So Joel (from Joel on Software), who just barely missed the cut for my sidebar, asks a very similar question to one I often ponder when I think of the east coast and the west coast in terms of good startup activity in the online space. He is griping about NYC-versus-Boston when he writes:
Is New York just lame compared to Boston? Or does it just seem that way? Why is that... is it because of MIT? or all the other high tech stuff going on there?
It's good to see this, because it makes me feel a little silly to often ask the question in the context of Boston-versus-Silicon Valley. Having just worked in New York for two years, and having just recently raised money in Boston, I feel qualified in saying that it really is no worse in New York than in Boston, and that in fact when it comes to media-related businesses it's actually better.
That said, it is still tough to find folks in Boston on the investment side of things that will take the big swings with that same level of nonchalance that you get from your typical west coast VC. In general I don't find this to be a huge impediment, but sometimes you see start-ups which try to squeeze themselves into a certain unnatural shapes for the sake of potential investors. The cost of this is an inability to stay loose and playful, two elements which seem to be so critical to the experimentation that allowed the west coast to take the torch from the east as soon as the PC wave hit.
However, the bigger problem is not with the investors or sources of talent per se, but rather with the fact that we are lacking a cabal of folks who can get together to bat ideas around without an explicit agenda. This was one of my favorite things about the culture out at Stanford when I lived there and it seems to be sorely missing here. Most of the events that I have been too are either tediously forced (where people with nothing more than raw ambition bump into each other, much like amoebas trying to recombine into higher lifeforms) or totally out of touch with the real cool and interesting stuff.
This is why, as Joel points out, Y Combinator may be such a special place-- if indeed Paul Graham's experiment can be made to take off.
In the meanwhile, I may take some airtime here to try to puzzle this out. And given that we've had 10 straight days of rain I might start with the climatological argument-- that is, maybe our shitty weather keeps us all locked away inside instead of out of doors bumping into each other between the rollerblading, biking, and tofu burrito munching.