My goal with this blog

I write about relevant changes in the way that people use the web and how startups are built to provide services and products for this ever changing wonderful thing we still know as "the web." As a former entrepreneur turned early-stage investor, my greatest hope is for this to be useful to other folks that are like me in the hopes that they can avoid some of the mistakes I've made.

Practice Good Platform Independence Hygene

I've been following the raging debate around the alpha geeks who are dumping OSX for Ubuntu (and the beta geeks who are making a stink about following them) with some of the same detached interest that I save for the Ruby-Python debate or the emacs-vi throwdown of yesteryear. Mostly because there are only two good points being made over and over again, with the rest of the chatter being just line noise.

The whole thing started when Mark Pilgrim (who writes as well as he thinks and thinks very well) wrote about how he was switching to Linux from OSX due to Apple's braindead proprietary data formats in their iLife suite. And herein is great point #1: proprietary data formats suck, especially as more and more of your critical information (photos, movies, music) migrates on to your computer. You will always run into some kind of artificial roadblock that the vendor (in this case Apple) cares little about helping you with because when you're running into the problem, it is either because you want to leave their "ecosystem" or too far in the future for it to be worth their worry.

The important thing to keep in mind though is that Mark is talking about metadata that is being locked up in a propietary way, not actual data. Yes it would suck to lose your iTunes playlists, and your iPhoto albums/tags/comments, but it definitely would suck a lot more to lose all of your data due to lock-in (hello Outlook at PST fans!?!), and at least thus far, Apple has been good about keeping that data visible and transparent to common filesystem tools. While they keep that up, I think they've still got the best platform out there.

Why? Because of point #2: running Linux on a desktop/laptop blows, plain and simple. The debate raging in the blogosphere would be a lot more information-rich if Technorati provided a filter that let you remove posts from anyone who has never actually run Linux on a laptop before, and by running it, I mean using it as their main OS in day to day activity. I did it for two years (about three years ago) and I can honestly say that the only way you could talk about it favorably is if you were suffering from Stockholm syndrome. It's just no fun to deal with power management (especially around suspend/resume), video issues, font issues, and wireless networking issues. True, Ubuntu has made great strides, but having recently installed it on an IBM T43, I can still see all of the same holes that have always existed around "user-centered Linux distros," the main one being around the way that GUI configurators and the textfiles they twiddle can get out of state and send you right into a commandline/manpage hell. This is ok for ifconfig (because you should know this anyway) but for X? for apm? C'mon, almost anyone has better things to do with their time. (Rob Flickenger has the best blogpost outlining the issues as to why Linux is just not viable and he touches on a number of things that I don't mention here for those who are curious).

So, what to do? Get ready to lose your metadata (read: don't invest a lot of energy in it) and make sure you practice good platform independence hygene for the possible moment when Apple drives us all off the cliff. Learn how the iApps store your data, and get really cozy with rsync and ssh (investing time in these two tools will pay off for far longer than investing energy into configuring X fonts or Alsa sound drivers). I used to think that good platform independence hygene meant not using applications that weren't available on all platforms which is the main reason why I kept running all those buggy versions of Aqua Emacs but after years of pain I finally said basta! and got on the Cocoa groove train. Now I live in TextMate and NetNewsWire and am fully expecting the coming withdrawal that may come someday. I'm not sure it's worth punishing yourself now for true platform independence.

Anyhow, I realize this debate has probably been spent (for now anyway, as it seems to come back every six months) but I figured it would make a good Independence day post, so happy 4th!