A recent Tech Crunch piece on a new photo sharing service called BubbleShare has got everyone excited about the power of simplicity. Bubbleshare amounts to a very thin (mostly email-based) interface for gathering collections of photos as "albums," along with a very nice set of DHTML effects (all built of the marvelous scriptaculous Javascript library).
Here is the good: BS has a wonderful out-of-the-box upload experience. You can get your stuff up there without a laborious account signup process that requires you to enter in every last bit of info only to then wait for an email with a too-long-for-its-own-good confirmation URL that you have to click on to get started. The BS team clearly worked hard to get this part right and it really shows.
Here is the bad: this is not an application but an applet, or perhaps better yet an tinyplet. In BS I don't have a notion of a library except for a bunch of emails in my inbox with byzantine Dewey Decimal style URLs that are also too long for their own good. There is no notion of permissions and sharing is limited to "forward this cool link to your friends" which, while great for videos of martial arts mishaps, doesn't map to the semi-private way in which most folks want to share photos (and security through obscurity can only take you so far).
And worst of all, despite the nice page title "Tell your story", BS provides very little in the way of tools to really tell stories. Where are the rich templates that incorporate text as a first-class citizen? Where are the picture editing (think crop not Photoshop) tools that really allow you to leverage the power of images? And where are all of the cool ways to tell stories online that folks have been dreaming up for some time now? And most importantly, where is the community?
Having dug around the site a bit, I realize that the BS folks were working with a role model in mind:
When we set out to build BubbleShare, the first question we asked ourselves that I can remember was: “If Google created a photo sharing service, what would it look like?”
But Google is mostly search, not expressive tools for personal publishing. To me this is like saying: if Cisco built a photo-sharing site, what would it look like? And you can bet that if Blogger (which is Google after all) had set out to build a photo sharing service it would most certainly not look like this. Because in BS there is precious little opportunity for context on the part of the story-teller and blogging in general is all about story-telling in context. Whereas I might spend six hours tweaking my Wordpress template, in BS there is no chance for a creative investment.
There is this general trend with all of these Web 2.0 companies to minimize the interface to the point where we're back to 1995 CGIs with two form elements and nothing else (witness the recent Odeo makeover). While I am a big fan of a lot of the tenets of Web 2.0, this is not one of them. Instead, I'd like my webapps to provide me with an interface that I can learn. Sure, let me do the basics fast and make it dead-dumb simple (as someone from the PC era once told me, the key is to get the user to a moment of absolute pleasure within 5 minutes). But then give me enough depth to sink my teeth in, to learn by struggling with the app, and to be rewarded when after struggling my creative investment pays off in something that really lets me express myself.
We're not dummies that either get a blank page with two form elements or click away to the latest Hollywood drivel. We want to be challenged, and if we're going to switch photo sharing sites, or start using them over email attachments at all, it better be because they really make something possible which just wasn't before.