My goal with this blog

I write about relevant changes in the way that people use the web and how startups are built to provide services and products for this ever changing wonderful thing we still know as "the web." As a former entrepreneur turned early-stage investor, my greatest hope is for this to be useful to other folks that are like me in the hopes that they can avoid some of the mistakes I've made.

Feed reading need not be social, just good and useful

Alex Payne has a thoughtful post on the future of feed readers where he argues that the current model (as best exemplified by Google Reader) is dying, and that all of the social replacements (Digg, Reddit, Twitter, Facebook) don't quite get us back to the same place.

I agree; back in 2001 I was convinced that RSS, pub/sub, and feed readers were a chocolate and peanut butter technology combination that would someday be as mainstream as IM. People have argued that their failure to attain mass market status was a result of the geekiness and complexity of "subscribing" to new content, but having turned a bunch of people on to Google Reader only to see them abandon it in short order, I have a different take: to me, the failure in feed readers has been all around content curation. And more importantly, since the atomization of feeds in feed reading, brought about by the aforementioned social replacements, that curation task has shifted to the "wisdom of the crowds," which— while hardly perfect— does take a step forward from what we were getting from the feed reading ecosystem.

Let's take an example from a related space, photo sharing: when Flickr first upended the traditional photo sharing category, people were quick to claim that it was their social dimension or their "default to public" attitude that made all the difference. And while these features were important to its success, I think the real innovation of Flickr was the atomization of the traditional "photo album" metaphor that everyone until them had taken for sharing photos online. By allowing and expecting people to share one photo at a time (and then making most of the other "open" feature differences), Flickr made itself a much more dynamic system for discovering and consuming relevant photo content quickly.

This is the same thing that a social news site like Hacker News achieve with feeds. Most of the content exposed in the top 10 list is actually pumped out in RSS by individual bloggers, but by atomizing it and using the community to curate the day's best content, the general user doesn't have to bother managing relationships with the individual subscriptions.

And if if that was good enough, I'd be the first one to let classic feed readers like Google Reader fade into the sunset. But all of these social aggregators seem good at getting me the B/B+ content that overlaps sufficiently with everyone else's interest— just not the A content that really makes me think. For that I think the right approach requires knowing too much about me and my particular tastes and reading habits.

Which by the way, a properly instrumented version of Google Reader could do more easily than any social app. If you've ever looked at the metrics page of Reader, you'll get a glimpse of the power of collecting this type of data: what you read, when, and for how long. If I were the PM on Reader, I would forget about all of this social sauce they are trying to port over from Facebook, Twitter, and Friendfeed, and focus instead on algorithmic curation of the atomized feeds in a given subscriber's account. Some of these tasks would be basic, such as intelligent de-duplication or time-based views of the newest content ("when I am at work, I only want to read 4-hour work week-ish stuff"), but others would require the level energy being applied to things like the Netflix recommendation algorithm with its associated $1MM prize.

Because one thing is very true: Google Reader with 200 subscriptions takes way too long to get through, and about 30% of the time is wasted on tasks that algorithms could cut out of the process for us.

When everyone zigs you should zag. As the rest of the web descends to a least common denominator social orgy for surfacing good content, Google would do well to remember its strengths and double down on making machine curated feed reading suck less.