My goal with this blog

I write about relevant changes in the way that people use the web and how startups are built to provide services and products for this ever changing wonderful thing we still know as "the web." As a former entrepreneur turned early-stage investor, my greatest hope is for this to be useful to other folks that are like me in the hopes that they can avoid some of the mistakes I've made.

Beam me up Johnny!

Markoff had the scoop on the next tidalwave of innovation on the Internet with front page puff piece in sunday's New York Times on the coming Web 3.0— a vast interconnected fabric of machines that understand each other and do our bidding so that we can schedule vacations, buy cars, and do all sorts of neat things with preciously little input on our part. Good times.

If you suspend disbelief for a moment on the possibility that you would want to ever have a machine buy me a car or book me a vacation without the level of time that you normally invest in doing those things today, I think the best way to tell that the piece is lightweight— and more importantly that it probably has the predictive power of lottery ticket— is to go into the time machine and look at Apple's Knowledge Navigator concept video from the 1980s and see how much of this Web 3.0 vision is just rehashing a very sexy idea that people trot out (like Sculley did then) when they are lacking a real actionable vision.

To be fair, it probably going to happen someday (along with flying cars and matter replicators) but so far in the future that it seems silly to be writing now about how this is what's coming after Web 2.0. Of all of the discussion that followed the article, my favorite take on it was Ross Mayfield's which simply stated: it's about the people stupid, and not about the super smart computers that reason.

While everyone else was busy working on all sorts of flux capacitor-like algorithms for processing the vast array of data on the web, Google proved that a conceptually simple algorithm for intelligently using key metadata could build enough value to unseat huge incumbents. Even today, the blogosphere gets all abuzz about startups that try to take on ridiculously hard computer science projects and productize them in the short time usually allowed by the venture model (even when it doesn't seem to work) and instead ignore incremental efforts to make what we have better and more usable.

It's easy to understand the power of "the story" around machines that truly reason— after all science fiction has trained us for the last 60 years that this eventuality is going to bring with a whole universe of interesting possibilities— so it's understandable that Markoff would know the Times readers would eat this up. What is not so great is when the air is sucked out of the discussion because of fluffy proclamations about "Web 3.0" and the ensuing raging debate about whether we are there yet or not. It's overload and has three direct casualties that I can see:

  1. There are people out there doing very interesting things around a lot of what could eventually really help the coming of this future that science fiction writers have been writing about, most notably anyone involved in microformats work. These guys are doing great stuff but it's going to be very incremental, and as such, it's important that we neither rush them nor discourage them.

  2. If you pull the bread out of the oven too soon, it simply will not have risen enough and you'll get a gooey mess. Tim O'Reilly's brilliance in coining Web 2.0 wasn't in the what but in the when. For a variety of reasons, he just nailed the timing at exactly the right moment. Peter Rip talks about Noah Spivak's company being "outed" too early which I am sure is not an isolated incident.

  3. While understandable, the shoot-for-the-moon science project approach to big stories can sometimes cause all of us little people who work hard for our coverage to take our eye off the ball (A social photo site that doesn't implement groups for 3 months because there are "cooler" things to do?!?).

We as entrepreneurs, makers, power users, and gadflies need to stay focused on what is achievable and what actually brings value to users in measurable increments of time. From that perspective it might be better if John would stick to covering research labs in universities (which he does mention), or better still, covering something like the transport of matter through information streams.