This was an interesting find on John Battelle's blog about the different amounts spent on R&D by companies like Microsoft, IBM, Google, and Apple. It's not the first time I've seen something like this where companies that get the lion's share of regular people's oohs and ahhs spend disproportionately little on R&D. In fact I remember when Steve came back to Apple and started hacking costs, one of the first things that went were a lot of these R&D project which caused some Wall Street Journal reporter to write a piece about how this was going to be short-term smart/ long-term stupid. Mind you this was before Apple did Wi-Fi, the iPod, the iTMS, video editing for everyone, or just about any of the incredible things they've done since then.
John argues that the data, being from Microsoft, is self-serving and under-reports Google's spend, but I think that there is something else going on here.Spending cash on R&D when there are no huge leaps to be made but instead incremental hops mostly punctuated by the commercialization of technology seems to be sort of a waste, and worse still, a distraction. The latter comes from the fact that the product groups at these big behemoths (MSFT, IBM) seem to be relieved of the responsibility of truly innovating because someone from the "R&D department" is supposed to be doing it. Maybe I am limited in my understanding of how much future-tense R&D shops can deliver, but when the engineering teams can come up with clever hacks like these, and when it's not clear what the last major R&D innovation Microsoft or IBM commercialized successfully, something certainly seems broken.
Then again, I've also just seen this new Photosynth project from Microsoft that seems really interesting and worth exploring further. That said, there is always an example afoot of how these new-fangled technologies can go awry as did the speech recognition in Vista just last week.