I really dig digg. I remember being at our VC's offices the day that the deal came in and thinking only one thing: wow this is going to be the end of Slashdot. But Seth Godin has recently written a brief but interesting piece about the challenges facing everyone's new media darling these days. In short, he argues that Digg is about the diggers and not so much about the larger community of readers that Kevin & co. like to talk about when the cite 900K uniques per day.
The problem with the diggers according to Seth? They are a "legion," an elite, and as such you have to treat them with kid gloves and manage them like talent. In my opinion, the real problem is that Digg as a site is built around too few publishers doing too little work to build the "media experience." To take an extreme on the other end, compare the diggers to your average World of Warcraft player and think for a moment: who is more likely to move elsewhere in the event that the guy running the hosting platform pulls a fast one? If I'm a digger, all I've invested in learning is the old thumbs-up/thumbs-down deal. How hard can this be to port to Reddit? If I'm a WoW player though, I know about my guild, I know about the 5 second rule, and most of all, I know a lot about the creative investment that I've made in my character(s).
If you're going to make a new media property, and if you're going to call it sticky, it seems to me that it makes sense to understand the nature of the creative investment you expect your users to make. Now, digg that!