While traveling this week, I discovered a really amazing radio show called "Radio Lab" from New York Public Radio (more specifically, I discovered its podcast). The first episode I listened to, on the ephemeral nature of memories, blew me away both from the quality of the content, and the way in which it was brought together by the show's producers.
The basic premise of the episode is that the old analogy that memories in the brain are stored like pages in a book (or more currently speaking, files on a hard drive) is actually flawed, and that memories are in fact stored in such a way that we re-create them every time we recall them (there is a better code + data analogy which I won't make here but is how I currently understand it). The piece really got me thinking about memory, identity, and what may come from all of us web who seem so obsessed with chronicling life in pictures, blog posts, and just about every form of digital excrement.
An example: right after listening to the piece, I found myself giving a toast at a wedding and trying to recall a story about the groom and I from sixteen years ago. As I felt my brain struggling to reform the memories, it occurred to me that this whole process would have been a whole lot easier in today's Facebook-enhanced world. The episode (and I won't go into it here) was exactly the kind of embarrassing thing that someone would now have caught with a digital camera; it would have made its way to Facebook, and ended up tagged with both of our names by all of our friends. And sixteen years from now it would be a trivial exercise for anyone preparing a toast to pull all of the interactions they've ever had with the person being celebrated— assuming of course that Facebook is still around. And not just pictures but comments, wall posts, blog posts— in short a whole lot of data that would go very far in helping assisting a more accurate reformation of those exact memories.
Progress, right? I've always thought so, for two reasons: because the act of chronicling is itself engages and rewards the author, and for the sake of history (even when you yourself are the historian coming back later to see how you've changed). It is after all exactly like Cory Doctorow wrote when he claimed that his blog served as his outboard brain. And in the Facebook example, the collective nature of the chronicling makes this outboard brain proposition even more compelling.
But the folks on the podcast made me think about whether this is in fact absolute progress. Apparently, every time you do the work of recalling a memory, you change it a little, according to the particular way in which your brain processes it at that given time. It is as though the process of bringing it to the surface bumps it against all of the stuff that has accumulated in your brain since the last time you thought about that particular memory. And in the process, the memory itself changes ever so slightly. Then when you put it away again, it goes back changed just a teeny tiny little bit. Less like what may have "objectively" happened, but a whole lot more "you" in the process.
Obviously the incessant chronicling of our lives doesn't have to affect this very human process for grooming memories over time. However, I suspect that this will only be the case for as long as the tools for chronicling our lives are lossy. Writing something down will almost always leave enough room for the memories around the words to evolve, and the photos we take are only snapshots of instants in time. But what happens when we've got Justin.tv style chronicling (assuming we could store, search, and excerpt it all)? What happens when the collective brain of all of your friends tagging and commenting puts enough perspectives in the chronicle to mitigate this process?
One of the hosts on the show made the incredibly insightful statement that in the end all we are is "a bunch of memories strung together." But from the sound of the rest of the show, it is a string that is always moving twisting slightly this way and that. I wonder what will happen as technology starts constraining the way in which we allow ourselves to move the string over time.