available to the regime in power.

Still, the piece does a good job of calling out the difference between collaboration and relationships in the era of weak ties between people who found little reason to stay in touch before the cost of doing so plummeted to zero. Assuming for a moment that most of us have mostly weak ties on these networks (which empirically is the case for me) and that most of these ties do not in fact graduate over time to becoming stronger ones capable of sustaining committed effort to achieve a goal (as say you do at work every day), it gives one pause in considering what this whole social media thing might just be.

To that end, one of my own nagging worries when it comes to social media is that most of the way that I see it presented these days is as yet another cheap marketing channel to acquire people (be they users, customers, or "products" as is the case with most dating/job reinventions these days) in order to feed commerce. In any other corner of the world not dominated by the idealism of the early hacker/Internet pioneers, this would be called direct-response marketing and if you don't believe me, head to the bowels of Connecticut where direct marketing is practiced as the highest form of art and talk to anyone there about what Twitter and Facebook are doing for the world.

Meanwhile, I want to believe that there is something here that is more powerful than just the latest version of Internet as marketing channel. Just as open source was the most transformative net-powered movement of the last decade, I'd love to see social media emerge as a fundamental way to organize the fruit of human labor in an ass-kicking, landscape-changing force (and I mean one that goes beyond farming virtual animals). While we get there though, it's worth having a little anti Kool-Aid Gladwell along the way.