During the first professional meeting I ever had with anyone at Apple in the summer of 2001, a senior designer named John G. took one look at the Sony Vaio Z505 laptop I was presenting from and said something that stuck with me ever since. "Look at the cheap antics in the design of that laptop," he said with the disgust thick enough to spread on a cracker, "you can tell it's not lasting design by how much that thing already looks like last year's model."
That meeting came whipping back in my memory tonight as I saw Francesco Mugnai's collection of Mac OS screenshots dating all the way back to System 1. If you've spent any time on the Mac OS train, it is worth scrolling through to see what John was talking about. Unlike the already pastel-infused Web 2.0 design aesthetic, there is a beautiful timeless coherence which goes back all the way to the days when the displays on the machines were less capable than what I've got on my voltmeter today.
I used to think that it was too difficult to see this type of timeless design without the benefit of hindsight, but I've come around on that one. You can spot it— it's just a matter of looking for the "cheap antics." And here's a hint: they're usually totally divorced from function.