Roger von Oech has a nice short post comparing his behavior when he reads articles online versus in print that makes the basic point that his relationship the content differs depending on whether he is flipping the page or scrolling with the mouse. Expectations, time spent, even conclusions drawn can vary, despite the fact that it's the same exact content.
The post underscores the premise that presentation matters, the fundamental underpinning of the graphics design profession. However, Roger also gets to something more: the commitment that a reader makes to a particular bit of content when he decides to consume it on paper. It is almost as though the act of stepping outside of the natural flow of screen life implies that a different mode of thinking is going to be used a different part of the brain engaged.
When we all became employees of HP, we were given this really sweet All-in-one printer to help us start thinking about how a printer is used in the home. In my case, this was the first time I've had a consistently reliable printer outside of work since I left my college dorm so I've been overconsuming paper and ink quite a bit. In fact, I've got this new pattern of consuming content where I star all of the items in Google Reader that I want to go back and consume on paper at a later point (as a general rule they have to be about 500 words or more and particularly thought-provoking for me though in my "skim to star" mode, I often get the latter wrong). Then, when I'm ready, I'll print off a whole bunch of posts and go through them as I might have a newspaper 10 years ago or the latest issue of the Economist on a Saturday morning. Right now this mode of consumption has two big limitations:
- The presentation of your average printed blog post sucks (but we're working on fixing that)
- There is no backchannel for communicating feedback on the really good stuff back into my electronic life (I can't add it to del.icio.us for example or email it to a friend)
but outside of these two limitations, I find that I'm doing more careful consideration of the arguments presented in the pieces when I consume them on paper. This whole Facebook/F8 meme for instance, has been something that I've read about mostly on paper where I am more likely to focus on the longer more thoughtful pieces and less likely (frankly because I can't) to jump around from soundbite blog post to soundbite blog post.
Along a somewhat related vein: in anticipation of the most hyped product launch ever, I've been reading "Designing for Small Screens," a book about user interface/interaction design for display-constrained devices. The book is well worth reading if you are interested in this vein of different mediums/different modes of relating to content. It starts from the premise that the visual interface is the most high bandwidth way to consume content and then walks through a number of interface patterns that are useful in maximizing limited real estate. In light of the paper versus screen modalities, you can not help but wonder what mode of relating to content might emerge as these smartphone-like interfaces really do gain mass market traction over the next couple of years.