Ev, who I find to be as intellectually honest as anyone I've ever met in the Internet sphere, has decided that the venture model is not right for Odeo and bought out his investors to create a more experimental, nimbler company. Or perhaps he saw that the podcast runway wasn't quite long enough for the big old airplane his VCs had saddled him to reach V2 and not crash. Either way, it takes balls to do what he is doing and I bet there is more than one funded entrepreneur out there right now scratching his head and saying, wow wouldn't it be nice to try that?
And in some ways it would. But I am a little struck by the fact that what he's doing with the new company (Obvious) is turning it into something that looks a lot like 37Signals. I can understand why 37signals wanted to do this— as a consulting shop without outside capital, they had little other choice. But for a company with no consulting clients to disengage and enough capital in the bank, setting up a "lab-like" structure with the general mandate "build webapps" seems to be a strange choice.
There is great benefit to come from focus, especially for those projects that require more than 2 engineers and 3 days. And external constraints are a good thing for creativity— even the best artists tell you that the clashes between the limitations of their medium and their intent is where most of the good stuff happens. Without deadlines and ship dates (the website kind not the packaged software kind), or external dependencies to other parts of a company (marketing/biz dev./the BOD), it's hard to see how any constraints can be enforced. The lab thing smells of the R&D labs of places like Microsoft and Yahoo (though supposedly Google has cracked the code on how to do this right) and it makes me wonder whether the outcome might not be similar— lots of smoke and no fire.
In looking for the why? behind this new structure, I found this part of his blog post:
Nearly everyone I know in the Internet business is either at one of the giants, wishing they were at a startup, or at a startup that hopes get bought by a giant. ...and later... The consumer web is increasingly hits-driven and increasingly crowded, which makes it more difficult to predict what's going to work.
to be most telling.
Ev is describing the Hollywood model where a studio backs two dozen movies in the hopes that one will hit it big and cover all of the flops. The way I see it, he's basically saying: no one can tell what the difference between a Star Wars and an Ishtar is but we know we want a hit with the consumers, so we've got to try a lot of stuff. I sort of agree with his statement that it's hard to know ahead of time what the megahits are going to be— but I am bummed to see that in this day and age of cheap innovation on the web, we're all stuck with the hits-driven model.
Why? Because, first of all, getting to 10MM users should not be the only path to success. And secondly, a web service is not like a studio movie in one critical way: if it sucks at launch, the web as a medium allows you to rip it apart and put it back together so that it does work for its natural audience. A movie is a piece of media you finish and ship— a website is a process of learning from your users and the limits of your medium.
I think this unfortunate mindset comes back to business models. We're back in the eyeballs game except that now the world is dominated AdWords which means that it's even less profitable than it used to not to be at some large enough scale where you can afford to own (or be owned by someone who owns) the ad network. And without the opportunity for other types of business models that work at lesser scales, everyone is going to be stuck going for the next MySpace or hoping to fool some big megacorp into thinking that there might be a small chance that they will someday become the next MySpace.
An example of the opportunities this mentality squelches: I liked Odeo a lot— I thought there were a lot of things that they did which were much better than what iTunes did. As a paying member of Audible (a much worse website for finding and acquiring audio), I would have gladly switched over to pay for an Odeo premium subscription if they had just added some more types of licensed content. Now I realize that people don't generally like to think of subscriptions as a viable business model on the web today but one good thing about charging for a service is that revenue grows linearly with the user base which means that the business doesn't have to get to 10 million actives before it can make some nice money. Ditto for e-commerce models, or mass-customized output models.
Good luck to the Obvious guys— but let's hope that as part of the experimentation, the play around with some of the businessmodel constraints that got them there in the first place.