Bob Metcalfe, while reminiscing about his days at Xerox PARC, and the specific passions of each of the researchers there once told me: "When it comes to what you are interested in doing, just remember that every one gets stuck on to something... and when you do, you should hope that you get stuck on something like Ethernet and not something like X" where X was a relatively obscure PARC technology.
I can't help but think of his advice that day every time that I see people from Boston area startups trying to "Web 2.0"-ize the latest version of their Lotus Notes-esque vision. And now it would seem that even Google is catching this particular disease.
Let me back up; broadly speaking (code for: huge generalization about to come), the evolution of personal computing seems to be split in three major phases:
1. The productivity revolution: incited first by the PC and then by the mainstream adoption of the GUI, this was the era of the spreadsheet and the word processor. These were the halcyon years when people realized that computers could have a tremendous impact on workplace productivity.
2. The networked productivity evolution: starts with Lotus Notes (the PC embodiment of all that people who'd had access to networked workstations had learned) and ends with Google's contributions to dynamic browser applications. Most of the Internet's killer apps fall into this bucket, and if you squint just so, even search and e-commerce belong in this broad bucket.
3. The social twist: though most of today's social Internet apps had their roots in networked productivity, they've since evolved socializing as a purpose of their very own. People go to Facebook "to facebook" not because they are hoping to get a particular task done. Similarly, despite all the exhortations about how Twitter is "the next step" in search, the reality is that it is first and foremost an interesting milieu for social interaction.
Now, here is where Metcalfe's advice comes in: when folks that grew up in phase 1 tried to build web companies in the mid 90s, we got productivity apps in the browser that failed to recognize that it was the network that really changed things (by enabling collaboration and server-held state, a.k.a. "the cloud").
I could start listing Boston companies that fell into this trap, both during the one-to-two transition and during the two-to-three but ultimately I am not sure whether there are more of them per capita than in any other tech hub except Silicon Valley. Perhaps what we should be wondering is why the folks in the Valley have managed to avoid these competency traps whereas those in Silicon Alley, Research Triangle, and Route 128 have not.
Except that now even my favorite networked productivity company, Google, seems to be trying to get all jiggy with social features. And the results are sort of gross. For instance, you get this heinous fly + man in transporter creation like "Google Reader + social" which leaves those of us who used Reader happily for years scratching our heads.
Perhaps we all ought to remember that, as Metcalfe says, the thing that matters is getting stuck on to something meaty and meaningful. And since I believe there is still so much untapped potential to the "networked productivity" phase, this seems like a good place to park. Maybe once we've done with the euphoria of tweeterbookspacing, some more folks around here will remember that.