I've have four different exchanges with folks today about the puff piece that Jason Pontin wrote on Pownce in today's New York Times. Essentially Pownce seems like another social network Web 2.0 application that is trying to build its own messaging infrastructure. Maybe I'm not getting something about what is going on with these sites but my general thinking is that between the web, email, IM, and SMS (all relatively open albeit in decreasing order), we've got enough bricks to play with, and that building closed systems in the name of expediency is a waste of effort.
Jason Kotke nailed the general sentiment a few weeks ago when he accused Facebook of "becoming the new AOL." In jumping on its closed platform, developers are cutting a Faustian bargain at best— and especially so if the revenue model is not clearly split out.
That said, Facebook is a juggernaut, and as such not many can ignore their "platform" play. I'm almost ready to admit that their in-system messaging and status updates make sense. After all, there are millions of college kids hitting refresh 60-70 times a day in order to see what they might have otherwise seen in their inboxes and buddy lists. But a brand new startup attempting to replace email and IM?
I love the implementation of Pownce (especially because it's powered by Django and feels very fast and light). But I just can not see getting onto yet another identity network and another messaging platform just so that I can send big files around. And I think that the Pownce folks would do much better to focus on the features that could complement email and IM instead of wholesale replacing it. For instance, both of these mediums could use much better integration with SMS— and yet Pownce didn't even come out of the gate supporting SMS at all (which to me this was the killer feature that made Pownce's original inspiration so compelling).
Note: to anyone who still wants to try it, I've got a whole load of Pownce invites. Send me an email and they are yours— no need to be bidding on eBay.