So it's too early to tell whether I can really give the OLPC a firm thumbs-up (or a definite trashing). From using it myself, and watching my five year-old play with it, I have two observations: 1. the hardware is really cute and definitely right-sized for children, and 2. the machine is really slow. About 45 seconds to boot up an application like the web browser and no less than 25 seconds on any other app.
I realize complaining about its slowness is unfair as this is a machine destined for third world hands who will likely never see anything faster and thus not know to expect better. Given that the machine is meant for kids though, I do feel somewhat justified in complaining about the fact that the OLPC folks have jammed too much software into it and made the overall discoverability of the "fun" applications for kids that are not quite literate too hard. Witness Alex (the 5 year-old in the photo) who has thus far only taken to the "Memorize" game (sort of like the old game with pairs of matching cards you flip over) and to typing his name over and over in 48pt type in the word processor. Between these two activities I think he could entertain himself for hours. However, the challenge is that any time he hits some part of the global navigation interface, he quickly gets himself in trouble. And unfortunately, this problem is compounded by the slow load time of new applications and the inevitable swapping that starts to quickly slow the machine to a crawl when you launch more than about 4 applications.
The ultimate test will be whether he sticks with it through these problems, coming to an adult when he is hopelessly stuck. At first I was skeptical that this would be the case, but then I remembered that as a kid, I spent countless hours playing with my father's Heathkit HERO 2000 kit under many of the same conditions: I would often get the robot stuck in such a way that only adult supervision would help unstick me (incidentally, I recently saw on Chris Anderson's blog that the HERO is coming back— yay!). In my case, the promise of controlling a robot kept me coming back for help.
Let's hope that the same applies for the kids looking to learn about the benefits of computers in the third world.
