First Google skids and then Microsoft comes in with an aggressive bid for Yahoo. Oh how we are coming to the end of this Web 2.0 party quickly.
I think it is a wonderful idea to put Microsoft and Yahoo together for a couple of reasons. First, despite what you may think about Microsoft, one thing they know how to do is build software at platform scale, something that Yahoo desperately needs to build the social platform they rightly seem to be intent on bringing into existence. Unlike Google and Facebook, the best elements to Yahoo's social platform were purchased and despite best efforts to bring them together under one Yahoo umbrella, they still feel like really different properties. Hopefully Microsoft can do the Office thing to Yahoo's best properties (Flickr, Mail, Finance, etc.) and make the whole thing feel well integrated. And in a bonus round they might also bring their whole developer-community effort to Yahoo's nascent attempts at building such a thing around Yahoo UI and a few web services.
The second reason why this is a good idea is that Microsoft can afford to take a much longer view on Yahoo's turnaround than Jerry & co. can under pressure from Wall Street. Just as they are nurturing the whole XBox platform, giving Yahoo room to breathe during the creation of its social platform could leave Microsoft with a great asset. Plus, the same could be said for a combined ad platform.
Finally, and despite the fact that this never happened with Hotmail, Microsoft-Yahoo could really deliver a seamless integration between rich client and web services. Every day that passes this becomes less and less relevant (as web browsers get better and people get used to the benefits of the cloud), but it's still going to be a while before we get back to ubiquitous broadband/4G, and in the meanwhile the combination of Yahoo's web savvy (including its recent acquisition of Zimbra) with Microsoft's emerging client platforms (.NET in the mainstream and Silverlight on the bleeding age) could conjure up some interesting brews. This was after all the idea behind the Adobe-Macromedia merger— which seems even more compelling in this case because it is not just two tools companies, but one of the greatest tools companies with a massive audience company.
Since I've been traveling I haven't had a chance to check on what the reaction to the announcement has been; however, I'm sure there are plenty of people who are using Scott McNealey's expression from the old HP-Compaq merger ("it's like two dumptrucks crashing into each other in the night"). While I can sympathize with the sentiment, we might pause to consider how the whole HP-Compaq thing has borne out— vaulting HP past Dell as the marketshare leader in PCs and notebooks and re-invigorating HP's entire PC business.
Might Yahoo not do the same for Microsoft's web businesses?