My goal with this blog

I write about relevant changes in the way that people use the web and how startups are built to provide services and products for this ever changing wonderful thing we still know as "the web." As a former entrepreneur turned early-stage investor, my greatest hope is for this to be useful to other folks that are like me in the hopes that they can avoid some of the mistakes I've made.

Mortar gets spread thin like peanut butter

As I was looking at Techmeme today in order to refresh our sponsorship link, I noticed that the absolute rage this weekend is the "leaked" memo by Yahoo SVP Brad Garlinhouse about how the company has no focus, is too fat, and most importantly, is trying to do too many things at once (and is thus spread "thin like peanut butter"). There must be hundreds of bloggers linking to the 2-3 main threads playing out over this public mea culpa, and for the most part there seems to be consensus around this notion that there are far too many redundancies in the projects that the company is pursuing.

I don't buy it. It's particularly interesting to see this piece come out just two weeks after everyone applauded Ev for relaunching Odeo as a sort of modern-day incubator because of his belief that it was just too hard to predict the hits a priori. Why can't this same reasoning be used to justify the co-existence of Yahoo Photos and Flickr, Delicious and MyWeb? After all, if Ev is right, and the home runs are too hard too spot up front, what a company like Yahoo needs to do is adopt a portfolio model where each property becomes an investment buying for the eyeballs and hours of potential users— to say nothing of the fact that it is not clear that there are not distinct non-overlapping audiences for some of the "competing" properties. They may be too slow to kill off the losers, and the company may in fact be over-run by middle management embahs that lack the cojones required to make big strategic bets, but if the Odeo learning is right, the fundamental portfolio plan for big hits seems pretty sound to me.

Except that I think that part of what is killing Yahoo is that they've gotten themselves cross-wise to the grain of the web. That term comes from Paul Graham's essay defining Web 2.0 when he applied it to describe why success seems so friction-free for Google while other similarly-sized companies (Yahoo) seem to struggle in the brave new Web 2.0 world. Because of their roots, because of this huge Damocles sword hanging over their heads every night at 12:00AM (just one billion page views to go before the clock rolls again!), and maybe even because it is staffed by Hollywood types, Yahoo can't escape this "hits-based" approach to building destinations on the web.

And yet, if there is one thing we can say about Web 2.0 is that to truly add value, people building applications, communities, etc. need to think less like bricks and more like mortar. When the web was new, getting big was all that mattered, and even with the recent MySpace-inspired frenzy, misguided M&A folks have felt that building the biggest pile of bricks was the only path to winning. This notion more than anything else is what is guiding Yahoo's current portfolio model— buying companies and hoping that a few of them can turn out to be big bricks with little in the way of direct investment post-merger and alignment within an overall strategic vision.

Meanwhile Google, with its syndicatable AdWords service and bottomless appetite for crawling even the most miniscule of sites, is showing us again and again that mortar really pays the bills (not necessarily though that they are any better at acquiring companies). Someone recently told me that 40% of requests for YouTube streams are requested from a non-YouTube site (thanks to the embeddable YouTube widget)— a statistic which, if true, is the ultimate affirmation of the services-as-mortar model that Google seems so good at pursuing.

Interestingly, a couple of Yahoo's more popular recent acquisitions have been great mortar plays— Flickr and delicious. The unfortunate thing seems to be that as soon as these little mortar players get under the purple umbrella their mandate seems to change to building big bricks in order to justify the eventual "monetization strategy."

I am sure there are many things currently plaguing Yahoo that have nothing to do with this brick-and-mortar metaphor— I mention it only because it seems to be a decent way to think through a more coherent (and timely) strategy for making something out of the sticky mess that Yahoo is currently facing.