It's pretty clear now that looking for product information on the web is a Killer App that has no equal with general users (except for possibly email). Which is why I am astounded that we still don't have the equivalent of a Froogle for product reviews. Sure, there was Epinions back in the day and there are also a number of new Web 2.0 comparison shopping sites that claim they are going to extend their reach into reviews, but none of these quite work because they don't live inside of my search engine.
I just finished writing up a review of a pair of Mion Current outdoor sandals that I got (despite not being able to turn up any reviews on them in Google), and I'm fairly sure that because I wanted to include pictures and therefore used Tabblo, I'm not going to see this review popping to the top of any search engine anytime soon.
Here is all that I would like:
Google, instead of doing all of these Microsoft office-killing apps (some of which I like), create a separate entry point into "reviews" and give me a search engine for reviews. Crawl Amazon, crawl the blogs, crawl anything you want- hell you are already doing that- but just make sure to present me with an interface that lets me sort through reviews really quickly, to rate them, and if you're feeling Web 2.0 to add to them if the feeling moves me.
There is hardly a day that goes by that I don't find myself typing "XXX review" only to have to sort out a bunch of junk I don't care about from the general Google search. Solving this problem can't be any harder than Google News which seems to be working pretty well these days.
And no, I don't want to use some standalone site- frankly I don't think any startup would be able to get enough scale (hype around "vertical search engines" notwithstanding) to cover anything and everything. And I certainly don't want to have to go run multiple searches: i.e., Google, Amazon, Technorati, just to get decent coverage. I just want the most comprehensive list of reviews you can give me.
C'mon, Google, how cool would "Google Reviews" be? And if not you, then maybe Yahoo, the "social search" company can jump on this one.