This week's Atlantic has a fantastic piece, "The Kindle Problem," on a fundamental tension that affects anyone trying to build a product or service. In it, Kevin Maney argues that any new offering must pick between one of two axes of differentiation: convenience or experience, where the former is defined by making something much easier, and the latter much better. In a nutshell, he argues that the Kindle falls into some dead space in the middle— not as convenient as reading books on a mobile phone and nowhere near as good as a real book.
On the Internet, we've forgotten about this age-old tension because for a long time now we've been so far over on the experience side of the house— poking at the opportunities that were simply not possible before a ubiquitous high speed digital network that anyone could get on existed— that users, developers, and business folks have been willing to give up on delivering solutions focused around the convenience axis. Take eBay as the prototypical example: what it enables, person-to-person trade of almost anything irrespective of geographic limitations, is so amazing that we've put up with a horrendous user experience for 15 years now. Ditto for Craig's List. In fact, it is hard not to think of a really popular web service (save perhaps Amazon's original bookstore) and not see an example of this.
There are signs that this is changing though. As a recent article on the TC50 conference argued, industry pundits are shifting from "wow, I didn't know you could do that!" to "show me how this is useful." Part of this is endemic to the economic boom and bust cycles. But it may also be that as a technology, the web has now left its infant phase, and as a result, all of us working in it ought to internalize Maney's advice to Amazon about the Kindle.