My goal with this blog

I write about relevant changes in the way that people use the web and how startups are built to provide services and products for this ever changing wonderful thing we still know as "the web." As a former entrepreneur turned early-stage investor, my greatest hope is for this to be useful to other folks that are like me in the hopes that they can avoid some of the mistakes I've made.

Some thoughts on my new Eye-Fi and the cloud

Last year, a couple of us at Tabblo got a chance to get on the beta program of this really neat wireless camera card called Eye-Fi that automatically uploaded your pictures from your camera to your favorite photo site. The idea was very cute, and even as a beta, the implementation was very nice, so it was a fun surprise last week to receive the 1.0 version of the card in the mail. In the intervening year, the Eye-Fi guys seem to have polished their packaging and found great distribution for their product (Amazon, Walmart), while settling on a very sensible business model (sell the card at a slight premium to regular memory cards).

I like the Eye-Fi concept a lot and intend to give a couple of the cards out as Christmas presents this year. But after a week of constant use, I've been forced to rethink some of my assumptions about getting all of your content up into the cloud as quickly as possible, bypassing the PC at all costs.

While it is fun and sort of magical to see pictures just appear on your favorite Internet photo site (though arguably less now now that camera phones are so prevalent, especially those armed with awesome applications like Shozu), but the problem with getting your regular camera pictures sent automatically is that the mode of use for a typical digital camera these days is very much "ready, fire, aim" with most casual photographers using brute force as a substitute for innate skill, knowing that there is a nice editing step waiting inside of Picasa or iPhoto. When photos go straight to the cloud and into a service like Flickr (which is what I've been using with the Eye-Fi), that editing step disappears, which means one of two things happen:

1. you really frustrate people who might be following your picture stream on Flickr with twelve slightly different shots of the same subject in the same composition

2. you frustrate the hell out of yourself using a web interface to take on that first editing pass

Of course, #2 could all be fixed if Flickr were to support an IMAP-like protocol that iPhoto and Picasa could implement as rich clients to help you manipulate the photos and do the editing later (I have to admit that Flickr almost does this with their API today, but no mainstream clients have taken advantage of it). And in that case, having the data resident in the cloud where other applications could use it might justify someone using some basic algorithms around finding good unique pictures to solve #1 (I've seen a bunch of algorithms that do this very well with date-clustering and object detection inside of HP Labs, so this part is not science fiction).

In the meanwhile, it is worthwhile pausing for a moment as we all race to cut the venerable PC out of the content-device-Internet loop, and thinking about what we might be giving up.